2008 phantom draft

[Bloods boy from the Bush]

44. Adelaide - Jake Walsh -196cm, 96kg –Northern Knights
62. Sydney - Jake Walsh -196cm, 96kg –Northern Knights

Hmmm think you may want to have another crack.

 

[giantroo]

There is no way we will pick up Shaun Mac with our first pick. We are crying out for midfielders and Zeibel,Sidebottom and Blease look the most likely to be the ones our club is/are after.

But don't right us off getting another pick in the first round. Maybe pick up another midfielder.

 

[hendo8888]

McKernan went to Sydney mate
you got Ziebell

 

[Vader]

10. Adelaide - Lewis Johnston – 192cm, 87kg – North Adelaide
28. Adelaide - Ryan Schoenmakers – 189cm, 85kg – Norwood
44. Adelaide - Jake Walsh -196cm, 96kg –Northern Knights
60. Adelaide - Bart McCulloch – 198cm, 83kg – South Launceston

Crows look like the land of the giants. Not saying it's impossible (we probably will be going tall this year), but slipping one midfielder in there wouldn't have hurt.

 

[Souup]

There is no way we will pick up Shaun Mac with our first pick. We are crying out for midfielders and Zeibel,Sidebottom and Blease look the most likely to be the ones our club is/are after.

But don't right us off getting another pick in the first round. Maybe pick up another midfielder.

I've got the feeling we will.. just coz he's a Mckernan

We better not though..

 

[myers_23]

1st Round:
9. North - Jack Ziebell – 188cm, 84kg – Murray Bushrangers

A few points...
Your name is Ziebell
You go for Richmond
You just signed up
Yet you have Ziebell going to North a pick after Richmonds pick??

This does not make sense..

 

[giantroo]

McKernan went to Sydney mate
you got Ziebell

Just talking about it in general because people think just because he is a McKernan, that we will pick him up with our first pick.

Well if we did pick up Ziebell ,i'm a very happy man.

 

[giantroo]

I've got the feeling we will.. just coz he's a Mckernan

We better not though..

I'm sure they'll do the right thing and fix our issues before picking him up.

 

[Portia]

Can you elaborate on this? 182cm is not that small. Taller than Masten and Palmer

Because he's in that second tier of players, not "almost top 3". On a level with players of types that clubs desperately need and are looking for, he'll drop to the bottom.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Why shouldn't O'Keefe go that high? What issues do you have with his game?

Nothing.. I rate other players higher then him though..

 

[sinepari]

Nothing.. I rate other players higher then him though..

or is it because the BigFooty consensus is 2nd round?

 

[Cruiser23]

Nothing.. I rate other players higher then him though..

Just wondering, because there has to be some reason why you think he'll go in Round 2. If you don't have issues with his game then wouldn't he be much higher up in your rankings?

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Just wondering, because there has to be some reason why you think he'll go in Round 2. If you don't have issues with his game then wouldn't he be much higher up in your rankings?

There is no issues.
I just dont think he will slip into the 1st rounds as I rate other players higher.

Just my oppinion.

 

[sinepari]

If you rate others higher, then surely there's some form of 'issue'?

 

[Cruiser23]

If you rate others higher, then surely there's some form of 'issue'?

Exactly, that's what i'm trying to get across, every player has issues, some more than others. There has to be a reason why a person rates that player where they do.

 

[wixism]

