List Mgmt. 2014: The List

[Superstar swan]

True but Warnock would have quality over those selections.
I think the future of trading is in win win trades and a club has to deal honestly as a business would to have future success at the trade table (avoid burning bridges) Curiously how did you feel about the Everitt trade last year? I felt at the time we paid unders for him but considering your cap issues due to the buddy recruitment I understood it.

I don't think anyone was sour over the everitt deal, he was pushed out due to cap issues and last year was his only consistant season so his value wasn't too high.

Good to see him playing footy for the blues and likewise Laidler for us

 

[smashbox gill]

I don't think anyone was sour over the everitt deal, he was pushed out due to cap issues and last year was his only consistant season so his value wasn't too high.

Good to see him playing footy for the blues and likewise Laidler for us

If jeffy was to leave carlton it would be back to WA i would think.

 

[LordLucifer]

The swans just signed rohan for a further 3 years and is highly rated at the club.

IMO the most likely offer the swans would put up would be something like towers and a pick

Good grief, it was a hypothetical example .................

 

[FlowersByIrene]

How the **** is Rohan a hypothetical for a Garlett trade, Rohan is a hack

Played the sub yesterday, played 20 mintues and didnt record a stat

 

[LordLucifer]

How the **** is Rohan a hypothetical for a Garlett trade, Rohan is a hack

FMD, Gary Rohan is a hack ................... I've read it all now.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

FMD, Gary Rohan is a hack ................... I've read it all now.

Rohan is a hack though.....

 

[LordLucifer]

Rohan is a hack though.....

We'll have to differ on this particular topic.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

We'll have to differ on this particular topic.

Played half an hour the other day and didn't even get a touch, or a tackle, or anything, as the sub. Should have been fresh and had an impact, zilch

 

[marcmurphy#3]

We'll have to differ on this particular topic.

Maybe hack is a bit harsh, but definitely overrated and performing terribly right now.

 

[I bleed Blue]

Rohan hasn't been the same since his injury. He is no hack though.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

If Rohan was offered up for Garlett, I'd drive Jeffy to Sydney.

Rohan will be a gem, think of a better version of Kane Tenace (with more pace!) (yes I know that rhymes).

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

If the Swans were prepared to trade Gary Rohan and a third rounder, Jeffy Garlett would be looking at real estate around Redfern & Surry Hills very shortly.

Racist.

 

[FoeverBlues]

If Rohan was offered up for Garlett, I'd drive Jeffy to Sydney.

Rohan will be a gem, think of a better version of Kane Tenace (with more pace!) (yes I know that rhymes).

Jeffy is a proven performer going thru a bad patch where as Rohan is potentially a very good HF who has not done much but lives off his potential.

 

[BM123]

If Rohan was offered up for Garlett, I'd drive Jeffy to Sydney.

Rohan will be a gem, think of a better version of Kane Tenace (with more pace!) (yes I know that rhymes).

He has struggled since his injury. As Superstar Swan mentioned before though he is highly rated internally by Sydney though.

 

[LanceRomance]

He has struggled since his injury. As Superstar Swan mentioned before though he is highly rated internally by Sydney though.

There are some who say that I am highly rated... internally.

 

[BM123]

Jeffy is a proven performer going thru a bad patch where as Rohan is potentially a very good HF who has not done much but lives off his potential.

Jeffy's form slumps last whole seasons though. If we could get a decent mid in the right age bracket for Garlett I'd make that trade easy.

 

[BM123]

There are some who say that I am highly rated... internally.

It's amazing how we see things from the outside then isn't it?

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Jeffy is a proven performer going thru a bad patch where as Rohan is potentially a very good HF who has not done much but lives off his potential.

Even though it's merely a hypothetical.

Rohan's scope/ceiling as a 189 cm utility with blistering pace is far higher than Jeffy's.

You state that Rohan hasn't done much and is living off of his own potential .... thats pretty much the same description for Garlett who I haven't seen impact a game this season (or for parts of last season).

 

[BM123]

Even though it's merely a hypothetical.

Rohan's scope/ceiling as a 189 cm utility with blistering pace is far higher than Jeffy's.

You state that Rohan hasn't done much and is living off of his own potential .... thats pretty much the same description for Garlett who I haven't seen impact a game this season (or for parts of last season).

Garlett

1. Beaten by a first gamer.
2. Missed from 15 metres out, 5 metres out
3. Unsighted
4. Dropped
5. Dropped
6. 3 goals and looked great
7. Unsighted and looked disinterested in chasing
8. bye
9. Squibbed it as sub and kicked a great goal straight afterwards which sort of sums up Jeffy's career
10. Squibbed it again as sub and kicked a great goal
11. 3 goals as sub but didn't get a touch or tackle otherwise
12. Some good plays but squibbed it about 5 times in crucial moments
13. Dropped again.

So 1 great game and loads of shit. In saying that our forward line has struggled all season with Waite and Henderson in horrid form. Our leading goal kicker is Menzel who has been sub for far too many games and missed games with injury too.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Carlton will do want Port did. Be Premiership contenders in 2 years. Hope

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Swans wouldn't want Garlett in current form

 

[BM123]

Surprise that there isn't more Menzel worship going on here.

He is leading our goal kicking tally

DESPITE

1. Having one decent preseason under his belt as a 2nd year player
2. Playing in a side that hates honouring leading forwards
3. Been injured or playing as the sub for 5 whole games.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Garlett is playing shit and is still fourth in goal kick with 12. Wouldn't be 4-8 if Garlett was in last years form

 

[etsal1]

Surprise that there isn't more Menzel worship going on here.

He is leading our goal kicking tally

DESPITE

1. Having one decent preseason under his belt as a 2nd year player
2. Playing in a side that hates honouring leading forwards
3. Been injured or playing as the sub for 5 whole games.

I try to worship him but get told in obsessed haha.

 

[etsal1]

Garlett is playing shit and is still fourth in goal kick with 12. Wouldn't be 4-8 if Garlett was in last years form

He had kicked double the amount of goals this time last year too