Analysis 2012, 2013 & 2014 draft ranking

Remove this Banner Ad

My list using the OPs top 20 with differences between OP and my ratings by Down and Up

1. Josh Kelly (2013) Up 3
2. Brodie Grundy (2012) Up 1
3. Ben Brown (2013) Down 1
4. Patrick Cripps (2013) Up 1
5. Joe Daniher (2012) Down 4
6. Marcus Bontempelli (2013) Up 3
7. Harris Andrews (2014) Down 1
8. Matt Crouch (2013) Even
9. Zach Merrett (2013) Up 2
10. James Sicily (2013) Up 5

11. Jack Macrae (2012) Down 4
12. Isaac Heeney (2014) Down 2
13. Ollie Wines (2012) Up 1
14. Lachie Whitfield (2012) Down 2
15. Jack Viney (2012) Up 1
16. Jake Lever (2014) Up 3
17. Christian Petracca (2014) Down 4
18. Jack Billings (2013) Even
19. Dom Sheed (2013) Up 1
20. Orazio Fantasia (2013) Down 3
 
Scharenberg looking better and better. Named as best on ground for the pies this week with 29 disposals, 14 marks, 13 intercepts and 7 rebound 50’s. Will start moving in to the top 10 conversation in this thread if he keeps up his rapid development.
Similar to Brayshaw, who has put up career best numbers the past three weeks. Neither is close to players like Brown, Cripps, Bontempelli and won't be for a couple of years.
 
Similar to Brayshaw, who has put up career best numbers the past three weeks. Neither is close to players like Brown, Cripps, Bontempelli and won't be for a couple of years.
Yep. The guys who have had early injury setbacks are coming from a way back, but their injury free runs have shown glimpses of why they were taken so high. Reckon Scharenberg will be looked at as a good get at 6 in a year or two.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

My list using the OPs top 20 with differences between OP and my ratings by Down and Up

1. Josh Kelly (2013) Up 3
2. Brodie Grundy (2012) Up 1
3. Ben Brown (2013) Down 1
4. Patrick Cripps (2013) Up 1
5. Joe Daniher (2012) Down 4
6. Marcus Bontempelli (2013) Up 3
7. Harris Andrews (2014) Down 1
8. Matt Crouch (2013) Even
9. Zach Merrett (2013) Up 2
10. James Sicily (2013) Up 5

11. Jack Macrae (2012) Down 4
12. Isaac Heeney (2014) Down 2
13. Ollie Wines (2012) Up 1
14. Lachie Whitfield (2012) Down 2
15. Jack Viney (2012) Up 1
16. Jake Lever (2014) Up 3
17. Christian Petracca (2014) Down 4
18. Jack Billings (2013) Even
19. Dom Sheed (2013) Up 1
20. Orazio Fantasia (2013) Down 3
where would you place Hogan in that list?

Was part of the 2012 mini draft
 
My list using the OPs top 20 with differences between OP and my ratings by Down and Up

1. Josh Kelly (2013) Up 3
2. Brodie Grundy (2012) Up 1
3. Ben Brown (2013) Down 1
4. Patrick Cripps (2013) Up 1
5. Joe Daniher (2012) Down 4
6. Marcus Bontempelli (2013) Up 3
7. Harris Andrews (2014) Down 1
8. Matt Crouch (2013) Even
9. Zach Merrett (2013) Up 2
10. James Sicily (2013) Up 5

11. Jack Macrae (2012) Down 4
12. Isaac Heeney (2014) Down 2
13. Ollie Wines (2012) Up 1
14. Lachie Whitfield (2012) Down 2
15. Jack Viney (2012) Up 1
16. Jake Lever (2014) Up 3
17. Christian Petracca (2014) Down 4
18. Jack Billings (2013) Even
19. Dom Sheed (2013) Up 1
20. Orazio Fantasia (2013) Down 3

This is Pretty Funny

Grundy,Daniher,Brown in front of Bonti lol

McCrae at this stage of the season is at No 1
 
1. Brodie Grundy
2. Patrick Cripps
3. Josh Kelly
4. Ben Brown
5. Jackson Macrae
6. Marcus Bontempelli
6. Jordan De Goey
7. Lachie Whitfield
8. Harris Andrews
9. James Sicily
10. Zac Merrett
11. Angus Brayshaw
12. Isaac Heeney
13. Joe Daniher
14. Matt Crouch
15. Jake Lever

2013 draft looks easily the best, and we were the biggest loser from that draft by wasting both pick 6 and pick 10. However, we certainly made up for it by picking the #1 player from both the 2012 and 2014 draft with pick 18 and pick 5.
 
