FWIW, I respectfully disagree with Rahul. He is enthusiastic in his praise of Aish, but Josh Kelly runs rings around him, especially in the age of run and spread, he has a freakish tank already without AFL pre seasons behind him. In fact Jack Billings is also a freakshow who has not been 100% fit this year, a goal kicking mid who dominates one on one whoever he is matched up on.
Aish could be the next Aaron Fiora with his small build, an outside player who receives and runs, so all I can suggest is not being hung up on James Aish.
Re Lachie Whitfield v James Aish, again I respectfully disagree, LW in a good team would be a super player already.