Review [2012] St Kilda vs Richmond

Remove this Banner Ad

nick1408

Club Legend
Dec 12, 2010
1,854
1,941
Why?
AFL Club
Richmond
Michaels feel free to close/remove this if it has already been created

I didn't see a game thread and since we are still getting games on Foxtel I thought some would like to discuss the match.

Original (St Kilda) Preview Thread
AFL Webste Match Link

[1] Jason Gram,[19] Sam Gilbert,[31] Tom Simpkin
[24] Sean Dempster,[33] James Gwilt,[18] Brendon Goddard
[16] Jack Newnes,[7] Lenny Hayes,[22] Farren Ray
[3] Jack Steven,[12] Nick Riewoldt,[32] Terry Milera
[44] Stephen Milne,[23] Justin Koschitzke,[21] Ahmed Saad
[27] Jason Blake,[11] Leigh Montagna,[4] Clinton Jones

[20] David Armitage,[35] Jamie Cripps,[26] Nick Dal Santo




[38] Steven Morris,[18] Alex Rance,[17] Chris Newman
[23] Daniel Jackson,[24] Ben Griffiths,[11] Jake Batchelor
[6] Shaun Grigg,[4] Dustin Martin,[10] Shane Edwards
[3] Brett Deledio,[29] Ty Vickery,[41] Nathan Foley
[30] Reece Conca,[8] Jack Riewoldt,[26] Robin Nahas
[20] Ivan Maric,[9] Trent Cotchin,[21] Shane Tuck

[14] Bachar Houli,[28] Jake King,[42] Brandon Ellis

(I know a player is missing - AFL website doesn't list the sub - Addam Maric in our case)




Things I've noted so far:

- Batchelor as a real fumbler. I'm not sure why we persisted so much
- Our midfield was actually pretty good. Cotchin, Tuck, Foley & Martin with Maric knocking them down. Too bad our back line and forward line are so thin.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Log in to remove this ad.

Brandon Ellis looked good. Bar Jack, Rance and Maric we looked poor with the talls. Griffiths was ok as a back but it shows our lack of talent and depth.

What are the chances of digging up the old thread vs Adelaide once we know what game it is next week? Be good to compare the comments from years ago to now. Even better, dig up the game from September 2017 vs Adelaide. that one was one sided but not too bad. (In all seriousness, I hope it's the keepings off match vs Adelaide next week)
 
Michaels feel free to close/remove this if it has already been created

I didn't see a game thread and since we are still getting games on Foxtel I thought some would like to discuss the match.

Original (St Kilda) Preview Thread
AFL Webste Match Link

[1] Jason Gram,[19] Sam Gilbert,[31] Tom Simpkin
[24] Sean Dempster,[33] James Gwilt,[18] Brendon Goddard
[16] Jack Newnes,[7] Lenny Hayes,[22] Farren Ray
[3] Jack Steven,[12] Nick Riewoldt,[32] Terry Milera
[44] Stephen Milne,[23] Justin Koschitzke,[21] Ahmed Saad
[27] Jason Blake,[11] Leigh Montagna,[4] Clinton Jones

[20] David Armitage,[35] Jamie Cripps,[26] Nick Dal Santo




[38] Steven Morris,[18] Alex Rance,[17] Chris Newman
[23] Daniel Jackson,[24] Ben Griffiths,[11] Jake Batchelor
[6] Shaun Grigg,[4] Dustin Martin,[10] Shane Edwards
[3] Brett Deledio,[29] Ty Vickery,[41] Nathan Foley
[30] Reece Conca,[8] Jack Riewoldt,[26] Robin Nahas
[20] Ivan Maric,[9] Trent Cotchin,[21] Shane Tuck

[14] Bachar Houli,[28] Jake King,[42] Brandon Ellis

(I know a player is missing - AFL website doesn't list the sub - Addam Maric in our case)




Things I've noted so far:

- Batchelor as a real fumbler. I'm not sure why we persisted so much
- Our midfield was actually pretty good. Cotchin, Tuck, Foley & Martin with Maric knocking them down. Too bad our back line and forward line are so thin.

batch had a great first year. Got coached out of him quick smart
 
Dusty, Lids were quiet, little cameos here and there. Cotch awesome. I thought Griffo was great down back, what a shame. B Ellis, excellent and hard at it.
conca, batch, Tyrone, Stevie...Loved em but the upgrades were needed and have been delivered.
Current side would destroy that one but it was a great game of footy.
seems like only yesterday but how’s Bachar with a fill head of hair? Cotch looked 15yo and the coach hasn’t aged a minute. Says something about him.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Cotch in Brownlow winning form in this game (in fact got 2 votes while Jack got the 3).

Great game, bit of a shootout, lead changes in the last quarter were exciting. Hope they show more like this one.
Vickery was abysmal.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top