Remove this Banner Ad

2013 Player X v Player Y

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
trent mckenzies vs enright vs malceski
all are getting tagged but seems like enright is the most safe one (hibberd goes on the bench :p )
Fairly sure McKenzie isnt getting tagged? And I think a tagging of Enright would be pretty irregular? But correct me if I'm wrong.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Fairly sure McKenzie isnt getting tagged? And I think a tagging of Enright would be pretty irregular? But correct me if I'm wrong.

enright got tagged on the weekend and a couple of times this year but then again he seems to do okay with them. my bad with mckenzie

EDIT: I expect Mckenzie to get tagged now
 
Fairly sure McKenzie isnt getting tagged? And I think a tagging of Enright would be pretty irregular? But correct me if I'm wrong.

I think McKenzie got some attention from McCaff for all the good it did, still scored a tonne.
 
trent mckenzies vs enright vs malceski
all are getting tagged but seems like enright is the most safe one (hibberd goes on the bench :p )



I've copped the Goodes and Hanley double this week. Very week in terms of bench cover with Clisby and Thurlow, so I am going to trade them both out.
Issue is, I have absolutely no idea which two defenders to bring in Ibbotson, Enright, Malceski and McKenzie.
Ibbotson has the highest average, but I'm just not sold on having him in my team.
At the moment I've gone for Malceski and McKenzie, but Enright keeps on tempting me. Which two would be the way to go?

Current bakline
Goddard, Heppell, Gibbs, .........., ............, Grimes (Clisby, Thurlow)
 
Took me a while to face facts and bring in Ibbo aswell, I think it's an Eagles supporter thing.

I would go Ibbo and Enright but I think they are all gonna score about the same.

I don't know what to do with Josh P Kennedy, I have had him all season and was going to trade him out but I feel I have all the real elite midfielders and JPK has just as good a chance of scoring big as anyone I bring in...

Current midfield - GAJ, Swan, Pendles, Barlow, ROK, Griffin, Priddis, JPK (T. Mitchell)

Maybe Montagna?
 
Took me a while to face facts and bring in Ibbo aswell, I think it's an Eagles supporter thing.

I would go Ibbo and Enright but I think they are all gonna score about the same.

I don't know what to do with Josh P Kennedy, I have had him all season and was going to trade him out but I feel I have all the real elite midfielders and JPK has just as good a chance of scoring big as anyone I bring in...

Current midfield - GAJ, Swan, Pendles, Barlow, ROK, Griffin, Priddis, JPK (T. Mitchell)

Maybe Montagna?


The more I think about it, the more I've started leaning towards Ibbotson. Can't go past his average.

Josh P Kennedy looked really good last week against the Eagles. Would be tough to trade him out after a performance like that, but with 2 trades per week, it feels like you have to use them.
My midfield is very similar to yours, but instead of Priddis and JPK, I have Selwood and Cotchin. I've had Selwood from the start and got Cotchin in the week he hurt his knee against Freo earlier in the year. What I've learnt is to stick by your premiums. There were many times I would have traded one or both of them out this season, but both have been great recently, especially Selwood the past 5 weeks (take out his Crowley tag).

In saying that, if you have a spare trade this week, then JPK to Montagna doesnt seem like a bad idea at all.
 
Hutchings vs Deledio (I cant ditch him because i have to upgrade 2 injuries this week)

Hutchings has been in great form.....just not sure if he can keep it up.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

So my Friday arvo stressing begins...

Dalziell > Cotchin or Dusty for this week? I just have a feeling Cotchin (and Lids) are gonna get shut down against the Swans MF.. and Dusty will do his usual.
 
Opinions on two things.. firstly who to trade out??

Staker v Thurlow v Clisby v Titchell? It's cash v cover basically :confused:
Secondly... which mid?

Scooter v Beams v Griff?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Trading out Stanton.

Beams or Montagna?
Beams worth much more. But worth it.
---
Trading out Terlich. Hartlett, Shaw or McKenzie? Hartlett has been okay recently and pretty cheap but can be a real killer, Shaw is inconsistent but you know his average will even out to something respectable (tough draw) and I would have easily said McKenzie until last weekend (easy draw). Was the Cannon's score just a one off or is it something we can expect from now on?
 
Beams worth much more. But worth it.
---
Trading out Terlich. Hartlett, Shaw or McKenzie? Hartlett has been okay recently and pretty cheap but can be a real killer, Shaw is inconsistent but you know his average will even out to something respectable (tough draw) and I would have easily said McKenzie until last weekend (easy draw). Was the Cannon's score just a one off or is it something we can expect from now on?


i think Cannon was a one off, he had to play KPD because rory thompson was a late out, should do okay but i havent picked him. I would trade Terlich, Hartlett, Shaw, McKenzie in that order
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top