That's not the argument I'm having "Arrow"
You want me to spend my time collating data in a detailed form to disprove my statement?
Surely that can be left to you and others if you suspect it is incorrect
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
That's not the argument I'm having "Arrow"
lmao Trav thinks he's Ben Shapiro. Wtf?
Sold.I can just ban anyone from the thread that is off topic if you'd prefer?
Lever was in the AA squad in his 3rd year. So that is 1Still can't get it right can you
"Weitering's output in the first 3 years of his career, is in the top 3 compared to all other KPD's in the last 10 years, compared to their first 3 years"
Some insight for you Trav, J McGovern, Rance and Talia are not in that top 3, yet some very good players are
Lever was in the AA squad in his 3rd year. So that is 1
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Yep. Lever more disposals, better rating points, same marks and same tackles.Lever was in the AA squad in his 3rd year. So that is 1
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Output, just output, stats, realism
Nothing to do with awards based on people's opinions
stats are overrated though
an extra five kicks in a backwards side ways kicking era doesn't always mean much
You want me to spend my time collating data in a detailed form to disprove my statement?
Surely that can be left to you and others if you suspect it is incorrect
Yep. Lever more disposals, better rating points, same marks and same tackles.
But in fairness he played alongside an AA like Talia and was able to play a less accountable role.
I should add that the above stats are from their first 3 years where they played the exact same amount of games - 56.
Before you worry about your statement being disproved, worry about proving your statement.
Output, just output, stats, realism
Nothing to do with awards based on people's opinions
You must be thinking of Harris Andrews who's only a year older. Head and shoulders, and then some above Weitering.So you picked two of the greats in Neitz and Buddy as a comparison to Weitering? Staggering
How about a comparison with other 4th year KPD's in the last 10 years, where Weitering's output is top 3 compared to his cohorts, playing in a bottom 4 side
Yes his 2018 was less effective, compounded by shoulder and thigh injuries not to mention development is not always linear, yet his second half of the season was solid
If you are making comparisons, use some realism
Ben Keays is a genuine chance to be de-listed after this year.This is my prediction for this draft class rankings after this season and beyond
1 - Clayton Oliver
2 - Charlie Curnow
3 - Harry McKay
4 - Eric Hipwood
5 - Callum Mills
6 - Aaron Francis
7 - Sam Weideman
8 - Josh Dunkley
9 - Jade Gresham
10 - Jacob Weitering
11 - Daniel Rioli
12 - Tom Phillips
13 - Ryan Burton
14 - Tom Doedee
15 - Wayne Milera
16 - Jacob Hopper
17 - David Cuningham
18 - Darcy Parish
19 - Harrison Himmelberg
20 - Ben Keays
And that’s the cop out answer, and code for, “I just made it up”.Information is at your finger tips, just research it
When you’re asking someone to back up their claim with cold hard facts, of course it’s perfectly reasonable.Stop acting entitled. It’s simply not reasonable to ask someone to spend time collating all the stats from the first 3 seasons of every KPD drafted in the last 10 years, to post here for your convenience, when the information is freely available in the public domain.
https://www.footywire.com
Drafts, stats, comparisons, it’s all there.
McGrath is still the best from his draft, though its only 2 years on
Taranto is right at his heels though.
its the hardest pick to get right.
Do you take the stand out kid, do you take a punt, do you go with your most pressing need.
Agree - but the race is far from won. All 3 look like having big years.McCluggage in 2018 caught McGrath and Taranto has overtaken him.