2013 Player X v Player Y

[lmach]

Enright v Ibbotson v Hanley?

 

[jakemelksham17]

midfielder 500k below selwood, stanton (if not injured), jack or dangerfield. Selwood looks to have a good run coming up

 

[Jessbek]

midfielder 500k below selwood, stanton (if not injured), jack or dangerfield. Selwood looks to have a good run coming up

I would say Stants.

 

[kierez4ever]

midfielder 500k below selwood, stanton (if not injured), jack or dangerfield. Selwood looks to have a good run coming up

kieren jack!

 

[jbiddy89]

Buddy to Nroo; and

Hibberd > Harbrow or Lewis > Dusty

 

[oddsok]

Cornes + 55k vs ROK?

As much as I want ROK, I also want the flexibility of being able to do a straight swap and an upgrade next week if I can. Do I limit my options by bringing in ROK?

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

Cornes + 55k vs ROK?

As much as I want ROK, I also want the flexibility of being able to do a straight swap and an upgrade next week if I can. Do I limit my options by bringing in ROK?

This guy!!! Answer his question!

 

[JDWCE]

ROK

 

[BomberJosh]

I picked cornes for being a consistent true performer, fittest player at Port. Good harder than anybody there. And is a pod. Should be able to consistently score 80+ week in week out this week with a massive sealing.

 

[BomberJosh]

Also like the idea of saving 50k on a premium upgrade target too.

 

[Bluey_McKenna]

I picked cornes for being a consistent true performer, fittest player at Port. Good harder than anybody there. And is a pod. Should be able to consistently score 80+ week in week out this week with a massive sealing.

Fixing the roof at Etihad is he?

 

[lmach]

Enright v Ibbotson v Hanley?

Nope? That's ok.

 

[Zach Package]

Nope? That's ok.

I'd give you an aswer, but i've got all 3. hard for me to say.

 

[oddsok]

Nope? That's ok.

Ibbo.

I'm too sacred of any crazy vossy player, no matter how tempting.

If you wanted enright, should have picked him from round one. I expect him to be rested at some point so I'm staying away.

Ibbo>enright>hanley

 

[Butler]

Nope? That's ok.

Would have to say Ibbo. If he hasn't dropped off yet, I don't see him doing so. Looks a different player this year.

Hanley can go large but also has to put up with the tag and Voss playing him forward. I have him and I honestly don't know what to expect week in week out.

Enright is consistent but doesn't really have the scoring potential as the others. Has only scored one big tonne with the others being 101,101 and 103. Going for consistency might not be such a bad idea considering how the backs have gone this year but then you have to account for Geelongs late year rests.

So I would go for Ibbotson and hope for the best.

 

[matt_y106]

Cloke Vs Stokes?

 

[HenrikLundqvist]

Pies have Adelaide, GC and GWS coming up.

Clokey will (hopefully) go big.

 

[Shaxx Attaxx]

Cornes or ROK???
my midfield. Swan, Ablett, Pendles, JOM, TMitchell, Barlow, Watson.

Also I just have enough money to go either ROK or Cornes for Watson

and my second trade can be SMitchell or Jelwood for JOM

Should I do both or wait a week when I have money and get Cornes & ROK?

 

[lmach]

Would have to say Ibbo. If he hasn't dropped off yet, I don't see him doing so. Looks a different player this year.

Hanley can go large but also has to put up with the tag and Voss playing him forward. I have him and I honestly don't know what to expect week in week out.

Enright is consistent but doesn't really have the scoring potential as the others. Has only scored one big tonne with the others being 101,101 and 103. Going for consistency might not be such a bad idea considering how the backs have gone this year but then you have to account for Geelongs late year rests.

So I would go for Ibbotson and hope for the best.

Thanks, I was thinking Ibbo too. I was mostly just contemplating Ibbo or Enright, I was never really considering Hanley because he gets tagged plus I couldn't stand having another player coached by Crazy Vossy in my team.

Ibbo will be my first Docker I've had all year too.

 

[CJApples87]

Terlich v Enright v Hibberd ?

 

[JDWCE]

Thanks, I was thinking Ibbo too. I was mostly just contemplating Ibbo or Enright, I was never really considering Hanley because he gets tagged plus I couldn't stand having another player coached by Crazy Vossy in my team.

Ibbo will be my first Docker I've had all year too.

It has to Ibbo or Enright for mine. I think Mcpharlin out could possibly help Ibbo's scoring as Mcph usually gets a bit of rebound and Ibbo (fingers crossed) may take up the slack. Enright has a very good run coming up though and could be a slight point of difference to most people. I say get both

 

[JDWCE]

Terlich v Enright v Hibberd ?

Enright by a fair margin

 

[CJApples87]

At the moment I have Terlich simply for the fact that under Neil Craig he appears to be the go to man and it's not like he's going to get a forward tag anytime soon. I may reconsider soon, though.

 

[lmach]

It has to Ibbo or Enright for mine. I think Mcpharlin out could possibly help Ibbo's scoring as Mcph usually gets a bit of rebound and Ibbo (fingers crossed) may take up the slack. Enright has a very good run coming up though and could be a slight point of difference to most people. I say get both

Whoever I don't get this week, I'll get in a week or two. I still have Goodes to upgrade in defence, which I won't do until he slows down.

 

[Butler]

At the moment I have Terlich simply for the fact that under Neil Craig he appears to be the go to man and it's not like he's going to get a forward tag anytime soon. I may reconsider soon, though.

Keep Terlich. I wish I did. He is currently playing like a top 6 defender and isn't really worth the upgrade. At the very least I would keep him as bench cover for the rest of the year.