List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft

[unplugged]

Apologies if this has been discussed in here or other threads however I haven't read through a lot of the potential draft pick threads. Has there any talk about what may happen with Ash Close? Is he a rookie or even draft chance from us or any other team? I remember he was invited to the combine but haven't really heard how that went. Cheers

The fact that he has all but recommitted to our VFL side tells me that we're not interested in an AFL capacity and no one else was either.

Could be wrong though.

 

[unplugged]

I just combined the current phantom drafts of Cal Twomey, Emma Quayle, Sam Landsberger, Knightmare and Snoop Dog and took some averages to get a summarised power rankings.

Basically I only took the top 30 from Twomey and Landsberger as that's all they offer. I could also only take the top 25 from Emma Quayle as that's all she offered.

Although Knightmare and Snoop both offer 31 and beyond, I cut them off there too so that it didn't take even longer to do.

Nonetheless, it probably has holes in it everywhere. Especially when considering only Cal Twomey has Fiorini in their top 25/30 (24th)and and a few others, including Knightmare with Partington at 28, etc.

Anyway, I couldn't be bothered lining up teams at this stage.

1. Weitering (average pick 1)
2. Schache (2)
3. Mills (3)
4. Oliver (4.6)
5. Francis/Parish (5.8)
6. Francis/Parish (5.8)
7. Hopper (6.4)
8. Weideman (9.2)
9. Ah Chee (9.6)
10. Kennedy (10.6)
11. H. McKay (11)
12. Milera (11.6)
13. Hipwood (11.8)
14. Curnow (13.2)
15. Burton (16.4)
16. Rioli (17.8)
17. Balic/Keays (18.2)
18. Balic/Keays (18.2)
19. Gresham (19.2)
20. Tucker (19.4)
21. Collins (20.4)

This is where it starts to fall apart a little (some people having players that others don't)...

22. Himmelberg (22)
23. Hibberd (23.75)
24. Fiorini (24)
25. Clarke (24.67)
26. B. McKay/Dunkley (25)
27. B. McKay/Dunkley (25)
28. Bonner (25.25)
29. Cole (25.33)
30. Cuningham (25.8)

And this is where it really starts to fall away, obviously...

31. Schoenfeld (26)
32. Skinner (27)
33. Mathieson (27.25)
34. Partington (28)
35. Redman (29)

I did this whole exercise trying to find who we would pick tonight and I feel like I may have wasted my time.

Sam Skinner? Well, only Knightmare and Snoop Dog had him in their 30 (27 & 27 respectively), so it might just be a BigFooty fascination. Dom Milesi followed him in his group of players earlier this year, so I wouldn't count him out.

If anyone wants to put teams to the above, be my guest!

Excited, even if it is just pick 32.

 

[Matt_352]

Is Blake Hardwick related to Damien

 

[Apex36]

I just combined the current phantom drafts of Cal Twomey, Emma Quayle, Sam Landsberger, Knightmare and Snoop Dog and took some averages to get a summarised power rankings.

Basically I only took the top 30 from Twomey and Landsberger as that's all they offer. I could also only take the top 25 from Emma Quayle as that's all she offered.

Although Knightmare and Snoop both offer 31 and beyond, I cut them off there too so that it didn't take even longer to do.

Nonetheless, it probably has holes in it everywhere. Especially when considering only Cal Twomey has Fiorini in their top 25/30 (24th)and and a few others, including Knightmare with Partington at 28, etc.

Anyway, I couldn't be bothered lining up teams at this stage.

1. Weitering (average pick 1)
2. Schache (2)
3. Mills (3)
4. Oliver (4.6)
5. Francis/Parish (5.8)
6. Francis/Parish (5.8)
7. Hopper (6.4)
8. Weideman (9.2)
9. Ah Chee (9.6)
10. Kennedy (10.6)
11. H. McKay (11)
12. Milera (11.6)
13. Hipwood (11.8)
14. Curnow (13.2)
15. Burton (16.4)
16. Rioli (17.8)
17. Balic/Keays (18.2)
18. Balic/Keays (18.2)
19. Gresham (19.2)
20. Tucker (19.4)
21. Collins (20.4)

This is where it starts to fall apart a little (some people having players that others don't)...

