2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y (Part 2)

[MightyMark]

Lewis, better for your byes could also look at N Roo as well.

Waters or Hurn or Rance?

Waters, he is on fire.

 

[Glenno23]

Have 2 spots to fill on my field

Can have any 2 of Smith, Zorko, McDonald or Treloar on field, 1 in mids and 1 up forward

So if i go with McDonald in the mids, i can have either of the 3 up forward

Or i can have any 2 of the other 3. Who would you go?

 

[toxic]

Lewis, better for your byes could also look at N Roo as well.

Waters or Hurn or Rance?

Cheers, is your choice limited to those 3??

 

[bbco49]

Zaha or Chapman?

 

[footyfan_25]

Zaha or Chapman?

Zaha

 

[Hoosy]

Guys, I need help with the Murphy trade...... Im looking to sideways trade without spending much cash so my options are NDS, Cotchin or Mitchell....... thoughts?

 

[Big Fozza]

who to start? Horsley or JMac???

 

[toxic]

Guys, I need help with the Murphy trade...... Im looking to sideways trade without spending much cash so my options are NDS, Cotchin or Mitchell....... thoughts?

Considered Bartel or Callan Ward as a P.O.D?

but of those 3 i'd take Mitchell - seems more consistent this season and with hodge being out he really cant be rested

 

[Shattered]

Hi guys,
I also need help with my Murphy trade.
Murphy > Danger
Murphy > Mitchell (+ uses less cash)

Advice appreciated!

 

[Shattered]

who to start? Horsley or JMac???

I'll be starting both.
But if I was going to leave one on the bench, it would be JMac (close call though)

 

[toxic]

Hi guys,
I also need help with my Murphy trade.
Murphy > Danger
Murphy > Mitchell (+ uses less cash)

Advice appreciated!

how much cash do you have to spend?

 

[Antimatter]

Hi guys,
I also need help with my Murphy trade.
Murphy > Danger
Murphy > Mitchell (+ uses less cash)

Advice appreciated!

I suspect that Danger might start getting a bit more tagging attention over the coming weeks, so Mitchell may be the safer option to pump out scores more consistently...Danger is highly tempting though based on the past 2 weeks

And I also need help with the Murphy trade - who out of these 3 should I go for???
B Stanton
J Watson
S Thompson

 

[Shattered]

how much cash do you have to spend?

Almost none.

Week 8 mid/fwd line is;
GAJ, Pendles, Murphy, J Kennedy, Zaha, Horsley, (JMac, C Smith)
Sidy, Franklin, Cloke, Martin, Porps, Milera, Treloar (A Kennedy, Smedts)

and $14K

Could do;

Milera + Murphy > Zorko + Mitchell (+ $162K)
Milera + Murphy > Zorko + Danger (+ $123 K and 2nd Mid/Fwd link)
C Smith + Murphy > Zorko + Mitchell (+ $30 K and 2nd Mid/Fwd link)

 

[toxic]

Almost none.

Week 8 mid/fwd line is;
GAJ, Pendles, Murphy, J Kennedy, Zaha, Horsley, (JMac, C Smith)
Sidy, Franklin, Cloke, Martin, Porps, Milera, Treloar (A Kennedy, Smedts)

and $14K

Could do;

Milera + Murphy > Zorko + Mitchell (+ $162K)
Milera + Murphy > Zorko + Danger (+ $123 K and 2nd Mid/Fwd link)
C Smith + Murphy > Zorko + Mitchell (+ $30 K and 2nd Mid/Fwd link)

doubt clay smith will be back any time soon so i prefer option 3 of those, at least malaria is playing.. just amatter of which premium you choose, plenty of "different options" around that range and all good for varying reasons

G-luck

 

[Shattered]

I suspect that Danger might start getting a bit more tagging attention over the coming weeks, so Mitchell may be the safer option to pump out scores more consistently...Danger is highly tempting though based on the past 2 weeks

And I also need help with the Murphy trade - who out of these 3 should I go for???
B Stanton
J Watson
S Thompson

Thanks Antimatter.
I hope you're right. I've been keeping my eye on Mitchell for weeks and planning to get him in, but I'm distracted by the dazzle of danger's last few weeks.

I don't think that Stanton can consistently get these mega scores all year (although I've been saying that for a few weeks).

I'd go for Thompson or Watson, whichever fits your byes better. If that isn't a consideration . . . Thompson by a nose?

 

[Dylan Burger]

Cheers, is your choice limited to those 3??

Na not limited, can have anybody but those suit the bye structure the best, would have 3/4 out in 13 if I picked Scotland and already have lids Goddard birchall shaw.

Complete defense would look like this:

Goddard, delidio, shaw, birchall, waters/hurn, lake, Dempsey.

Rookies at the moment would be mohr and Ellis.

Possibly upgrading Dempsey later on if he doesn't improve and can afford to with leftover trades.

 

[Shattered]

doubt clay smith will be back any time soon so i prefer option 3 of those, at least malaria is playing.. just amatter of which premium you choose, plenty of "different options" around that range and all good for varying reasons

G-luck

Thanks Toxic.

Yep, I think I'll go option 3 aswell. I'll find upgrade cash somewhere else another week.

 

[Big Fozza]

I'll be starting both.
But if I was going to leave one on the bench, it would be JMac (close call though)

cheers, i'll be going horsley with Jmac sub

 

[jhamilton]

who to trade out for Zorko?

D Smith
Treloar
Adams

???

 

[Adz]

Giles v Kreuzer?

 

[crowsarethebest]

Mitchell, Judd, Dal Santo?

 

[Seppo]

Magner to NDS with 253k left over
...or to Cotchin with 207k?

Need to go with one or the other for BYE structure.

 

[toxic]

Mitchell, Judd, Dal Santo?

judd, will carve the dees up

 

[dlanod]

Magner to NDS with 253k left over
...or to Cotchin with 207k?

Need to go with one or the other for BYE structure.

You'd have to go NDS.

 

[scullman]

You'd have to go NDS.

Definately NDS.

J.Selwood or Stanton?

Essendon have any easy run the next couple of weeks, but can Stanton keep pumping out these scores?