Opinion 2012 draft thread.

[pepalenko]

I haven't seen any Menzel footage, so which current player do posters think he reminds them of?

 

[Sin City]

I haven't seen any Menzel footage, so which current player do posters think he reminds them of?

Cotchin.

 

[coryne]

These rumours coming out about Dayle Garlett over the past 24 hours cannot be true.
If they are, he will not be drafted, even as a rookie.

Care to elaborate ??? I have heard some stuff about sleeping pattens if that is the rumours you are referring to

 

[Stamos]

Brett Anderson has tweeted that Emma Quayle has got the first 13 picks in her Phantom Draft, which means we get Menzel.

 

[coryne]

Brett Anderson has tweeted that Emma Quayle has got the first 13 picks in her Phantom Draft, which means we get Menzel.

It wouldn't surprise me, but I will still be a little disappointed that Wines didn't drop all the way to us



That said I think Menzel COULD be a star IF his knees hold up, so having the choice made for us, to a degree, may be the best thing in the end ...........

 

[Silvagnis]

Brett Anderson has tweeted that Emma Quayle has got the first 13 picks in her Phantom Draft, which means we get Menzel.

Does Anderson's DeLorean run on unleaded?

They're just guessing that Menzel could be too hard to overlook.

 

[AlecDuncan]

Whos the delisted player?

Cachia?

 

[Stamos]

Does Anderson's DeLorean run on unleaded?

They're just guessing that Menzel could be too hard to overlook.

Brett Anderson ‏@BrettAndersonIF
Just read @emmasq's final phantom update & from all we're hearing the top 13 appear spot on. North is the interesting pick. #AFLDraft

 

[Bronze]

Care to elaborate ??? I have heard some stuff about sleeping pattens if that is the rumours you are referring to

I'd prefer not to. There were a few bad ones yesterday going around twitter yesterday and on BF last night (which were removed) I've heard about his sleeping issues too and his drinking/smoking, but these were worse and I don't want to put it out there. I really think they have to be BS.....I hope.

 

[BROWN20]

Brett Anderson has tweeted that Emma Quayle has got the first 13 picks in her Phantom Draft, which means we get Menzel.

I would not bank on this being correct, likely to be at least one curve ball.

 

[etsal1]

Really hope North or Cats or GWS @ 14 snap up Grundy. Would hate the Pies to be gifted Grundy.

 

[Sin City]

Does Anderson's DeLorean run on unleaded?

They're just guessing that Menzel could be too hard to overlook.

Fair call. This was his tip for us last year.

Pick 22 – Carl – Todd Elton (Dandenong Stingrays) ..... Others in mix - Jordan Murdoch, Julian Dobosz, Shane Kersten

 

[Sin City]

I would not bank on this being correct, likely to be at least one curve ball.

Yeah, there's always at least one club who does something from left field and that's enough to throw the whole order out.

 

[BluStreak]

So have him drafted by Richmond then ???

no, Adelaide!

 

[Silvagnis]

Fair call. This was his tip for us last year.

You should be a mod.

Oh, wait...

 

[Bronze]

I haven't seen any Menzel footage, so which current player do posters think he reminds them of?

Knightmare, who knows his stuff, says Steve Johnson.

 

[Silvagnis]

Brett Anderson ‏@BrettAndersonIF
Just read @emmasq's final phantom update & from all we're hearing the top 13 appear spot on. North is the interesting pick. #AFLDraft

Part of his schtick to promote his brand as a draft expert.

 

[zeeCFC]

Watched the second collingwood match from this year and Yarran absolutely blows the game apart in a small burst. If Menzel can decide games like The Silk can, we'll have a very nice player on our list. Could be anyone though, even first round and all...

 

[Kramer1]

Will be happy enough with any of Wines, Menzel, Macrae, Mayes, Jaksch, Stringer, Vlastuin, Simpson, Lonergan...hell, even Grundy. Can't lose.

Second pick is shaping as more interesting now. High profile slider like in 2010? Could a Membrey sneak through?

 

[krayfesh]

The only player I'm not too excited about getting is Jaksch.

I do like change.

 

[Sin City]

Second pick is shaping as more interesting now. High profile slider like in 2010? Could a Membrey sneak through?

If one of my favourites slips through to 35 or 54 there will be some big celebrations

 

[Jucman]

Will be happy enough with any of Wines, Menzel, Macrae, Mayes, Jaksch, Stringer, Vlastuin, Simpson, Lonergan...hell, even Grundy. Can't lose.

Second pick is shaping as more interesting now. High profile slider like in 2010? Could a Membrey sneak through?

Membrey please no , his tattoo! The worst ever ,looks like it was drawn by a 10 year old , will suit the pies

 

[Kramer1]

If one of my favourites slips through to 35 or 54 there will be some big celebrations

Anyone in particular Sin?
I recall this time last year people were praying that Dobosz might make it through to our second...there will be surprises tonight.

 

[Wickzki]

If one of my favourites slips through to 35 or 54 there will be some big celebrations

Only to be let down as Carlton select some unknown "great athlete, unlimited potential" from outback Northern Territory.

 

[Kramer1]

Membrey please no , his tattoo! The worst ever ,looks like it was drawn by a 10 year old , will suit the pies

Yep...nothing but gentry for the blues...