22. Himmelberg (22)
23. Hibberd (23.75)
24. Fiorini (24)
25. Clarke (24.67)
26. B. McKay/Dunkley (25)
27. B. McKay/Dunkley (25)
28. Bonner (25.25)
29. Cole (25.33)
30. Cuningham (25.8)

And this is where it really starts to fall away, obviously...

31. Schoenfeld (26)
32. Skinner (27)
33. Mathieson (27.25)
34. Partington (28)
35. Redman (29)

I did this whole exercise trying to find who we would pick tonight and I feel like I may have wasted my time.

Sam Skinner? Well, only Knightmare and Snoop Dog had him in their 30 (27 & 27 respectively), so it might just be a BigFooty fascination. Dom Milesi followed him in his group of players earlier this year, so I wouldn't count him out.

If anyone wants to put teams to the above, be my guest!

Excited, even if it is just pick 32.

I get the feeling we might avoid kids who've had knee reconstructions already after yesterday's tragedy, so that puts a line through Skinner for me.

 

[unplugged]

I get the feeling we might avoid kids who've had knee reconstructions already after yesterday's tragedy, so that puts a line through Skinner for me.

It's a good point, but would you have ruled our the recruiting Troy Menzel though if he was available or recently offered to us?

 

[TradeDraft]

It's a good point, but would you have ruled our the recruiting Troy Menzel though if he was available or recently offered to us?

Maybe-Maybe not and the Reputation of Menzel be Lazy at Times

 

[TradeDraft]

Rookie Draft be Interesting now with have 1 Rookie Elevation available with The Sad News of Schaz's ACL Injury

 

[wednesdaywarrior]

I just combined the current phantom drafts of Cal Twomey, Emma Quayle, Sam Landsberger, Knightmare and Snoop Dog and took some averages to get a summarised power rankings.

Basically I only took the top 30 from Twomey and Landsberger as that's all they offer. I could also only take the top 25 from Emma Quayle as that's all she offered.

Although Knightmare and Snoop both offer 31 and beyond, I cut them off there too so that it didn't take even longer to do.

Nonetheless, it probably has holes in it everywhere. Especially when considering only Cal Twomey has Fiorini in their top 25/30 (24th)and and a few others, including Knightmare with Partington at 28, etc.

Anyway, I couldn't be bothered lining up teams at this stage.

1. Weitering (average pick 1)
2. Schache (2)
3. Mills (3)
4. Oliver (4.6)
5. Francis/Parish (5.8)
6. Francis/Parish (5.8)
7. Hopper (6.4)
8. Weideman (9.2)
9. Ah Chee (9.6)
10. Kennedy (10.6)
11. H. McKay (11)
12. Milera (11.6)
13. Hipwood (11.8)
14. Curnow (13.2)
15. Burton (16.4)
16. Rioli (17.8)
17. Balic/Keays (18.2)
18. Balic/Keays (18.2)
19. Gresham (19.2)
20. Tucker (19.4)
21. Collins (20.4)

This is where it starts to fall apart a little (some people having players that others don't)...

22. Himmelberg (22)
23. Hibberd (23.75)
24. Fiorini (24)
25. Clarke (24.67)
26. B. McKay/Dunkley (25)
27. B. McKay/Dunkley (25)
28. Bonner (25.25)
29. Cole (25.33)
30. Cuningham (25.8)

And this is where it really starts to fall away, obviously...

31. Schoenfeld (26)
32. Skinner (27)
33. Mathieson (27.25)
34. Partington (28)
35. Redman (29)

I did this whole exercise trying to find who we would pick tonight and I feel like I may have wasted my time.

Sam Skinner? Well, only Knightmare and Snoop Dog had him in their 30 (27 & 27 respectively), so it might just be a BigFooty fascination. Dom Milesi followed him in his group of players earlier this year, so I wouldn't count him out.

