2011 Draft Ratings

[Clyde's mullet]

I remember seeing a thread a few years ago leading into the draft where all the players were rated on where they were put in the phantom's.
I will endeavour to put a top 50 together leading towards the draft based on posters phantom's.
As a result we should be able to see who are the players that are rising and the ones that are dropping off. I will update the list at least once a week until November 20.

 

[Clyde's mullet]

TOP 50 AS AT 30/10/11

Jonathon Patton
Stephen Coniglio
Chad Wingard
Dom Tyson
Billy Longer
Will Hoskin-Elliott
Matthew Buntine
Liam Sumner
Elliott Kavanagh
Toby Greene
Taylor Adams
Todd Elton
Hayden Crozier
Adam Tomlinson
Mitchell Grigg
Fraser McInnes
Sam Docherty
Brad McKenzie
Daniel Markworth
Michael Talia
Jackson Paine
Myles Bolger
Tom Mitchell
Shane Kersten
Devon Smith
Shane Nelson
Sam Frost
Jordan Lockyer
Andrew Boseley
Brandon Ellis
Tom Sheridan
Alex Forster
Waylen Manson
Murray Newman
Nick Haynes
Tom Downie
Sebastian Ross
Julian Dobosz
Josh Waldhuter
Nicholas O'Brien
Elliott Yeo
Michael Bussey
Marley Williams
Josh Tynan
Brody Mihocek
Clay Smith
Tom Curran
Jackson Merrett
Brett O'Hanlon
Alex Woodward

 

[Turbocat]

Very good idea !!Can i suggest that you have the the phantoms that you have used and where they were rated for eg

#1 Johnathon Patton Ave rating ...

Knightmares PD-P3 , Snoops PD-P2 , Chris25-P2



I say this because some phantoms are better than others and these 3 and a couple of others have history and runs on the board. Perhaps a poll for everyone to rate their fav5 phantoms might determine you source data

 

[SydneyPhilly]

Great idea! But Tom Mitchell shouldn't be that far down the list. He's at least a top 15 pick.

 

[Clyde's mullet]

Great idea! But Tom Mitchell shouldn't be that far down the list. He's at least a top 15 pick.

Sorry mate but this system doesn't cater for father-sons.

 

[Clyde's mullet]

TOP 50 AS AT 1/11/11 (I've now included all Phantoms that have been put up)
I've listed their movement within the list as well.The big movers are in bold.

1 Jonathon Patton
2 Stephen Coniglio
3 Chad Wingard
4 Dom Tyson
5 Billy Longer
6 Will Hoskin-Elliott
7 Matthew Buntine
8 Liam Sumner
9 Elliott Kavanagh
10 Toby Greene
11 Todd Elton up 1
12 Taylor Adams down 1
13 Hayden Crozier
14 Devon Smith up 11
15 Mitchell Grigg
16 Brad McKenzie up 2
17 Michael Talia up 3
18 Sam Docherty down 1
19 Fraser McInnes down 3
20 Tom Mitchell up 3
21 Adam Tomlinson down 7
22 Jackson Paine down 1
23 Sam Frost up 4
24 Daniel Markworth down 5
25 Alex Forster up 7
26 Shane Kersten down 2
27 Jordan Lockyer up 1
28 Shane Nelson down 2
29 Brandon Ellis up 1
30 Julian Dobosz up 8
31Andrew Boseley down 2
32 Myles Bolger down 10
33 Nick Haynes up 2
34 Tom Sheridan down 3
35 Josh Waldhuter up 4
36 Brody Mihocek up 9
37 Sam Kerridge up 17
38 Sebastian Ross down 1
39 Waylen Manson down 6
40 Clay Smith up 6
41 Tom Downie down 5
42 Jackson Merrett up 6
43 Murray Newman down 9
44 Marley Williams down 1
45 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen up 14
46 Josh Tynan down 2
47 Jordan Kelly up 7
48 Michael Bussey down 7
49 Elliott Yeo down 9
50 Henry Schade up 10

 

[real_invincibles]

good job, I think that Grigg is likely to slide from 15 and Ross will be top 20.

 

[CrimsonRaven]

Any chance you could number them? Makes it tricky to figure out who will be around at what pick according to the phantoms.

 

[Snoop Dog]

Its interesting to read this.

I know I will be doing a recut the week before and at this stage I will have Grigg sliding. As much as I like him the reality is he will fall bc of his pace. I would think he will be around the 15-25 mark. Mihocek is another whose testing leads you to think he may struggle a bit. Of the risers there are not really any notable ones. I probably have Kavanagh at the highest of the range and thats simply bc hard to assess where he goes having not played a great deal.

 

[Clyde's mullet]

AS AT 6/11/11

1 Jonathon Patton
2 Stephen Coniglio
3 Chad Wingard
4 Dom Tyson
5 Billy Longer
6 Will Hoskin-Elliott
7 Matthew Buntine
8 Liam Sumner
9 Elliott Kavanagh
10 Toby Greene
11 Todd Elton
12 Taylor Adams
13 Hayden Crozier
14 Devon Smith
15 Brad McKenzie
16 Mitchell Grigg
17 Sam Docherty
18 Michael Talia
19 Fraser McInnes
20 Tom Mitchell
21 Adam Tomlinson
22 Jackson Paine
23 Shane Kersten up 3
24 Alex Forster
25 Sam Frost
26 Daniel Markworth
27 Brandon Ellis
28 Jordan Lockyer
29 Shane Nelson
30 Myles Bolger
31 Nick Haynes
32 Julian Dobosz
33 Andrew Boseley
34 Tom Sheridan
35 Sebastian Ross up 3
36 Josh Waldhuter
37 Brody Mihocek
38 Sam Kerridge
39 Waylen Manson
40 Clay Smith
41 Murray Newman
42 Jackson Merrett
43 Tom Downie
44 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen
45 Marley Williams
46 Henry Schade up 4
47 Josh Tynan
48 Tom Curran up 5
49 Michael Bussey
50 Jordan Kelly

 

[Devo_]

Clyde, this is a great idea. Really helpful stuff. Please keep this up if you can

 

[Fastwaters]

This is great...well done. How many Phantoms are you averaging it over?

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Great thread.

The only thing better would be to keep track of each players highs and lows (either from each individual phantom which would be a lot of work, or just according to their averages on this thread which would be easy to update as you go along).

 

[Clyde's mullet]

This is great...well done. How many Phantoms are you averaging it over?

I've done it over all of them. This next list contains the Big Footy Official Phantom and there are some new phantom's which I'll include on the next list.

AS AT 10/11/11

1 Jonathon Patton
2 Stephen Coniglio
3 Chad Wingard
4 Dom Tyson
5 Billy Longer
6 Will Hoskin-Elliott
7 Matthew Buntine
8 Liam Sumner
9 Elliott Kavanagh
10 Toby Greene
11 Taylor Adams
12 Todd Elton
13 Hayden Crozier
14 Devon Smith
15 Mitchell Grigg
16 Brad McKenzie
17 Adam Tomlinson up 4
18 Sam Docherty
19 Michael Talia
20 Tom Mitchell
21 Fraser McInnes
22 Jackson Paine
23 Shane Kersten
24 Alex Forster
25 Sam Frost
26 Daniel Markworth
27 Brandon Ellis
28 Nick Haynes up 3
29 Jordan Lockyer
30 Shane Nelson
31 Myles Bolger
32 Andrew Boseley
33 Julian Dobosz
34 Sebastian Ross
35 Tom Sheridan
36 Josh Waldhuter
37 Brody Mihocek
38 Sam Kerridge
39 Waylen Manson
40 Murray Newman
41 Clay Smith
42 Jackson Merrett
43 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen
44 Tom Downie
45 Marley Williams
46 Henry Schade
47 Josh Tynan
48 Tom Curran
49 Michael Bussey
50 Alex Woodward up 3

 

[Clyde's mullet]

Great thread.

The only thing better would be to keep track of each players highs and lows (either from each individual phantom which would be a lot of work, or just according to their averages on this thread which would be easy to update as you go along).

I'd like to Enviable but it's a big job now. Just re-visit the previous listings to see the highs and lows.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

I tell you what I'll do a few to get it started and if everyone chips in it should be easy. Remember these are not the high and lows across every phantom but just amongst the averages on here.

1 Jonathon Patton (1-1)
2 Stephen Coniglio (2-2)
3 Chad Wingard (3-3)
4 Dom Tyson (4-4)
5 Billy Longer (5-5)
6 Will Hoskin-Elliott (6-6)
7 Matthew Buntine (7-7)
8 Liam Sumner (8-8)
9 Elliott Kavanagh (9-9)
10 Toby Greene (10-10)
11 Taylor Adams (11-12)
12 Todd Elton (11-12)
13 Hayden Crozier (13-13)
14 Devon Smith (14-25)
15 Mitchell Grigg (15-16)
16 Brad McKenzie (15-18)
17 Adam Tomlinson (14-21)
18 Sam Docherty (17-18)
19 Michael Talia (17-20)
20 Tom Mitchell (20-23)
21 Fraser McInnes (16-21)
22 Jackson Paine (21-22)
23 Shane Kersten (23-26)
24 Alex Forster (24-32)
25 Sam Frost (23-27)
26 Daniel Markworth
27 Brandon Ellis
28 Nick Haynes
29 Jordan Lockyer
30 Shane Nelson
31 Myles Bolger
32 Andrew Boseley
33 Julian Dobosz
34 Sebastian Ross
35 Tom Sheridan
36 Josh Waldhuter
37 Brody Mihocek
38 Sam Kerridge
39 Waylen Manson
40 Murray Newman
41 Clay Smith
42 Jackson Merrett
43 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen
44 Tom Downie
45 Marley Williams
46 Henry Schade
47 Josh Tynan
48 Tom Curran
49 Michael Bussey
50 Alex Woodward

Someone else can do the other half

 

[Clyde's mullet]

AS AT 13/11/11

1 Jonathon Patton
2 Stephen Coniglio
3 Dom Tyson up 1
4 Chad Wingard down 1
5 Billy Longer
6 Will Hoskin-Elliott
7 Matthew Buntine
8 Liam Sumner
9 Toby Greene up 1
10 Elliott Kavanagh down 1
11 Taylor Adams
12 Todd Elton
13 Hayden Crozier
14 Adam Tomlinson up 3
15 Devon Smith down 1
16 Sam Docherty up 2
17 Brad McKenzie down 2
18 Fraser McInnes up 3
19 Mitchell Grigg down 2
20 Tom Mitchell
21 Michael Talia down 2
22 Shane Kersten up 1
23 Alex Forster up 1
24 Brandon Ellis up 3
25 Daniel Markworth
26 Jackson Paine down 4
27 Sam Frost down 1
28 Nick Haynes
29 Myles Bolger up 3
30 Shane Nelson down 1
31 Jordan Lockyer down 1
32 Andrew Boseley down 1
33 Julian Dobosz
34 Sebastian Ross
35 Waylen Manson up 4
36 Tom Sheridan down 1
37 Josh Waldhuter down 1
38 Sam Kerridge
39 Murray Newman up 1
40 Brody Mihocek down 3
41 Clay Smith
42 Jackson Merrett
43 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen
44 Tom Downie
45 Henry Schade up 2
46 Marley Williams down 1
47 Josh Tynan up 1
48 Tom Curran up 1
49 Alex Woodward up 2
50 Michael Bussey

 

[Clyde's mullet]

AS AT 16/11/11

1 Jonathon Patton
2 Stephen Coniglio
3 Dom Tyson
4 Chad Wingard
5 Billy Longer
6 Will Hoskin-Elliott
7 Matthew Buntine
8 Liam Sumner
9 Toby Greene
10 Elliott Kavanagh
11 Taylor Adams
12 Adam Tomlinson up 2
13 Hayden Crozier
14 Todd Elton down 2
15 Sam Docherty up 1
16 Fraser McInnes up 2
17 Tom Mitchell up 3
18 Mitchell Grigg up 1
19 Devon Smith down 4
20 Brad McKenzie down 3
21 Michael Talia
22 Shane Kersten
23 Brandon Ellis up 1
24 Jackson Paine up 2
25 Sam Frost up 2
26 Daniel Markworth down 1
27 Alex Forster down 4
28 Nick Haynes
29 Myles Bolger
30 Jordan Lockyer up 1
31 Shane Nelson down 1
32 Andrew Boseley
33 Julian Dobosz
34 Waylen Manson up 1
35 Sebastian Ross down 1
36 Tom Sheridan
37 Josh Waldhuter
38 Murray Newman up 1
39 Sam Kerridge down 1
40 Brody Mihocek
41 Henry Schade up 4
42 Clay Smith down 1
43 Tom Downie up 1
44 Jackson Merrett down 2
45 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen down 2
46 Marley Williams
47 Michael Bussey up 3
48 Alex Woodward up 1
49 Tom Curran down 1
50 Josh Tynan down 3

 

[LemmingMaster]

This thread is interesting to see the changing perceptions of players.

 

[Thorgils]

This thread is interesting to see the changing perceptions of players.

I agree

Really interesting to read, interesting to see what happens in the draft and how similar the results may be.

