#13: Chris Yarran

[Ned_Flanders]

I didn't suggest that. I was clearly taking the piss. I even used the sarcasm face didn't I?

Edit: what crap about players getting treatment outside the club. That's a fact. Not all players. Some players. Mostly retired players now. I would assume it still happens.

You should actually know that a GP can refer you for a mental health plan and then refer you to a psychologist or another professional who then diagnoses you with anxiety or depression or psychosis or whatever else the issue is.

I know this has happened - player told me years ago about how he went to an outside doc because he was concerned if the club learned the possible diagnosis it would be career over

naive to think it still doesnt happen, esp in the areas of mental illness and substance abuse

 

[Livonski]

This whole Yarran thing is unseemly.

Too much chat about something people don't know about and I include those who have gone through similar who are critical.

It's an individual journey.

How good would it be if he did his knee in preseason and we had the metrics of what that entails because it's a more easily known.

Just leave it alone because it makes everyone look a fool.

Very well said.

 

[Mall Grab]

okay, so we have an approved list of doctors now? how do we determine what is an approved doctor, and how do you intend to tell the AMA (one of the strongest unions in Australia) that you are boycotting their members?

On the second, you're the git for this suggestion. firstly you're assuming clubs monitor and constantly evaluate players for mental illness to have these records. does that mean we wont trade with any club without these records? secondly if the records are bad, why would the club hand then over?

and wait.... as a poster already told you, doctor patient records are confidential - the club cannot hand them over to us without the players permission, and I can 100% guarantee the AFLPA would be instructing all its members to reject such requests

suggest you stop drinking, put the laptop down, and go back to pub keno

How did you jump to the conclusion that I'm making that assumption?

And rejecting a request for a player's medical background is a warning sign in itself. You do realise that players often send their medical history to clubs that are looking to sign them as it can actually help facilitate the transfer, especially if they've had no serious injuries. But wait, you can 100% guarantee me that the AFLPA advise against it? F***ing lol. It can be beneficial for both parties if that kind of information is transferred.

 

[Mall Grab]

I didn't suggest that. I was clearly taking the piss. I even used the sarcasm face didn't I?

Edit: what crap about players getting treatment outside the club. That's a fact. Not all players. Some players. Mostly retired players now. I would assume it still happens.

You should actually know that a GP can refer you for a mental health plan and then refer you to a psychologist or another professional who then diagnoses you with anxiety or depression or psychosis or whatever else the issue is.

Zzzzzzzzz.

Read over my last post. You're not even arguing against some of the stuff I'm saying.

 

[theflea]

And there would be nothing suss about Yarran supplying a medical certificate from a bulk billing doctor in Broadmeadows saying he has no mental illness.

Carlton would have his medical records you git. They would sign it off. If he doesn't go through Carlton he would have to pay for it himself, which I highly doubt he would've done.

Carlton don't own a players records, as if this was the case the clubs would know about drug strikes.

 

[Tiger71]

Zzzzzzzzz.

Read over my last post. You're not even arguing against some of the stuff I'm saying.

Your blue jumper and scarf are showing. Stop trying so hard. The good trolls use subtle lube bait, you are just going in dry.

I love reading your troll bait but if you use lube I can still drink a brandy and have a smoke after reading your posts.

 

[Sassafras]

Your blue jumper and scarf are showing. Stop trying so hard. The good trolls use subtle lube bait, you are just going in dry.

I love reading your troll bait but if you use lube I can still drink a brandy and have a smoke after reading your posts.

Why do you call anyone that disagrees with you non Richmond?

 

[TigerBelle]

As someone who does have depression, it's pretty easy to tell the doctor/pscyh want they want to hear - diagnosing mental illness is only possible in extreme cases or if the patient is honest with themselves and to the doctor. Interviewing players can only get you so far.

I hope you are doing ok
All the very best!

 

[Tiger71]

Why do you call anyone that disagrees with you non Richmond?

Pick one post I have done that before?

Let me know when you have boomer

 

[Ned_Flanders]

How did you jump to the conclusion that I'm making that assumption?