If anyone wants to put teams to the above, be my guest!

Excited, even if it is just pick 32.

Commendable effort. Rest assured - intensely analysing footy and draft stats is never a waste of time. Only an ignoramus would think that. I see much greater waste in my workplace every week. Im about to go to my annual review but would much rather examine your power rankings. You'll be able to compare it to the actual draft tonight and see how accurate you got it. Then you'll know whether to do it again next year. Good work.

 

[AmellyPies]

Tim Golds will get picked up on the Rookie list. Elevated for Scharenberg.

How many spots do we have?

 

[Stifler's mom]

I hope we nominate Jack Silvagni @ pick 27.

Happy either way if we get him or make Carlton pay more than they wanted to.

 

[AmellyPies]

I hope we nominate Jack Silvagni @ pick 27.

Happy either way if we get him or make Carlton pay more than they wanted to.

Carlton would match faster then they sack a coach. Would be a pisser tho.

 

[unplugged]

Commendable effort. Rest assured - intensely analysing footy and draft stats is never a waste of time. Only an ignoramus would think that. I see much greater waste in my workplace every week. Im about to go to my annual review but would much rather examine your power rankings. You'll be able to compare it to the actual draft tonight and see how accurate you got it. Then you'll know whether to do it again next year. Good work.

I thought it was a good way to pick my "own" draft order without having to pretend I've actually seen any of these kids play!

 

[Apex36]

It's a good point, but would you have ruled our the recruiting Troy Menzel though if he was available or recently offered to us?

2 days ago I would have been good with it. Now not so much.

 

[TradeDraft]

2 days ago I would have been good with it. Now not so much.

Is Say the Medical Staff would of been the Ones to make that Call

 

[Apex36]

Is Say the Medical Staff would of been the Ones to make that Call

I'm pretty sure the medical staff have no bearing on my personal opinion.

 

[TradeDraft]

http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/news/2015-11-24/late-mail-phantom-drafts

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Dream Draft Night

Pick 27 - Ben McKay / Harrison Himmelberg / Daniel Rioli
Pick 64 - Hisham Kerbatieh / Mitch Brown / Declan Mountford
pick 71 - Hine Special

If Hine can draft 3 players at once, e is a genius!

 

[Couch Coach]

I just combined the current phantom drafts of Cal Twomey, Emma Quayle, Sam Landsberger, Knightmare and Snoop Dog and took some averages to get a summarised power rankings.

I did this whole exercise trying to find who we would pick tonight and I feel like I may have wasted my time. QUOTE]

Good work.

Try this one also:
https://hurlingpeoplenow.wordpress.com/2015/11/22/2015-hpn-consensus-phantom-draft-v2-afl/

 

[TradeDraft]

Well - I doubt Hine would let much out

 

[danielnajdek]

Not that excited about the draft tbh.

The fact that Schaz is gone for the year and our first pick is so late.

 

[Quicky]

What time does the draft start? And how is it being telecast?

 

[Crazy Tails]

Tim Golds will get picked up on the Rookie list. Elevated for Scharenberg.

How many spots do we have?

If we go with a list of 38 + 6 we will have four rookie selections. 2 would be for Thomas and Keeffe and 1 for Golds. This would leave 1 uncommitted spot for one live pick. This would become zero if we take an additional ND pick tonight.

 

[AmellyPies]

If we go with a list of 38 + 6 we will have four rookie selections. 2 would be for Thomas and Keeffe and 1 for Golds. This would leave 1 uncommitted spot for one live pick. This would become zero if we take an additional ND pick tonight.

Thanks Tails!

 

[The Dawes]

Not that excited about the draft tbh.

The fact that Schaz is gone for the year and our first pick is so late.

I think we're all a bit deflated from yesterday, but who knows we might end up with a late gem like Swanny or Langdon.

Chin up young man!

 

[TradeDraft]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-11-24/the-draft-show-live