Thanks Clyde

 

[Clyde's mullet]

AS AT 20/11/11 Now a TOP 60

1 Jonathon Patton
2 Stephen Coniglio
3 Dom Tyson
4 Chad Wingard
5 Billy Longer
6 Will Hoskin-Elliott
7 Matthew Buntine
8 Liam Sumner
9 Toby Greene
10 Elliott Kavanagh
11 Taylor Adams
12 Adam Tomlinson
13 Hayden Crozier
14 Todd Elton
15 Sam Docherty
16 Devon Smith up 3
17 Fraser McInnes down 1
18 Mitchell Grigg
19 Tom Mitchell down 2
20 Brad McKenzie
21 Shane Kersten up 1
22 Michael Talia down 1
23 Brandon Ellis
24 Daniel Markworth up 2
25 Jackson Paine down 1
26 Sam Frost down 1
27 Alex Forster
28 Nick Haynes
29 Myles Bolger
30 Jordan Lockyer
31 Shane Nelson
32 Andrew Boseley
33 Julian Dobosz
34 Waylen Manson
35 Sebastian Ross
36 Murray Newman up 2
37 Tom Sheridan down 1
38 Sam Kerridge up 1
39 Josh Waldhuter down 2
40 Clay Smith up 2
41 Henry Schade
42 Brody Mihocek down 2
43 Jackson Merrett up 1
44 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen up 1
45 Tom Downie down 2
46 Marley Williams
47 Michael Bussey
48 Alex Woodward
49 Tom Curran
50 Josh Tynan
51 Elliott Yeo
52 Jordan Murdoch up 10
53 Josh Bootsma up 4
54 Brad Hill
55 Jordan Kelly down 3
56 Ben Brown down 3
57 Nick Murphy down 2
58 Brett O'Hanlon down 2
59 Fletcher Roberts down 1
60 Joel Hamling up 5

 

[Clyde's mullet]

FINAL LIST PRIOR TO DRAFT 23/11/11 TOP 80(A few big movers over the past couple of days)

1 Jonathon Patton
2 Stephen Coniglio
3 Dom Tyson
4 Chad Wingard
5 Will Hoskin-Elliott up 1
6 Billy Longer down 1
7 Matthew Buntine
8 Liam Sumner
9 Toby Greene
10 Elliott Kavanagh
11 Taylor Adams
12 Adam Tomlinson
13 Sam Docherty up 2
14 Hayden Crozier down 1
15 Todd Elton down 1
16 Devon Smith
17 Tom Mitchell up 2
18 Shane Kersten up 3
19 Brad McKenzie up 1
20 Fraser McInnes down 3
21 Mitchell Grigg down 3
22 Brandon Ellis up 1
23 Nick Haynes up 5
24 Michael Talia down 2
25 Daniel Markworth down 1
26 Sam Frost
27 Alex Forster
28 Jackson Paine down 3
29 Jordan Lockyer up 1
30 Myles Bolger down 1
31 Shane Nelson
32 Andrew Boseley
33 Julian Dobosz
34 Waylen Manson
35 Murray Newman up 1
36 Sebastian Ross down 1
37 Tom Sheridan
38 Clay Smith up 2
39 Sam Kerridge down 1
40 Josh Waldhuter down 1
41 Henry Schade
42 Jordan Murdoch up 10
43 Brody Mihocek down 1
44 Jackson Merrett down 1
45 Tom Downie
46 Cameron Ellis-Yolmen down 2
47 Josh Bootsma up 6
48 Elliott Yeo up 3
49 Marley Williams down 3
50 Alex Woodward down 2
51 Michael Bussey down 4
52 Josh Tynan down 2
53 Tom Curran down 4
54 Brad Hill
55 Ben Brown up 1
56 Justin Clarke up 10
57 Jordan Kelly down 2
58 Brett O'Hanlon
59 Nick Murphy down 2
60 Jack Newnes up 1
61 Joel Hamling down 1
62 Fletcher Roberts down 3
63 Steven Verrier
64 Hayden Schlothe up 8
65 Nathan Blee up 11
66 Jimmy Webster down 2
67 Kyal Horsley up 34
68 Jack Crisp up 6
69 Dylan Buckley down 4
70 Haydn Hector down 3
71 Lachlan Dalgleish up 10
72 Lewis Hender down 4
73 Nicholas O'Brien down 4
74 John McKenzie down 4
75 Ben Darrou down 4
76 Brendon Ah Chee down 3
77 Coleman Schache down 2
78 Lee Spurr up 1
79 Cameron Valentine down 2
80 Aseri Waikirasa down 2