Loud Eagle
Senior List
Brown not being named for the second week is a bad sign, but in saying that i have both Goodwin and McPhee and both have been solid, McPhee more so
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
2009 Trade Discussion - Part 3
- Thread starter Dimitri_Mishkin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Brown not being named for the second week is a bad sign, but in saying that i have both Goodwin and McPhee and both have been solid, McPhee more so
I have only used 1 trade and am tired of watching oppurtunities go by, alah rance, nahas, zaharakis etc.
Should i trade out petrenko for greenwood and then skippy to buddy? I really hate playing 2 rookeis in my froward line and have a tough opponent this week. or am i best to wait and see greenwoods second game, see how deboer and other players go?
I can also trade rich for hartlett which is probably a waste, i am keen on using 2 trades and getting another premium forward to match pav,goodwin and delidio.
Should i trade out petrenko for greenwood and then skippy to buddy? I really hate playing 2 rookeis in my froward line and have a tough opponent this week. or am i best to wait and see greenwoods second game, see how deboer and other players go?
I can also trade rich for hartlett which is probably a waste, i am keen on using 2 trades and getting another premium forward to match pav,goodwin and delidio.
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Anyone
Dalsantowhatastar
Senior List
Do i trade Skipworth -> Warren this week and get the 180,000
then next week go Walker -> Buddy
Or would it be better to go Walker -> Warren this week and get the 90,000 plus my 40,000 and go Skip->Buddy next week
Also if I traded Skip -> Warren this week I could go Hille -> Cox. It's defiantly tempting but would mean i have 2 rookies to play in forwards (Ziebell,Walker,Warren,Brown), and not really wanting that.
I have been hearing from people to do one or the other but does it really matter which one i choose?
Any help would be great.
then next week go Walker -> Buddy
Or would it be better to go Walker -> Warren this week and get the 90,000 plus my 40,000 and go Skip->Buddy next week
Also if I traded Skip -> Warren this week I could go Hille -> Cox. It's defiantly tempting but would mean i have 2 rookies to play in forwards (Ziebell,Walker,Warren,Brown), and not really wanting that.
I have been hearing from people to do one or the other but does it really matter which one i choose?
Any help would be great.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Who would you rather trade out for Hartlett, Hasleby or T.Tuck? I'm using one of these on the bench since my midfield is pretty good. BE's are both 99 i'm leaning more towards Tuck simply because I see Hasleby having a biggy this week and Tuck scoring 75. Thoughts?
I'm keeping Patrenko, I'm going to get my cash from Beams/Rich -> DeBoer in 2 weeks. Your call though.
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Haselby has always been the best midfeilder at freo, i never remember him having trouble in the past. If it was my team i would chop Tuck if you want to get Hartlett in.
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Would depend on how many rookies your playing in the mids, wouldnt want to play more than 2 IMO. Sounds like a good trade though.
With Hall and Micky O back in would it be worth me trading Skippy to O'Keefe this week?
tarkin
Debutant
Rich is my only playing Midfielf Rookie at the moment. Bringing in Hartlett is for both backup (Liam Anthony is my other benched Mid) and for cash.
As for Skippy -> O'Keefe ... I personally would leave it another week. I doubt O'Keefe's price will increase much if he obtained a decent score. I also doubt O'Keefe will score much more that 80 this week (just a gut feeling).
Definately. Only gaining there imo.
Loud Eagle
Senior List
Rich hasnt peaked yet though
maximus15
Senior List
but he is the only that will be a downgrade to hartlett
and i really reckon hartlett will keep his spot
some of this is based on not knowing how long
skipworth, broughton and anthony are out for so if someone could let me know that would be great.
have suban starting in backline with broughton, cheney benched
have beams starting midfield with robinson and anthony benched
have ziebell and brown starting forwards with walker and skipworth on the bench.
i could:
1. trade walker to warren this week and (a) upgrade skipworth next week after gia or others go down in price or (b) wait until skipworth plays and goes up more in price and use the trade upgrade on him to get a gun premium like roo then or (c) upgrade someone else instead of skippy in a few weeks such as suban or brown
2. trade skipworth to warren this week and wait until walker/brown goes up a bit more in the next 1 or 2 weeks and then upgrade them
i think it's very tricky to decide which option has the best value. would appreciate others thoughts in trying to work it out. probably one of the first options
skipworth, broughton and anthony are out for so if someone could let me know that would be great.
