Remove this Banner Ad

2013 Player/s X versus Y

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
paul23 said:
Maric is fully priced but should maintain his high average as he will ruck solo again. Jacobs could improve a little more as he is still young. Goldstein has 10-15 points of improvement in him with the slight risk of Currie stealing his number one spot. Id say find the cash and get Jacobs, but if you are short on cash settle for goldstein. No value in Maric.

Moloney with Bartel Fwd VS Dangerfield with Varcoe Fwd (i already have karnezis)
Click to expand...
I think the gun midfielders win you games so I'd go Danger/Varoce
 
paul23 said:
Maric is fully priced but should maintain his high average as he will ruck solo again. Jacobs could improve a little more as he is still young. Goldstein has 10-15 points of improvement in him with the slight risk of Currie stealing his number one spot. Id say find the cash and get Jacobs, but if you are short on cash settle for goldstein. No value in Maric.

Moloney with Bartel Fwd VS Dangerfield with Varcoe Fwd (i already have karnezis)
Click to expand...

danger option
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

richolovesgoal said:
Heppell, Currie/Blicavs/Rowe (on the ground), Bartel

VS

Vlastuin, Leuenberger, Buddy?

This is doing my head in
Click to expand...

I'm not expecting any of these to be on the ground more than a couple of times in the first half of the year.
 
richolovesgoal said:
I'm leaning towards option 2 and I can swap Vlastuin for Stevenson/Terlich etc
Click to expand...

That would be my choice. The general consensus is that Stevenson and Terlich will both play regularly. Vlastuin probably not, and as an onballer, more of a vest chance.
 
toxic said:
which Swallow?
Click to expand...
Sorry - Andrew. Sheuy's due for a breakout year I feel, but so is Swallow, but he's an extra 40k. Still not sure on Sheuy or Swallow??

Now that Crouch is Emer, Crouch or Viney as well??
 
Swan/Pendle?

Enright/Taylor?

Is a 4 gun 6 rookie midfield too biased?? Going for leagues only - Cheers!
 
Commando said:
Swan/Pendle?
Enright/Taylor?
Is a 4 gun 6 rookie midfield too biased?? Going for leagues only - Cheers!
Click to expand...
Swan, but flip a coin.
Taylor
And yes, too biased. 4 rookies (including bench), 5 at an absolutle maximum. Midfield is where your points are scored.
 
Thank
jiska78 said:
Swan, but flip a coin.
Taylor
And yes, too biased. 4 rookies (including bench), 5 at an absolutle maximum. Midfield is where your points are scored.
Click to expand...

Thanks jiska
But I'd have to sell watts to finance another mid, have Goddard and Gibbs back and Bartel forward. Is this enough cover?

And is watts going to kill it this year? (Sorry I've been os for 4 of the last six weeks)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Commando said:
Thank

Thanks jiska
But I'd have to sell watts to finance another mid, have Goddard and Gibbs back and Bartel forward. Is this enough cover?

And is watts going to kill it this year? (Sorry I've been os for 4 of the last six weeks)
Click to expand...
I think Watts will get a heap of it early off half back, but I think teams will then start to shut him down soon enough. And I don't think he, or Melbourne, are good enough to shake a tag.
 
Going around in circles iwith my Ruck

Tempted to go very mid-priced with it. Anyway....

Bellchambers vs Jenkins +100k?
 
Commando said:
Thanks jiska
But I'd have to sell watts to finance another mid, have Goddard and Gibbs back and Bartel forward. Is this enough cover?
Click to expand...
How is it any cover at all? Do you have mid/def or mid/fwd players in midfield that you can swap them with? If so who are they?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Commando said:
But I'd have to sell watts to finance another mid, have Goddard and Gibbs back and Bartel forward. Is this enough cover?
Click to expand...
Impossible to answer, and outside the scope of this thread, without seeing the rest of your team - post it in here: http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2013-rate-my-supercoach-team.985978/page-85

richolovesgoal said:
Koby Stevens or Wines or Toumpas?
Click to expand...
Stevens is injured, due back round 3 - possible downgrade later.
Wines for mine, but wouldn't be suprised if Toumpas burnt that suggestion

Zorko and Martin
or
Rockliff and Stevie J
 
I normally hate going mid pricers unless they turn into a premium but here's my dilemma at the moment. Would you go a high end premium (such as Swan/Danger/Watson) + Rookie (ie. Kommer/Wines etc) + 100k extra cash or Fyfe + Moloney? I think Fyfe is set for a big year and is headed towards being a high end premium (110+) however I'm not sold on Moloney. The latter option potentially has higher upside I guess with the first being more safe. Moloney's best ave for SC in a year is 99, which was 2 years ago in his career best year. Add to that he's a bit more older (albeit he's still in his prime) and he had a terrible year last year. He'll play in a more successful team this year though which might bump his scores a bit higher. I think Moloney + Fyfe might score higher than the Swan/Danger/Watson + Rookie + 100k extra cash, however I'm not sure Moloney will turn into a 'keeper' by the end of the season, and I hate it when mid-pricers don't turn into them by the end of the year.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Maybe Tomorrow
Opinion 2026 Player X x Y x Z
Replies
14
Views
658
Petrify
Petrify

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top