2014 SuperCoach Draft

[Jiska]

Gee - why am i not jumping for joy???

Well. IMO:
Sloane 9/10
Dunn 5/10
Luey 8/10
So, 22/30

Wines 6/10
Hibberd 7/10
Minson 9/10
So, 22/30

Or, compare their prices, which are based on output from last year
Sloane 577k
Dunn 444k
Luey 523k
Total: 1.54 million

Wines 399k
Hibberd 517k
Minson 616k
Total: 1.53 million

Up to you, but I think it's a pretty fair swap. In fact now I'm wondering if it's worth it

 

[toxic]

Well. IMO:
Sloane 9/10
Dunn 5/10
Luey 8/10
So, 22/30

Wines 6/10
Hibberd 7/10
Minson 9/10
So, 22/30

Or, compare their prices, which are based on output from last year
Sloane 577k
Dunn 444k
Luey 523k
Total: 1.54 million

Wines 399k
Hibberd 517k
Minson 616k
Total: 1.53 million

Up to you, but I think it's a pretty fair swap. In fact now I'm wondering if it's worth it

Wines underpriced and we both agree hibberd is a gun

 

[Jiska]

Wines underpriced and we both agree hibberd is a gun

Why is Wines underpriced - he scored what he scored. You can't trade based on "potential"

If we're going to ignore statistics, I think Luey is underpriced and Minson is overpriced, and I know you agree on both those points.

Hibberd is the sweetner to make me trade

 

[toxic]

Why is Wines underpriced - he scored what he scored. You can't trade based on "potential"

If we're going to ignore statistics, I think Luey is underpriced and Minson is overpriced, and I know you agree on both those points.

Hibberd is the sweetner to make me trade

Agrred on luey and minson, hence im trying to offload him...but lynden dunn

 

[Jiska]

Agrred on luey and minson, hence im trying to offload him...but lynden dunn

Well, look at my defense. Not a lot to offer.

The only way I'd consider trading is to improve my backline, that's why I want Hibberd, but I'm not going to give away Sloane and Luey, both of who I rate very highly, unless I'm going to get something close to their levels. Sloane much better than Wines IMO and Luey/Minson on par.

Wines < Sloane
Minson = Luey (or perhaps very marginally better)
Hibberd > Dunn

Up to you. I'm more than happy not to trade. The more I think about it, the more I think Luey/Dunn/Sloane will outscore Minson/Hibb/Wines over the course of the year TBH.

You do know that Luey was the player I selected with my very first draft pick - that's how highly I rate him.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

13/1376(C) one team even with low scores from Sutcliffe and Broughton. Thanks Pendles
The other 11/1057. Would have been a whole lot worse if not for Mumford and Harlett.

 

[GOAUS!]

My draft team is currently 7/833. Bartel, Cross, MaCrae and Petrie to come.

 

[Honeyboy Wilson]

Is it just me or is it impossible to trade multiple players?

I can put multiple players up for trade with another team, but when I try and select the players from their team I want to make the offer for, it only lets me select one?!

This website is an absolute disgrace. Those involved should actually feel ashamed that this is their chosen profession.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Anyone know what happens when you put in a claim for a player whose waiver expires during lockout? Particularly if one of the players has already played.

 

[unclechopchop2]

Im looking for feedback if this is a fair trade. My team has a very deep midfield, I need another decent forward and back.
Myself and another manager are discussing this trade.

My team trading out: josh kennedy (swans) and matthee stokes.
My team recieving: Andrew Walker and Chad Wingard.

It will essentially mean I will have on the field ;
Walker, wingard, jack steven and ben cunnington
As opposed to
Reilly, Petrie, Kennedy and Stokes

Any feedback would be apreciated.

 

[unclechopchop2]

Anyone know what happens when you put in a claim for a player whose waiver expires during lockout? Particularly if one of the players has

Anyone know what happens when you put in a claim for a player whose waiver expires during lockout? Particularly if one of the players has already played.

I had the same thing last week, rolling lockout rules apply

 

[GUMBLETRON]

I had the same thing last week, rolling lockout rules apply

We're on classic lockout. The smart method would be to process the claims the moment it unlocks, but we shall see.

 

[GOAUS!]

My current draft bench

Fyfe, Hickey, Dixon and Ben Reid. Traded out Walters for De Boer too.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

We're on classic lockout. The smart method would be to process the claims the moment it unlocks, but we shall see.

In this case, the waiver expired at 4AM Sunday, and on expiry was extended to 4AM Monday.

 

[lmaohelp]

Hi guys, with auto emergency selected as one of our rules, if I have 2 zeroes on my field but I have 2 bench players who have scored, will those bench players contribute to my score in a match day game?

And if I have a 0 that has played yesterday, do you think its possible to trade out a player on my bench who is not playing, to a player that is going to play today to cover the 0 that happened yesterday?

Thanks

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Auto-emg only covers one zero, and you'll get the lowest bench score no matter when they're traded in.

 

[MaxNRG]

What are peoples opinions on a trade like this. Which option would you go with? The other team is really struggling in the ruck so I'm happy to offload Lobe but the ruck options are very thin to find a replacement.

What players would you choose in a trade, and do you think it is worth it?
TEAM 1
Def(Malceski or Fletcher or Gibson) AND Fwd(Petrie or J.Merrett or Higgins)
TEAM 2
Ruc(Goldestein or Lobe)

 

[lmaohelp]

Hey everyone sorry if this has been asked. But can you have the SC captain loop whole in draft if I want to have rockliff captain tonight ?

 

[hawker92]

Is there a prize for the highest scoring draft team? Just racked up 1327 with 11 players