2010 Rising Star Winner

[TRAWP]

Hannebery 1 inside 50 and 1 assist on the weekend - it was a good game but let's not get carried away.

Worry about your own lists inside 50's mate

 

[TigerTime88]

It is a fair point though, he obviously got alot of possies in the back half. I didn't see it but someone could confirm!!

 

[indieswan96]

I have no idea why his name is not in the poll.

Ben Stratton has been a sensation for the Hawks.

Poll was made early in the season, I'm pretty sure the OP didn't know who Ben Stratton was.

Also I feel quite confident in declaring Hannebery as the winner now.

 

[Mister Carlton]

Jack Watts has it in the bag.

 

[BarneyBent]

It is a fair point though, he obviously got alot of possies in the back half. I didn't see it but someone could confirm!!

No, the vast majority were around stoppages and in link play. Generally the first touch after a clearance, that sort of thing. While he wasn't superr effective with his ball use, he wasn't picking up cheapies. He was definitely in our top 3 for the game, alongside Jack and Mumford.

 

[Dangas]

Hannebery 1 inside 50 and 1 assist on the weekend - it was a good game but let's not get carried away.

i'm not, i was just stating the stats

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

I'll be interested to see where Stratton finishes in the final standings of the actual count.
If he doesn't poll better than a certain other more publicised player in the black and red it'll be the end of credibility for the award for me.

 

[Hollow Knight]

I'll be interested to see where Stratton finishes in the final standings of the actual count.
If he doesn't poll better than a certain other more publicised player in the black and red it'll be the end of credibility for the award for me.

You realise that it is a 5,4,3,2,1 voting system right?

You aren't going to get a 1-22 ranking of all the nominated players.

More than half of them wont get any votes.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

You realise that it is a 5,4,3,2,1 voting system right?

You aren't going to get a 1-22 ranking of all the nominated players.

More than half of them wont get any votes.

Yeah, but I'm saying if I see that player get a 3,2 or 1 and Stratton get nothing, I'll have a laugh.

 

[festa1234]

average disposals for 2010 best performance

tom rockliff 22.6 31 disposals



tom scully 20.9 39 disposals

dan hannerberry 20.6 38 disposals

jack trengove 19.6 26 disposals

ryan bastinac 18.6 24 disposals

dustin martin 20.3 24 disposals

jordie mackenzie 18.2 (no nomination yet is laughable considering he is ranked 8th) 26 disposals


so i dont think its all that clear cut on who will win i think scully hannerberry and rockliff will be top 3 but in what order im not sure

 

[robertg22]

Stratton's been as good as Reid really, so don't be surprised if Reid polls as many if not more than him mainly due to the fact that he has been the starting CHB of the top of the table team.
The thing that counts in Stratton's favour though with comparing those two is that Stratton has played a couple of extra games, but Reid should be back either this week or next so no big deal I don't think.

 

[indieswan96]

If I were going to give votes right now it would be:

5. Daniel Hannebery
4. Jack Trengove
3. Tom Scully
2. Tom Rockliff
1. Ryan Bastinac

Stiff: Reid, Stratton and McKenzie

 

[Notorious_29]

5. D.Hannebery
4. T.Rockliff
3. T.Scully
2. B.Reid
1. J.Trengove

Unlucky - Fyfe, Stratton, Bastinac, Hurely, Morabito.

 

[The Mighty Boosh]

If I were going to give votes right now it would be:

5. Daniel Hannebery
4. Jack Trengove
3. Tom Scully
2. Tom Rockliff
1. Ryan Bastinac

Stiff: Reid, Stratton and McKenzie

Incredibly stiff- hasn't even had a nomination yet consitantly racks up contested possies, tackles and is always under packs.

 

[blues4flag]

If I were going to give votes right now it would be:

5. Daniel Hannebery
4. Jack Trengove
3. Tom Scully
2. Tom Rockliff
1. Ryan Bastinac

Stiff: Reid, Stratton and McKenzie

Garlett?

34 goals for the season - stiff at the very least.

 

[indieswan96]

Garlett?

34 goals for the season - stiff at the very least.

Not IMO but whatever floats your boat.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Stratton's been as good as Reid really, so don't be surprised if Reid polls as many if not more than him mainly due to the fact that he has been the starting CHB of the top of the table team.
The thing that counts in Stratton's favour though with comparing those two is that Stratton has played a couple of extra games, but Reid should be back either this week or next so no big deal I don't think.

Yeah, Reids been good this year too.
I had forgotten about him. Should probably be rated higher than Stratton, but then again, Stratton's almost been our best defender in his debut season.

My comments are not so much about Stratton but that I think the Rising Star may just sway towards high draft picks and hype, in a way of cross promotion for the AFL and it's drafting system.

 

[liz]

5. D.Hannebery
4. T.Rockliff
3. T.Scully
2. B.Reid
1. J.Trengove

Unlucky - Fyfe, Stratton, Bastinac, Hurely, Morabito.

Fyfe won't come close to winning (I predict) but in terms of x-factor, he has been one of the most impressive of the nominees this year. So long as he has his fair share of luck on the injury front, he is showing all the signs of becoming a high impact player.

I think few have any doubts that Hurley will become a very good player (at worst) but he hasn't consistently demonstrated it based on his performances this year. He has missed a huge chunk of the season and, while his best games have been super, he's not had that many of them. If the votes are awarded based purely on actual performances this year (rather than the voters' beliefs on who will become the best players in the longer term) he really shouldn't poll many votes at all on the voting system the competition uses.

Morabito hasn't even been nominated has he?

In terms of the top 4 smaller ball-winners (from whom the overall winner will probably come), it is hard to predict who will come out on top. Given that watching every game every week doesn't appear to be a requirement the AFL typically places on those who vote on this (or the AA team), it is likely to come down to an element of chance in terms of which of the youngsters' stand out games most of the panel happen to have seen.

 

[raymagoo]

stratton has been great but wont get the kudos? im guessing he got nominated!
garlett has been very solid all year and has 35 goals from about 17 games, will poll wellbut wont win.

hannebury will win imo but could be tight

 

[Millington Magic]

If Dan Hannebery doesn't win it I will jump off the westgate.

 

[AG]

If Dan Hannebery doesn't win it I will jump off the westgate.

You'll land in water so it's ok.

 

[blues4flag]

If Dan Hannebery doesn't win it I will jump off the westgate.

Last I checked there were barriers in place to stop that happening. Find yourself another bridge.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

You'll land in water so it's ok.

Most don't.

 

[jiphoc]

Most don't.

At that height water is like concrete anyway. But yea statistically most miss the water. Seriously how hard is it to not fall in the water. You must be suicidal to be able to miss it (da da ching).

 

[Mister Carlton]

If Dan Hannebery doesn't win it I will jump off the westgate.

Have fun.