2007 Player Votes - R1

[Kildonan]

All welcome

This year's player of the year thread will again be run by Sainter and StKildonan.

Voting will be Top 5 players on a 5-4-3-2-1 votes basis

We will accept other combinations as long as the highest vote is 5 points and the total number of votes cast does not exceed 15 pts

i.e. N. Riewoldt 5, N. Dal Santo 5, L. Ball 4, B. Voss 1.

No half points will be accepted.

This is specifically for St Kilda supporters, but foreign team supporters will be accepted (but their votes will be devalued if there is a tie).

All Saints supporters are encouraged to contribute, you do not need to have seen the game "live".

Votes will be tallied and presented in a table in another thread entitled "Player of the Year Table".

This thread will be updated Thursday nights - so get your votes in before then.

 

[bluejay]

Re: Player Votes

Thanks StKildonan. I will try to post my votes (as it's already usual) before thursday every week, if by then I have managed to watch the previous weekend game. I hope I won't miss voting in many of them. Playing on friday will help me a lot on Round1, hehe.

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

Re: Player Votes

5. L.Montagna
4. X.Clarke
3. S.Baker
2. F.Gehrig
1. J.Blake

 

[Kildonan]

Re: Player Votes

4 F. Gehrig
3 X. Clarke
3 L. Montagna
3 B. Goddard
1 A. Fiora
1 L. Fisher

 

[DanA]

Re: Player Votes

4. X.Clarke
3. B.Goddard
3. F.Gehrig
2. L.Montagna
2. A.Fiora
1. J.Attard

Attard kept Davey to 5 or so possesions, good effort
Too many missed opportunities and Clangers from Montagna to get big votes

 

[bergholt]

Re: Player Votes

F Gehrig - 5
X Clarke - 4
L Montagna - 2
B Goddard - 1
J Attard - 1
J Blake - 1
A Fiora - 1

 

[Fehring]

Re: Player Votes

5. Gehrig
4. X Clarke
3. BJ
2. Joey Montagna
1. S Fisher

 

[Falchoon]

Re: Player Votes

5 Montagna
4 Clarke
3 Goddard
2 Gehrig
1 Fiora

 

[Big Member]

Re: Player Votes

4 Gehrig
3 Montagna
3 Goddard
1 Baker
1 Attard
1 Clarke
1 Fisher
1 Fiora

 

[St DAC]

Re: Player Votes

4. Gehrig
3. Montagna
3. Goddard
2. X Clarke
1. S Fisher
1. Fiora
1. M Clarke

 

[Kildonan]

Re: Player Votes

4 Gehrig
3 Montagna
3 Goddard
1 Baker
1 Attard
1 Clarke
1 Fisher
1 Fiora

Sam or Leigh ??

 

[sainter]

Re: Player Votes

Thanks StKildonan. I will try to post my votes (as it's already usual) before thursday every week, if by then I have managed to watch the previous weekend game. I hope I won't miss voting in many of them. Playing on friday will help me a lot on Round1, hehe.

We can't really mention about downloading games on here but our game is available.

I was at the game but I generally like to watch a replay before giving my votes.

 

[bluejay]

Re: Player Votes

I actually can, sainter (I think), as long as I don't say from where . Is really the AFL gonna try to detain me here in Spain, or should I download their telstra/bigpond crappy service (believe me, I tried and payed in the past)?

Having said this, here come my votes:

5.Gehrig
4.X.Clarke
3.Goddard
1.Harvey
1.Montagna
1.Baker

 

[sainter]

Re: Player Votes

I actually can, sainter (I think), as long as I don't say from where . Is really the AFL gonna try to detain me here in Spain, or should I download their telstra/bigpond crappy service (believe me, I tried and payed in the past)?

Haha, that's fine by me.

I'm hoping the quality is good. The guy who uploaded it generally does a good job.

 

[The Punter]

Re: Player Votes

5 Gehrig
4 Montagna
3 X Clarke
2 M Clarke
1 Blake

 

[Big Member]

Re: Player Votes

Sam or Leigh ??

Sorry, Leigh Fisher and Xavier Clarke!!!

 

[foxy_dal]

5.gehrig
4.x clarke
3.fiora
2.montagna
1.dal santo

 

[sainter]

4 - Gehrig
3 - Montagna
3 - X Clarke
2 - Goddard
1 - Baker
1 - Attard
1 - Fiora

 

[Bourky23]

5 - Gehrig
4 - Montagna
3 - X. Clarke
2 - Fiora
1 - Goddard

 

[Oh When the Saints]

5. X. Clarke
4. F. Gehrig
3. S. Baker
2. L. Montagna
1. J. Attard

 

[PHX]

5. X.Clark
4. Goddard
4. Gehrig
1. Montagna
1. Fiora

 

[HoldenMCaulfield]

4 - F Gehrig
4 - X Clarke
3 - N dal Santo
3 - L Montagna
1 - S Baker

 

[JeffDunne]

5 - B. Goddard
4 - X. Clarke
3 - F. Gehrig
2 - L. Montagna
1 - S. Fisher

 

[MCG-Unit]

4 - Clarke X
3 - Gehrig
3 - Goddard
3 - Fisher L
2 - Montagna