2013 Player/s X versus Y

[karaoke]

Reverse X v Y;

Who to trade out, 1 trade left and facing the donut (unless Saunders survives the cut)

Heppell v ibbotson?

 

[timtamWB]

Reverse X v Y;

Who to trade out, 1 trade left and facing the donut (unless Saunders survives the cut)

Heppell v ibbotson?

I get the feeling Heppell might not be back round 23, so trade him. Also means you have more cash to play with.

 

[doofdoof]

Start JJKennedy (WCE) or Craig Bird (both unique to my team). Wary of the weakened West Coast and JJK has a poor records against Collingwood. Expect 70-80 from Bird, without much upside.

 

[karaoke]

I get the feeling Heppell might not be back round 23, so trade him. Also means you have more cash to play with.

Thanks timtamWB,

actually Hepp is 407k & Ibbo 435k,

but doesn't really matter as no Def is >550k,

 

[karaoke]

Start JJKennedy (WCE) or Craig Bird (both unique to my team). Wary of the weakened West Coast and JJK has a poor records against Collingwood. Expect 70-80 from Bird, without much upside.

Bird at the Cattery?,

may not be the case,

will get eaten alive ,

Can you loophole?

 

[karaoke]

One for my SC Draft final this w'end (ie No loopholes available);

Who should I bench? - just one-

Defs - LHenderson v McKenzie v Gibbs V Houli v Birchall v Patfull*

Mids - Ziebel v Masten v MMurphy v Armitage* v Fyfe V Danger v Cotchin

Rucks - Jacobs* v Mumford v Kreuzer

Fwds - Monfries v Rioli v Tippett* v Breust v JJK v Rockcliff

* My initial thoughts,

 

[doofdoof]

Bird at the Cattery?,

may not be the case,

will get eaten alive ,

Can you loophole?

Lol

No loophole unfortunately. Yep, bit of a quandry in what looks like a very tight matchup

 

[Krujan]

Lol

No loophole unfortunately. Yep, bit of a quandry in what looks like a very tight matchup

I would start JJK as he has a higher ceiling. Bird could also be used as a tagger as well. Bird has only tonned up 4 times this year compared to JJK's 9 times.

 

[karaoke]

Reverse X v Y;

Who to trade out, 1 trade left and facing the donut (unless Saunders survives the cut)

Heppell v ibbotson?

Or should I trade out Webster and keep Heppell &Ibbo in hope of next week?

Heppell/ibbotson > premo defender

Or

Webster > Duffield(?)/Stanley/Grimes

Only have the one trade left,

Thoughts?

 

[Sir Skid]

Or should I trade out Webster and keep Heppell &Ibbo in hope of next week?

Heppell/ibbotson > premo defender

Or

Webster > Duffield(?)/Stanley/Grimes

Only have the one trade left,

Thoughts?

Pretty sure Ibbo is gone with an Achilles injury so will struggle even if he comes back.
I'd lose him and get a premo.

Which 2 should I play out of Cox, Roughy and Rider.
I have Cox's 100 (E) on the bench at the moment and can take both of the others over him or 1.

 

[karaoke]

Pretty sure Ibbo is gone with an Achilles injury so will struggle even if he comes back.
I'd lose him and get a premo.

Which 2 should I play out of Cox, Roughy and Rider.
I have Cox's 100 (E) on the bench at the moment and can take both of the others over him or 1.

I'd take Cox & go Ruff,

Not sure with whole bombers drama on where Ryders head would be at,

How does your match up look like in SC Match Centre?

 

[Sir Skid]

I'd take Cox & go Ruff,

Not sure with whole bombers drama on where Ryders head would be at,

How does your match up look like in SC Match Centre?

Opponent has all 3 (1 fwd) and I can do the same but at the risk of weakening the fwd line.
Ryder also has NO Bellchambers to compete for points with this week I think...

 

[karaoke]

Opponent has all 3 (1 fwd) and I can do the same but at the risk of weakening the fwd line.
Ryder also has NO Bellchambers to compete for points with this week I think...

Can't ignore 100 from Big Cox,

Ruff has only averaged 80 in his last 3,

Go Ryder then......

 

[gh172]

I have Hartlett and Heppell out down back and Nicholls out in the ruck.
I can use Grundy's score in the ruck and I have L Brown from Adelaide sitting on the pine down back.
I plan on using one trade for Hartlett and
I was planning on seeing who gives me the most points out of Grundy and Brown before deciding where to use my second trade.
I would prefer to bring in Bob Murphy as my first trade for Hartlett. If I do that and L Brown posts a rubbish score I'm struggling to think of who I want to bring in after Murphy. So do I bring in Birchall first saving Bob for my second trade or bring Bob in now, take Browns score and trade Nicholls to Minson providing ruck security should I get through to the GF?

 

[gh172]

I have Hartlett and Heppell out down back and Nicholls out in the ruck.
I can use Grundy's score in the ruck and I have L Brown from Adelaide sitting on the pine down back.
I plan on using one trade for Hartlett and
I was planning on seeing who gives me the most points out of Grundy and Brown before deciding where to use my second trade.
I would prefer to bring in Bob Murphy as my first trade for Hartlett. If I do that and L Brown posts a rubbish score I'm struggling to think of who I want to bring in after Murphy. So do I bring in Birchall first saving Bob for my second trade or bring Bob in now, take Browns score and trade Nicholls to Minson providing ruck security should I get through to the GF?

Well I decided to go with Birchall. Great decision that's turning out to be. 20sc point's at halftime!

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2

 

[Beardown1023]

With Lewis a late withdrawal, who to play on the field: Lee against Gold Coast or Daniher against Carlton? Lee being full forward and Daniher starting at ruck

 

[karaoke]

With Lewis a late withdrawal, who to play on the field: Lee against Gold Coast or Daniher against Carlton? Lee being full forward and Daniher starting at ruck

Id go Daniher, playing 2nd ruck means bonus pts most times,

Plus, Lee looks like year is catching up with him ATM, looks to be carrying a few injuries,

 

[Beardown1023]

Id go Daniher, playing 2nd ruck means bonus pts most times,

Plus, Lee looks like year is catching up with him ATM, looks to be carrying a few injuries,

Well you were exactly right there. Didn't matter who I put on the field with Lee a late withdrawal

 

[gh172]

Will Minson or Goldstein?