- Joined
- Jul 19, 2005
- Posts
- 25,624
- Likes
- 13,089
- Location
- Bunbury, WA
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Manchester United
Actually ODN, I think that this thread has just about run it's course for the night.
The collingwood numpties are going to come flooding over here to crow about their favorite thug winning the award and Judd losing.
Personally, I think that the Brownlow, as the distributor has said, is a meaningless award these days because it seems that the only person who wins is a midfielder or a utility player.
Maybe the AFL needs to have 3 brownlow medals... for positionals
They have the Coleman medal for the leading goal kicker. They need to have awards for defenders and the ruck division players. Similar to the awards they have in association football (soccer) at the end of the year. Best defender, best midfielder and best forward.
With possibly an overall award for the best player.
The collingwood numpties are going to come flooding over here to crow about their favorite thug winning the award and Judd losing.
Personally, I think that the Brownlow, as the distributor has said, is a meaningless award these days because it seems that the only person who wins is a midfielder or a utility player.
Maybe the AFL needs to have 3 brownlow medals... for positionals
They have the Coleman medal for the leading goal kicker. They need to have awards for defenders and the ruck division players. Similar to the awards they have in association football (soccer) at the end of the year. Best defender, best midfielder and best forward.
With possibly an overall award for the best player.

