2013 Doig

[Schauermann]

Nah, votes go to whoever did their role. Rd 1 last year 20 players got votes, but in Rd 8 against the hawks only 4 got votes.

Ok, so very player on a 0,1,2,3,4,5 base.

 

[PavLike]

Not sure if this has been Posted before - but was curious about whom people think will take home trophies on Presentation night? So far there is

Doig Medal
Beacon Award
Best Clubman
Leading Goal Kicker: Michael Walters

Wonder if they introduce a "Best Finals player" this year

 

[FreoGirl]

think it will be Barlow or Fyfe

 

[Wizard]

Mundy to win his second.

Barlow won't finish top 5.

 

[Alfonz]

It's not as simple as every player being graded on a 1 to 5 scale. I think they also have 4 coaches giving votes. Perhaps they grade each player out of 5 (and grade them quite harshly), then add them up? So the most you can get per game is 20, but that would have to be a superhuman effort like 50 possessions or 10 goals.

I seem to remember over the years it being documented in the online report of the evening that players have scored 12-16 votes per game (e.g. Pav vs Geelong final, Mundy vs Adelaide final). I think the year Mundy won, he scored 25 or 30 votes over the 2 finals. The guys who finished at the top last year (Crowley and Mayne), I think they also scored 15-20 points in the finals.

 

[Schauermann]

It's not as simple as every player being graded on a 1 to 5 scale. I think they also have 4 coaches giving votes. Perhaps they grade each player out of 5 (and grade them quite harshly), then add them up? So the most you can get per game is 20, but that would have to be a superhuman effort like 50 possessions or 10 goals.

Still not sure about the system. My guess at the moment is the same like here on this board: 15 votes from 4 coaches. To distribute as they like with 5 as maximum.

 

[Wizard]

FWIW i think theres only 5 legit contenders to win it, they are:
Johnson, Crowley, Mayne, Mundy and Fyfe.

 

[Seppo]

Not sure if this has been Posted before - but was curious about whom people think will take home trophies on Presentation night? So far there is

Doig Medal
Beacon Award
Best Clubman
Leading Goal Kicker: Michael Walters

Wonder if they introduce a "Best Finals player" this year

Doig - Johnson/Crowley
Beacon - Hannath
Clubman - Mayne

Not sure if there is a best Finals player award, but that would go to Mundy or Fyfe

 

[masai]

Not sure if there is a best Finals player award, but that would go to Mundy or Fyfe

Crowley - " oh what do I need to get some respect !!!? ".

 

[FreoGirl]

I can also see Crowley winning it

 

[sansian]

On a side note, has anyone received their tickets yet?

 

[Centurions]

FWIW i think theres only 5 legit contenders to win it, they are:
Johnson, Crowley, Mayne, Mundy and Fyfe.

I agree but Barlow would be the only other one as he didnt miss many games

 

[JunglistPosse]

Fish Pub

 

[PavLike]

I can see Crowley doing back to back for the Doig
Hannath is really the only contender for the Beacon
Best Clubman - Wouldn't be surprised if Morabito or Pitt gets this. IIRC the reaction from some of the lads when they saw him after the Geelong final was awesome
Finals - I'd give it to Mundy

 

[Moo]

MJ for me

Dark Horse - Spurr

 

[kp junior]

If its the same scoring system they were using in 2011 Fyfe may not win it, but he should

 

[Righteo]

MJ for me

Dark Horse - Spurr

Between MJ and Crowls for me, I like your dark horse too and I agree.

 

[electricfeel]

I really hope Fyfe wins to make up for the Doig he should have won in 2011 (also he deserves it)... but I have a feeling he may miss out again.

Crowley or Johnson to win.

 

[Latro]

Crowley missed the fewest games so he will win it.

 

[Bender571]

Crowley comfortably for mine, did his job well even in our bad games, ie Selwood and Mitchell. Even his game against the Saints should get him 8-12 votes

 

[Dormammu]

Needs a poll.

Preferably one based on a 3-2-1 system.

 

[more_of_bito]

C Mayne

 

[willoblue]

Mayne

 

[JunglistPosse]

Clancee

 

[23cmonShane!]

Crowley