2013 Player X v Player Y

[Willo #6]

K. Jack vs Boyd?

Love Jack's consistency but Boyd could be very good value.

 

[Borshk]

K. Jack vs Boyd?

Love Jack's consistency but Boyd could be very good value.

I would go boyd because of the value.

People seem to be off Boyd, so I traded him in last week (along with Barlow) for this exact reason (proven gun, now a POD). With the two trades per week, his new injury concerns (old age, calf niggles) are not as big of a problem that they would have been in previous years.

Boyd is still racking up the possessions this year. It has just been a few low mark and tackle counts in a few games that have seen him have a poor score by his usual standards. In his games this year, he has had 28, 29, 25, 20, 29, 38 and most recently 32 disposals.

 

[CrozaN]

Ibbotson vs Ellis is doing my head in....

 

[JDWCE]

Ibbotson vs Ellis is doing my head in....

I really don't think ibbotson can keep it up. Averaging 79 away from home but dominating at Subi. Tough one but Ellis I'd averaging 130 from his last 3

 

[goondog]

Walker or JJK out for Dusty or Martin?
Looking to finish off my fwdline, with Staker and Macaffer on the bench.

 

[JDWCE]

Walker or JJK out for Dusty or Martin?
Looking to finish off my fwdline, with Staker and Macaffer on the bench.

Depends if JJK is named this week. For me walker has a higher ceiling but also has the bye this week so if JJK is named then walker for sure.

And ps. Dusty and Martin are the same player

 

[goondog]

Depends if JJK is named this week. For me walker has a higher ceiling but also has the bye this week so if JJK is named then walker for sure.

And ps. Dusty and Martin are the same player

This round's trading has addled my brain, I meant Rocky

 

[JDWCE]

This round's trading has addled my brain, I meant Rocky

Rocky will drop another 20-30k this week if that helps. And I also think Richmond will destroy bulldogs this week. So a tough one. I have picked up Rocky this week as I have no other options to pick up. If u didn't have Martin though I would prefer him as Voss is a nut case and played Rocky at FF last week for a period

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

I need to upgrade to a premo forward and get rid of macaffer or dwyer.

The best forwards available are. Nroo, Bartell, Stokes, Rockliff. I'm kinda leaning towards NRiewoldt

 

[oddsok]

Murphy> Jack or Scooter?

Midfield is currently: GAJ, Pendles, Barlow, Watson, Priddis, Ball, Murphy, D. Martin, Vlas, T. Mitchell.

Leaning Jack for consistency.

Or go for value...? (Swallow?)

 

[JDWCE]

Murphy> Jack or Scooter?

Midfield is currently: GAJ, Pendles, Barlow, Watson, Priddis, Ball, Murphy, D. Martin, Vlas, T. Mitchell.

Leaning Jack for consistency.

Or go for value...? (Swallow?)

Boom

 

[MrRock131313]

Scott Selwood or Kieren Jack

 

[jbiddy89]

Ellis or Ibbotson?

 

[lmach]

Riewoldt v Martin?

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

Riewoldt v Martin?

I like Martin.

Ibbotson vs Malceski?

 

[JDWCE]

I like Martin.

Ibbotson vs Malceski?

Malceski is a sure thing, Ibbotson has probably a higher scope for scoring but could easily back fire

 

[Hammers_Saints]

An extension to that last question. Malceski v Ibbo v Ellis v Duffield.

 

[JDWCE]

An extension to that last question. Malceski v Ibbo v Ellis v Duffield.

Ellis is averaging 112 from his last 4, low breakeven

Malceski could be a good option. Had some downer games early in the season bring his price down a touch and looks the goods now

I'm scared of Ibbo

Duffield has lots of cash to drop

 

[JDWCE]

Ellis or Ibbotson?

Ellis

 

[Hammers_Saints]

Ellis is averaging 112 from his last 4, low breakeven

Malceski could be a good option. Had some downer games early in the season bring his price down a touch and looks the goods now

I'm scared of Ibbo

Duffield has lots of cash to drop

I'm sold. Ellis it is then. He better not do a Hanley/Birchall to me as I seem to have cursed every backman I've had since Bryce

 

[JDWCE]

I'm sold. Ellis it is then. He better not do a Hanley/Birchall to me as I seem to have cursed every backman I've had since Bryce

In that case go Ibbo

 

[Hammers_Saints]

In that case go Ibbo

The way he is going, Birchall might become Ibbo!

 

[Pinochio]

ellis or rooey this week as an upgrade????

 

[kierez4ever]

been said to death but ibbostion or ellis :S
thinking ellis for the money now and get garrick in two weeks time

 

[Squall]

been said to death but ibbostion or ellis :S
thinking ellis for the money now and get garrick in two weeks time

Ellis based on fixture coming up and more consistent over his last 3 games