2013 Player/s X versus Y

[toxic]

need 2 of Gibbs v Houli v Heppell

thinking of leaving Gibbs out... ***i can't believe i'm saying this***

I'd bench Houli, Gibbs at a dry etihad does appeal depsite his recent illness "spudism"

 

[toxic]

Scott D Thompson + Cotchin
Vs
Enright and JSelwood

Dixon and Cotchin

 

[Krujan]

Go Griffen,

Carazzo out, Cachia not as much a 'lock down' as a 'run-with' tagger,

FWIW

Curnow will go to Griffen. He's been our #1 tagger all year.

 

[kierez4ever]

H. Scotland + D. Martin
vs
H. Shaw + M. Stokes

yeh scotland and martin

Scott D Thompson + Cotchin
Vs
Enright and JSelwood

Enright and Joel

 

[Suns of Anarchy]

I'm still new to SC and wondering why Leigh Montagna is in so few teams 1.4%?
Ranked in top 20 point scorers this year, averaged 132 the past 3 weeks which included a hiding at the cattery. He should play every game.
I swapped J Steven to S Mitchell earlier this week on advice but could Montagna be that unique player or am I way off the mark?

 

[aflcliche]

J. O'meara / T. Mitchell?

 

[Suns of Anarchy]

J. O'meara / T. Mitchell?

Jaeger looks tired and even McKenna said this week he will be managed on the way home. Whether that means he's starting sub, subbed out or even misses a game...

 

[syl]

T Mitchell by a mile. Just getting going! 1 down week!

 

[Suns of Anarchy]

T Mitchell by a mile. Just getting going! 1 down week!

Agree. Mitchell played mostly forward against GWS and again last week for his freshen up. Normal service resumes this week

 

[Krujan]

Agree. Mitchell played mostly forward against GWS and again last week for his freshen up. Normal service resumes this week

Also McGlynn back in (Lamb who has been playing mids makes way) McGlynn being one of Sydney's best forwards should mean that TMitch gets Lamb's spot in the mid rotations...in theory.

 

[Test Tickle]

Dixon and Cotchin

That wasn't the option puppies toxic and why Dixon?

 

[BigD231]

Hmm decisons decisions

jack and his recent dominance vs fyfe and his easy run home

tempted to go with jack seeing as fyfe might get a week to freshen up before finals

 

[toxic]

Homer1 -

Dixon pre injury was headed to be in everyone's teams, he seems healthy and flying again. kicks goals, takes marks and spends decent time in the ruck. On the down side he comes up against the Demons formidable duo of Fitzpatrick and Spencer who recently moved to Melb from the uppercombucta west reserves team. Dixon will dominate them is my call

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Homer1 -

Dixon pre injury was headed to be in everyone's teams, he seems healthy and flying again. kicks goals, takes marks and spends decent time in the ruck. On the down side he comes up against the Demons formidable duo of Fitzpatrick and Spencer who recently moved to Melb from the uppercombucta west reserves team. Dixon will dominate them is my call

More likely to effect Nicholls score I would think when he comes back.

 

[RWnBluey]

Final mid upgrade. Barlow v GWS this week and great finals draw. Watson cheaper, tougher draw but SC gun

Which one would you want in your team?

 

[toxic]

Final mid upgrade. Barlow v GWS this week and great finals draw. Watson cheaper, tougher draw but SC gun

Which one would you want in your team?

Watson

 

[Lotch]

Minson vs. Roughead vs. Jacobs (POD) vs. Boomer vs. Pavlich vs. Double trade to get SJ

Long list I know but appreciate any help.

 

[kierez4ever]

Minson vs. Roughead vs. Jacobs (POD) vs. Boomer vs. Pavlich vs. Double trade to get SJ

Long list I know but appreciate any help.

i would do minson (or harvey as my 2nd option)

 

[Knighta21]

Minson vs. Roughead vs. Jacobs (POD) vs. Boomer vs. Pavlich vs. Double trade to get SJ

Long list I know but appreciate any help.

I would want SJ but don't think a double trade is worth it unless you have 5+
I think Boomer is a pretty good POD but can have his down days.

 

[Sanigav]

Priddis, O'Meara or Crouch, need one on the park

 

[Knighta21]

This is more a who do I play.
I have H Shaw, Hanley, Heppell, Ellis, Gibbs, Dixon
I need to bench one and seriously considering H Shaw. I would Loophole him but can't.
At ANZ vs the swans, can't see him getting too much of the pill.

 

[Lotch]

Okay thanks for the ffeedback!

Minson and Menzel vs. Grundy(bench) and SJ/Boomer/Roughead etc

 

[dtswans12]

Minson vs Goldstein vs Roughead?

 

[Sanigav]

Minson vs Goldstein vs Roughead?

Roughy

 

[kierez4ever]

Priddis, O'Meara or Crouch, need one on the park

crouch has been in some fine form so him