Opinion 2009 Top 50 Players

[AG]

Mitch Clark - extremely promising, however, but he isn't the second best ruckman in the league, and certainly isn't only 4 spots behind Sandilands, considering McIntosh missed out on the Top 50 all together.

I think he has been. Who do you think is the second best ruckman this year?

O'Keefe - Has been solid, but at #23, there have been PLENTY better playing similar position.

Probably too high. I wouldn't say there are plenty ahead of him though.

 

[PLP4ever]

To leave avlich out of the top 50 players is a joke. He has had an off year but it is still better than most on the list. He is in the top 25 players for sure, especially since Adam selwood is on the list.

 

[AG]

To leave avlich out of the top 50 players is a joke. He has had an off year but it is still better than most on the list. He is in the top 25 players for sure, especially since Adam selwood is on the list.

Thanks for coming.

 

[Pykie]

I think he has been. Who do you think is the second best ruckman this year?


Probably too high. I wouldn't say there are plenty ahead of him though.

Well McIntosh and Clarks stats read almost identical accross the board, yet one is in the top 30 or so players, and the other doesn't even make the top 50.


And you placed Jolly in between them.


Doesn't make alot of sense to me tbh.


Its either,


- Mcintosh in a similar position to Clark.

- Clark out of the Top 50.

- if 2/3 make it, according to your rankings, it should be Clark and McIntosh, with McIntosh having performed stastically very similar to Clark this year, whom you have 10 spots higher than Jolly.


Personally; I think you got Sandilands spot about right, however id definately have Clark out, he probably had the best patch of any ruckman this season, however the other 3 have had far more consistent seasons imo.

Id have Jolly and McIntosh in the 40's somewhere.

 

[PLP4ever]

Wel, I am back. Don't dismiss Pavlich's contribution this year. He has been a lot better than many on the list. If the Dockers had more arounf him to support him and finished higher on the ladder he would be a shoe in. And for what it's worth, I would throw tarrant in the top 50 as well.

 

[AG]

I rate the ruckman as Sandilands, Clark, Jolly, McIntosh in order. I only took McIntosh out this week so he could slot back in at no.50 instead of Cooney.
Pavlich is close but not top 50 and defintely not top 25. At his best he is top 10 material but he has had a patchy season.

 

[Barnzy]

Yeah, you're right with your comment before AG, Deledio will probably win his 2nd B&F. I would have him in over Cooney but it's line ball for sure. I also think SJ is probably a bit too high, not his fault though as he's struggled with injury.

 

[EFL Boy]

Just for a comparison...

Mike Sheahan's Top 50.

1. ??
2. ??
3. ??
4. ??
5. ??
6. ??
7. ??
8. ??
9. ??
10. ??
11. J.Bartel
12. D.Swan
13. P.Chapman
14. L.Montagna
15. M.Boyd
16. B.Goddard
17. R.O'Keefe
18. B.Lake
19. M.Murphy
20. S.Pendlebury
21. S.Mitchell
22. S.Black
23. J.Corey
24. M.Clark
25. S.Goodwin
26. L.Power
27. B.Vince
28. C.Bolton
29. A.Sandilands
30. A.Mackie
31. C.Rioli
32. H.Shaw
33. A.Goodes
34. S.Fisher
35. M.LeCras
36. J.Watson
37. D.Glass
38. N.Maxwell
39. D.Jolly
40. C.Ling
41. A.Didak
42. B.Sewell
43. B.Gibbs
44. J.Porplyzia
45. L.Davis
46. D.Fletcher
47. L.Franklin
48. D.Cross
49. C.Jones
50. R.Hargrave

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

:|

I somehow doubt Gilbert's gonna be in the top 10. He wasn't that good, but damn...surely he's in the top 50!

Oops, thought this was the MB thread for some reason...

 

[LoveLeon]

Just for a comparison...

Mike Sheahan's Top 50.

1. ??
2. ??
3. ??
4. ??
5. ??
6. ??
7. ??
8. ??
9. ??
10. ??
11. J.Bartel
12. D.Swan
13. P.Chapman
14. L.Montagna
15. M.Boyd
16. B.Goddard
17. R.O'Keefe
18. B.Lake
19. M.Murphy
20. S.Pendlebury
21. S.Mitchell
22. S.Black
23. J.Corey
24. M.Clark
25. S.Goodwin
26. L.Power
27. B.Vince
28. C.Bolton
29. A.Sandilands
30. A.Mackie
31. C.Rioli
32. H.Shaw
33. A.Goodes
34. S.Fisher
35. M.LeCras
36. J.Watson
37. D.Glass
38. N.Maxwell
39. D.Jolly
40. C.Ling
41. A.Didak
42. B.Sewell
43. B.Gibbs
44. J.Porplyzia
45. L.Davis
46. D.Fletcher
47. L.Franklin
48. D.Cross
49. C.Jones
50. R.Hargrave

Mackie over Davis and Didak??? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Mike Sheahan, I know more about footy than you. Mackie = soft as butter half-back reciever who hasn't made a spoil or laid a tackle in his ****ing career, Leon adn Dids have won the club 7 games this season between them. This angers me. No ****ing idea.

 

[Big Nasty]

Mackie over Davis and Didak??? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Mike Sheahan, I know more about footy than you. Mackie = soft as butter half-back reciever who hasn't made a spoil or laid a tackle in his ****ing career, Leon adn Dids have won the club 7 games this season between them. This angers me. No ****ing idea.

He also compares players efforts throughout the final series, and based on that Davis & Didak are lucky to be in the top 50, particulalry Davis.

 

[AG]

As I said on the main board, I'd rather he did it straight after the H & A season. He gets to use the AA selection, B & F results to help him rather than just using his own opinion. I doubt Goodwin or Fletcher would be in there is they weren't in the AA squad/team.