And rejecting a request for a player's medical background is a warning sign in itself. You do realise that players often send their medical history to clubs that are looking to sign them as it can actually help facilitate the transfer, especially if they've had no serious injuries. But wait, you can 100% guarantee me that the AFLPA advise against it? F***ing lol. It can be beneficial for both parties if that kind of information is transferred.

there is a big difference between revealing info on a known injury and an unknown

players have disclosed injuries from clubs for years

 

[Tiges1229]

Can't pick depression , my old man told me he covered it up for years until it got to much and he got help .
Just last year guy I do business with killed hkmsekf , 48 years old , 2 kids , successful etc . Week before I went to lunch with him and I had nfi .

 

[Mall Grab]

there is a big difference between revealing info on a known injury and an unknown

players have disclosed injuries from clubs for years

Of course, but my point is if someone like Chris Yarran does not disclose his medical information, you'd surely be a bit more hesitant about pursuing the signing.

And when I say someone like Chris Yarran, I mean someone who's off field issues have been well documented.

 

[Mall Grab]

Your blue jumper and scarf are showing. Stop trying so hard. The good trolls use subtle lube bait, you are just going in dry.

I love reading your troll bait but if you use lube I can still drink a brandy and have a smoke after reading your posts.

Geez. I won't ever PM you with my info again.

 

[Sassafras]

Pick one post I have done that before?

Let me know when you have boomer

The one I quoted, also you have suggested it to me, and many others.

And actually reply this time.

 

[partycorolla]

I know this has happened - player told me years ago about how he went to an outside doc because he was concerned if the club learned the possible diagnosis it would be career over

naive to think it still doesnt happen, esp in the areas of mental illness and substance abuse

That's what I was talking about. I know of at least 3 players and 1 umpire who went outside their club or AFL doctors (for physical ailments).

 

[Tiger71]

The one I quoted, you have suggested to me, and many others.

Many others?

Show me. You see I could do what some others do and speak what I think via a alt account but I don't do it as to me that is gutless.

So boomer, you have accused me of many times calling trolls out so show me? To my knowledge it's only been less then a handful of times in the 5 years I've been active. Hardly many

 

[partycorolla]

Zzzzzzzzz.

Read over my last post. You're not even arguing against some of the stuff I'm saying.

Off to bed champ. You stuffed up with your posts or point (whatever it was).

 

[Tiger71]

Geez. I won't ever PM you with my info again.

lol you have never PM me or maybe you have on another account?

 

[Sassafras]

Many others?

Show me. You see I could do what some others do and speak what I think via a alt account but I don't do it as to me that is gutless.

So boomer, you have accused me of many times calling trolls out so show me? To my knowledge it's only been less then a handful of times in the 5 years I've been active. Hardly many

Truth be told I fess up when wrong...I have seen you state "use your main account" which my simple mind associated with 'troll', sorry.

One serious question....

What is with the Boomer/NM theory you have? I seriously don't care about the suggestion, but more interested considering I can't stand them.

 

[Tiger71]

Truth be told I fess up when wrong...I have seen you state "use your main account" which my simple mind associated with 'troll', sorry.

One serious question....

What is with the Boomer/NM theory you have? I seriously don't care about the suggestion, but more interested considering I can't stand them.

Not to derail the thread but just for the record. I have never called you troll myself. As to the Norf stuff it is just when you started some thought you were a norf lover and my use of boomer was a vein attempt at wit and humor, surprised you missed it .

You mentioned " reply this time". I always reply when quoted if I missed a question from you prior, it was not intentional.

 

[Nostradumbass]

lol you have never PM me or maybe you have on another account?

He got banned on his other account. Can't remember who he was, to be honest.

 

[Mall Grab]

lol you have never PM me or maybe you have on another account?

Gosha

 

[Sassafras]

Not to derail the thread but just for the record. I have never called you troll myself. As to the Norf stuff it is just when you started some thought you were a norf lover and my use of boomer was a vein attempt at wit and humor, surprised you missed it .

You mentioned " reply this time". I always reply when quoted if I missed a question from you prior, it was not intentional.

Ok, I got the humour from you but the others felt a little straight faced. To be honest I don't care but for what it's worth (sadly) I'm Richmond.

 

[Laffy2Chaffey2Daffy]

Yeah I think you've butchered that one. Nice try though.

Just joshing ya, dude.

To be honest I don't care but for what it's worth (sadly) I'm Richmond.

its something you are, not something you choose.

 

[Sassafras]

Just joshing ya, dude.
its something you are, not something you choose.

I chose Richmond becuase I liked a sticker on a car in the 90s.