Remove this Banner Ad

2012 draft

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
amcre said:
Really? Because compo picks can be traded so I find that hard to believe.

All I want is a classy all round midfielder who is decent on the inside but then silky on the outside. This type of player will step straight into our 22 especially if they are a good size.
Click to expand...
Problem is, I think that guy will be going top 3 :D
 
O'Rourke or Wines probably best fit that description. Hopefully one will fall.
 
Well from what I can tell you have:

Whitfield, Grundy, Toumpas, Viney all going in the first four.

So sounds like one of Mayes, Wines, O'Rourke could potentially fall through to us. Or they could be the next 3 selected.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

amcre said:
Well from what I can tell you have:

Whitfield, Grundy, Toumpas, Viney all going in the first four.

So sounds like one of Mayes, Wines, O'Rourke could potentially fall through to us. Or they could be the next 3 selected.
Click to expand...
Don't think Viney will have to go top 4 will he? I am under the impression Melbourne can take him with their 2nd rounder.
 
Damo80 said:
As much as them bidding helps everyone else out, can't see it happening :(
Click to expand...
It helps them out also, seeing as they
1) Have low 2nd round picks.
2) May well trade in to the middle part of the 1st round. Eg. GCS / Caddy

Never give a sucker an even break, I say!
 
Dea_Day said:
It helps them out also, seeing as they
1) Have low 2nd round picks.
2) May well trade in to the middle part of the 1st round. Eg. GCS / Caddy

Never give a sucker an even break, I say!
Click to expand...
That and GWS may end up with pick 4 & 6 with the mini-draft trades. Leave Viney and get 4th and 6th best or bid on Viney and it's 3rd & 5th. Also, I'd rate Viney close to top 3 anyway. And probably suits the Suns needs perfectly.
 
amcre said:
Really? Because compo picks can be traded so I find that hard to believe.

All I want is a classy all round midfielder who is decent on the inside but then silky on the outside. This type of player will step straight into our 22 especially if they are a good size.
Click to expand...
there compensation picks have to be activated prior to the season start. think if they are activated idk if they can trade it. geelong can coz they havnt activted there mid 1st rnd
 
Cotcho said:
Draft order?!?! What is it?!
Click to expand...

Provided the ladder stays that way, top 8 changes depending on where they finish in finals.

First Round:
1. GWS
2. GCS
3. MEL
4. MEL (COMPO)
5. WBD
6. WBD (COMPO)
7. PORT
8. BRIS
9. RICH
10. ESS
11. CARL
12. STK
13. MELB (COMPO)
14. NTH
15. FREM
16. GEEL
17. WCE
18. COLL
19. SYD
20. ADEL
21. HAW
22. GWS (COMPO)
23. BRIS (COMPO)

Second Round:
24. GWS
25. GCS
26. MEL
27. WBD
28. PORT
29. RICH (COMPO via PORT)
30. BRIS
31. RICH
32. ESS
33. CARL
34. STK
35. NTH
36. FREM
37. GEEL
38. WCE
39. COLL
40. SYD
41. ADEL
42. HAW


Third Round:
43. GWS
44. GCS
45. MEL
46. WBD
47. WBD (COMPO)
48. PORT
49. BRIS
50. RICH
51. ESS
52. CARL
53. STK
54. NTH
55. FREM
56. GEEL
57. WCE
58. COLL
59. SYD
60. ADEL
61. HAW

Fourth Round:
62. GWS
63. GCS
64. MEL
65. WBD
66. PORT
67. BRIS
68. RICH
69. ESS
70. CARL
71. STK
72. NTH
73. FREM
74. GEEL
75. WCE
76. COLL
77. SYD
78. ADEL
79. HAW

Fifth Round:
80. GWS
81. GCS
82. MEL
83. WBD
84. PORT
85. BRIS
86. RICH
87. ESS
88. CARL
89. STK
90. NTH
91. FREM
92. GEEL
93. WCE
94. COLL
95. SYD
96. ADEL
97. HAW
 

Remove this Banner Ad

#9 Wines
#29 Stringer (shut up its my dream ok)
#31 Liam McBean
#50 Tom Lee
#68 Tim Membrey
#86 Kyle Hartigan

Rookie Draft
1 Ruckman
5 Inside Mids
 
guys does wines remind ppl of selwood? just curious as to see how you guys see him. he wins heaps of the ball, think stated its like 24 disposals a game on avg. so just saying are they kinda like joel selwwods?
 
Martin_Riewoldt said:
Guys, the only knock on Garlett is that he may have some attitude problems. So this may stop us from taking him. On talent, he is easily a top 5 pick.
Click to expand...
He doesn't have attitude problems per-say. I think it's just media driven that he's got problems. Waking up out of bed to go to training is what lots of unprofessional people do. If he really wants to become a footballer he's got to prove to people that he will be mature in his actions.
 
Dragonss said:
He doesn't have attitude problems per-say. I think it's just media driven that he's got problems. Waking up out of bed to go to training is what lots of unprofessional people do. If he really wants to become a footballer he's got to prove to people that he will be mature in his actions.
Click to expand...
Just make sure he doesnt share with Dusty
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

NZ_Tiger said:
Do you think Melbourne will enter the mini draft with pick 4? Or are their needs more immediate? If they both the Dogs and Melbourne enter the mini draft how do you think that will effect GWS' choices, will they go mid crazy like they did last year?
Click to expand...

There is some chat around that Suns will trade pick 2 and Dees will trade pick 3 to get into the mini draft. That would give GWS the first 3 picks in the draft which would allow them to take Whitfield Toumpas and Grundy and give them some more genuine class on their list.
 
Article in today's HS on Dean Towers rise through the ranks, I haven't seen his name mentioned on here. Anyone have any thoughts on him as a mature aged player for the tigers?
 
RT73 said:
There is some chat around that Suns will trade pick 2 and Dees will trade pick 3 to get into the mini draft. That would give GWS the first 3 picks in the draft which would allow them to take Whitfield Toumpas and Grundy and give them some more genuine class on their list.
Click to expand...

Clever by Melbourne, get a gun 17 yo and get to use their second rounder on Viney

Seriously man-crushing on Wines, hope he lasts until 9

images
 
Cutty said:
Clever by Melbourne, get a gun 17 yo and get to use their second rounder on Viney

Seriously man-crushing on Wines, hope he lasts until 9

images
Click to expand...
F/S bidding comes first. So they may not have pick 3 come trade week as it will be already an activated pick in the draft for Viney. Apparently comp picks can't be traded for mini draft picks, but I'm so sure and can't seem to find anything that clarifies it.
 
NZ_Tiger said:
F/S bidding comes first. So they may not have pick 3 come trade week as it will be already an activated pick in the draft for Viney. Apparently comp picks can't be traded for mini draft picks, but I'm so sure and can't seem to find anything that clarifies it.
Click to expand...

So if GC/GWS do not bid for Viney, Melbourne can trade pick 3?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

tigs2010
List Mgmt. 2026 AFL Draft
22 23 24 25 26
Replies
644
Views
34K
sregit
sregit

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom