I'm honestly not too sold on him yet but if he's available at our pick he's definitely a no brainer for us. I do really think he fits in quite well with the type of forward we're looking for. Great contested/one on one mark, fast on the lead, good at ground level (which I feel is very important for any forward we get seeing as we have to scrap for a lot of our goals and have a very 'contested' style in all parts of the ground) and a great field kick/skills if he pushes up the ground.
I like him at FF and a Jones/Reid/Jaksch type at CHF but then add in a couple of Cramers/Stringer/Bonts and then where does our 2nd ruck come from? No way you can play a Cordy on top of that, that's why I'd prefer Wright. Would have to rely on the CHF, Sam Reid might be okay out of those 3 but still not ideal. Maybe if we play a Rough, Roberts, Talia set up down back Rough can do it, would be an interesting but different set up.
Honestly don't think McCartin is that different to Stringer playing out of the square, what maybe 2cm taller and probably a better contested mark which is handy I guess.
That sort of line up is really going hard at big bodies talls who are good below their knees, literally all over the ground, which I like a hell of a lot.