have suban starting in backline with broughton, cheney benched
have beams starting midfield with robinson and anthony benched
have ziebell and brown starting forwards with walker and skipworth on the bench.
i could:
1. trade walker to warren this week and (a) upgrade skipworth next week after gia or others go down in price or (b) wait until skipworth plays and goes up more in price and use the trade upgrade on him to get a gun premium like roo then or (c) upgrade someone else instead of skippy in a few weeks such as suban or brown
2. trade skipworth to warren this week and wait until walker/brown goes up a bit more in the next 1 or 2 weeks and then upgrade them
i think it's very tricky to decide which option has the best value. would appreciate others thoughts in trying to work it out. probably one of the first options
my trades this week are
Hille LTI --> Cox
Harvey LTI --> Goodwin
1: I should have had cox from the start
2: I chose goodwin over warren rookie because i always end up 2-3 premiums short of my perfect DT with 400-600k spare by the end of the year and it's because i trade in too many rookies for cash.
PS: F#$% YOU HILLE AND HARVEY!!! fa@@ots
Hille LTI --> Cox
Harvey LTI --> Goodwin
1: I should have had cox from the start
2: I chose goodwin over warren rookie because i always end up 2-3 premiums short of my perfect DT with 400-600k spare by the end of the year and it's because i trade in too many rookies for cash.
PS: F#$% YOU HILLE AND HARVEY!!! fa@@ots
is nathan g brown to s.johnson to sidewayish? Or.... is a better option:
Hasleby to Barham
Skipworth to Riewoldt....
I have to do either one, because im not copping another god damn donut, with nathan g and didak and skipworth all missing with only 2 to cover
Hasleby to Barham
Skipworth to Riewoldt....
I have to do either one, because im not copping another god damn donut, with nathan g and didak and skipworth all missing with only 2 to cover
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
maximus15
Senior List
Get hartlett and riewoldt if you can afford that coz i think hartlett has more job security
True but you might make another 100k off him at best. Hartlett will improve by a min of 100k and possibly even a min of 150k. Whats the better option?
i know that but i cannot, if i get hartlett, ill have to settle for someone lower than riewoldt... like SJ
Hes big scores have now fallen off his 3 round rolling average.
This leaves a 69, 54 and whatever he scores when he returns which isnt good for a $250k player.
Hes out for another 2-3 weeks and may come back through the VFL, he also suffered abit for ToG in his last couple of games which concerned me abit.
Hes already made some money (around $50k) and will probably only make you another 30k if you hold him where as a Warren now might made you $150-200k in the same timeframe and be ready to downgrade by around 10ish.
You just need to weigh up the options. Also for those who need money this trade fees up close to $170k which goes a long way for an upgrade elsewhere.
This leaves a 69, 54 and whatever he scores when he returns which isnt good for a $250k player.
Hes out for another 2-3 weeks and may come back through the VFL, he also suffered abit for ToG in his last couple of games which concerned me abit.
Hes already made some money (around $50k) and will probably only make you another 30k if you hold him where as a Warren now might made you $150-200k in the same timeframe and be ready to downgrade by around 10ish.
You just need to weigh up the options. Also for those who need money this trade fees up close to $170k which goes a long way for an upgrade elsewhere.
have skippy in the mids, have the cash to upgrade him this week, would really like to as i am currently playing 3 rookies on the field in the mids and also have 19 trades ledt.
already have ablett, swan, stanton
can afford anyone except bartel (will upgrade otten to bartel a little bit later).
who else do you think will be top 6 mids come year end.
options are - montagna, corey, dal santo, priddis, cross, kornes, gibbs, boyd, thompson, pendlebury, hayes, sewell, selwood, lewis.
bolded are preffered options at this stage.
thoughts???
already have ablett, swan, stanton
can afford anyone except bartel (will upgrade otten to bartel a little bit later).
who else do you think will be top 6 mids come year end.
options are - montagna, corey, dal santo, priddis, cross, kornes, gibbs, boyd, thompson, pendlebury, hayes, sewell, selwood, lewis.
bolded are preffered options at this stage.
thoughts???