1 melbourne Jack watts because david neits is gone and need a forward
2 west coast Daniel rich with daniel keer and other midfeilders retired there will need rich
3 fremantle Nick naitanui with robbie warnock gone there will pick him up
4 port adielade hamish hartlett because south austrsalian boy and good midfeilder
5 essendon tyrone vickery with lloyd lucas nearly gone and laycock shit lol there would want a tall or a forward
6 carlton michal hurly with carlton got no backman there would want a dual under 18 championship full back in there team to be the next full back of the club
7 brisbane jack ziebial pretty good player people rate him highley runs of half back and a midfeilder to and ppl recon he will come 5th
8 richmond chris yarren with richo nearly retired and richmond forward line pretty weak there would want chris yarren a strong forward player sho plays seniors allready and will suit richmods forward allready
9 collingwood jackson trengrove 196cm player can play back or forward and was impressive start of year but i got a minor injury late in the carnival people rate him highly with collingwood players like presti and wakelin retiring soon we would want a full back player or a forward if michal hurly is still in draft will pick him up or will probly get mckernen or if we want a midfeilder will get mitch robinson
10 kangaroos shaun mckernen or mitch robinson
11 sydney shaun mckernen with peter evritt gone and mckernen a pretty good ruckman will suit darren jollys back up ruckman well or there will get mitch robinson

 

[wixism]

sorry forgot bout order dont worry bout it

Cbf bout others lol

 

[bombers15]

zeibell to essendon we need a young midfielder and will fit it well with his run

 

[Warwick]

1 melbourne Jack watts because david neits is gone and need a forward
2 west coast Daniel rich with daniel keer and other midfeilders retired there will need rich
3 fremantle Nick naitanui with robbie warnock gone there will pick him up
4 port adielade hamish hartlett because south austrsalian boy and good midfeilder
5 essendon tyrone vickery with lloyd lucas nearly gone and laycock shit lol there would want a tall or a forward
6 carlton michal hurly with carlton got no backman there would want a dual under 18 championship full back in there team to be the next full back of the club
7 brisbane jack ziebial pretty good player people rate him highley runs of half back and a midfeilder to and ppl recon he will come 5th
8 richmond chris yarren with richo nearly retired and richmond forward line pretty weak there would want chris yarren a strong forward player sho plays seniors allready and will suit richmods forward allready
9 collingwood jackson trengrove 196cm player can play back or forward and was impressive start of year but i got a minor injury late in the carnival people rate him highly with collingwood players like presti and wakelin retiring soon we would want a full back player or a forward if michal hurly is still in draft will pick him up or will probly get mckernen or if we want a midfeilder will get mitch robinson
10 kangaroos shaun mckernen or mitch robinson
11 sydney shaun mckernen with peter evritt gone and mckernen a pretty good ruckman will suit darren jollys back up ruckman well or there will get mitch robinson

Somebody shoot me.

 

[Cruiser23]

Somebody shoot me.

Got to start somewhere i guess

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Somebody shoot me.

x 2

 

[Burzum]

ok guyz watchd a few vidz on utube so i think i can make a fare asesment of these playas

here my top 5

1. jack wats because dees dnt have 2 many tall fwds
2. daniel rich cuz hes a gud mid wit a nice kik
3. nik natanui cuz hes da best talent here n hez a freek
4. tyrone vikery prob cuz lade is old n brogan is old 2
5. michael hurley donz lose mal michael n fletch is getn old so i rekon hed be a gud replacement

 

[dominguez]

ok guyz watchd a few vidz on utube so i think i can make a fare asesment of these playas

here my top 5

1. jack wats because dees dnt have 2 many tall fwds
2. daniel rich cuz hes a gud mid wit a nice kik
3. nik natanui cuz hes da best talent here n hez a freek
4. tyrone vikery prob cuz lade is old n brogan is old 2
5. michael hurley donz lose mal michael n fletch is getn old so i rekon hed be a gud replacement

 

[monna]

Alot of people seem to have Mitch Robinson going to the Kangaroos @ pick 9. Is there any logic to this? Having played against Mitch, i wouldn't be very happy if the Kangaroos picked him up @ 9. Surely one of Zeibell/Hartlett/Sidebottom will slip to pick 9, and i'm pretty sure the kangas will be after one of those. Having said that, if he slipped to pick 27, i'd be glad to take him.

 

[monna]

Kangaroos definately won't pick up Mckernan, or if they do, they are really stupid. Good talent but with Petrie, McIntosh, Hale and Goldstein he doesn't fit our needs at all.