1. Brodie Grundy
2. Patrick Cripps
3. Josh Kelly
4. Ben Brown
5. Jackson Macrae
6. Marcus Bontempelli
6. Jordan De Goey
7. Lachie Whitfield
8. Harris Andrews
9. James Sicily
10. Zac Merrett
11. Angus Brayshaw
12. Isaac Heeney
13. Joe Daniher
14. Matt Crouch
15. Jake Lever

2013 draft looks easily the best, and we were the biggest loser from that draft by wasting both pick 6 and pick 10. However, we certainly made up for it by picking the #1 player from both the 2012 and 2014 draft with pick 18 and pick 5.


Only 2 Collywobbles in the top 10?
Tell us what you really think.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

turn it around? its been a handful of games early in the season and the whole team is rife with it.
He was AA in 2017.

if i was looking for a FF that was a FF and that is all, then i'd go Brown over anyone else in the comp....maybe Tom Lynch if i ever get to see him serviced by a decent team.

Daniher is a CHF who roams up the ground.
They're not comparable players and from a list perspective Daniher has more strings to his bow.

Lolololololol... I guarantee you that Brown covers more ground per game than Daniher....
 
1: Brodie Grundy
2: Ben Brown
3: Josh Kelly
4: Patrick Cripps
5: Marcus Bontempelli
6: Joe Daniher
7: Jack Macrae
8: Harris Andrews
9: Zac Merrett
10: Matt Crouch
11: Lachie Whitfield
12: Jordan De Goey
13: Isaac Heeney
14: Angus Brayshaw
15: James Sicily
16: Jack Viney
17: Ollie Wines
18: Christian Petracca
19: Orazio Fantasia
20: Jake Lever
 
What are those strings? His goal kicking is so bad you want him up the ground and not kicking for goal.

Daniher has fallen away so badly he shouldn't be playing seniors.

Also - you can compare them - in a draft ranking thread like the one your in.

So now you know that Daniher was playing with OP. Those strings are, the odd run in the ruck, the high marking, the long goals on the run, the spectacular goals off the ground and more involvement in general play. It's like comparing Lloyd and Carey. Lloyd kicked more goals, but I know which player every footy fan would choose.
 
So now you know that Daniher was playing with OP. Those strings are, the odd run in the ruck, the high marking, the long goals on the run, the spectacular goals off the ground and more involvement in general play. It's like comparing Lloyd and Carey. Lloyd kicked more goals, but I know which player every footy fan would choose.
Brown and Carey.
 
New
1: Brodie Grundy
2: Josh Kelly
3: Ben Brown
4: Marcus Bontempelli
5: Patrick Cripps
6: Harris Andrews
7: Jack Macrae
8: Lachie Whitfield
9: Joe Daniher
10: Jordan De Goey
11: Angus Brayshaw
12: Matt Crouch
13: Isaac Heeney
14: Jack Viney
15: James Sicily
16: Zac Merrett
17: Ollie Wines
18: Dom Sheed
19: Christian Petracca
20: Jake Lever
 
Interesting that if you count Hogan as well then the Dees have 5 out of the top 20. Very exciting time to be a Dees fan.
 
DeGoey shooting up like a bullet. There would be few more valuable (trade wise) players in the league than him right now. If he kicks on the way he's projecting, could well be a top 5 player in the comp in no time at all. He could also do a Stringer and look like he's heading in that direction and become a comparative spud, only the future will tell....
 
DeGoey shooting up like a bullet. There would be few more valuable (trade wise) players in the league than him right now. If he kicks on the way he's projecting, could well be a top 5 player in the comp in no time at all. He could also do a Stringer and look like he's heading in that direction and become a comparative spud, only the future will tell....
Yeah special player. The million we offered him was laughed at but by the way money is getting thrown around it looks like a fair deal now.
 
Yeah special player. The million we offered him was laughed at but by the way money is getting thrown around it looks like a fair deal now.
Yep was fairly savvy by North I thought. You were obviously projecting, but he would have been a bargain in the long run with your cap space and the way he’s tracking. Glad we hung on to him, and hopefully will do so past the 2 year extension. At the least you made us pay a lot more than we had planned for him, and we’ll likely miss out on or lose a player as a result.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top