2015 SC NAB Challenge Thread

[SHAKESPEARE]

B Smith -> Goodes?

Might be onto something. Thinking moving my M4 to Goodes. Free cash up all around the joint

 

[Mattrox]

Kingy can eat a dog turd.

Kingy is going to #betmorebulldog

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Collingwood vs Western Bulldogs

131 Marcus Bontempelli

123 Will Minson

121 Brett Goodes

120 Scott Pendlebury

111 Jack Macrae

108 Luke Dahlhaus

106 Steele Sidebottom

104 Tory Dickson

103 Robert Murphy

100 Lin Jong

99 Taylor Adams

98 Marley Williams

92 Mitchell Wallis

88 Matthew Boyd

88 Dane Swan

84 Jamie Elliott

79 Michael Talia

76 Liam Picken

76 Josh Thomas

73 Tom Langdon

72 Jack Redpath

71 Jarrad Grant

69 Jarryd Blair

63 Jackson Ramsay

60 Nathan J. Brown

59 Mitch Honeychurch

58 Ayce Cordy

58 Adam Oxley

58 Levi Greenwood

57 Jake Stringer

56 Tom Boyd

56 Travis Cloke

52 Jesse White

52 Dale Morris

51 Joel Hamling

50 Jordan Roughead

50 Easton Wood

47 Travis Varcoe

43 Brodie Grundy

38 Tyson Goldsack

34 Jack Crisp

33 Jack Frost

29 Alan Toovey

25 Alex Fasolo

23 Caleb Daniel

23 Ben Sinclair

16 Corey Gault

14 Jason Johannisen

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

I currently have the Bont.

Very excited.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

I currently have the Bont.

Very excited.

I always did. All aboard!

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

I always did. All aboard!

TOOT TOOT MOTHER****ERS!

 

[timtamWB]

I thought Minson played pretty badly honestly, that is very surprising.

Waiting for idiots saying how we overpaid for Boyd, disregarding that we're paying him the normal draftee wage this year as well as paying for what he'll bring in a few years

 

[Bont2Bruce]

I thought Minson played pretty badly honestly, that is very surprising.

Waiting for idiots saying how we overpaid for Boyd, disregarding that we're paying him the normal draftee wage this year as well as paying for what he'll bring in a few years

Around the ground yes, he didn't do that much apart from a snap goal in the square.
But he really did dominate the hitouts with 50 and also 5 clearances. Grundy had 22 hitouts.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Was JB worth a million per after just 9 games?

I didn't say he's no good. In time, could even be great...But you don't bank your future on potential alone. Not a million anyway.

I thought Minson played pretty badly honestly, that is very surprising.

Waiting for idiots saying how we overpaid for Boyd, disregarding that we're paying him the normal draftee wage this year as well as paying for what he'll bring in a few years

Not sure what you were waiting for. Just a few posts above yours in fact.

 

[timtamWB]

Around the ground yes, he didn't do that much apart from a snap goal in the square.
But he really did dominate the hitouts with 50 and also 5 clearances. Grundy had 22 hitouts.

Honestly? I didn't really notice him dominating the hitouts at all. I thought he was pretty bad, as I said, and no amount of stats will disprove that.

But the fact is that he was up against Grundy, and at the moment Grundy's not that great in the ruck. I wouldn't be hanging my hat on that.

As for the Boyd post, I missed it. Didn't even have to wait for it!

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Honestly? I didn't really notice him dominating the hitouts at all. I thought he was pretty bad, as I said, and no amount of stats will disprove that.

But the fact is that he was up against Grundy, and at the moment Grundy's not that great in the ruck. I wouldn't be hanging my hat on that.

As for the Boyd post, I missed it. Didn't even have to wait for it!

I don't have the hitouts-to-advantage breakdown, but you are being too harsh on Will tonight. I noticed several really sweet taps straight down the throat of a Dogs player tonight, he was good not bad.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I did'nt think minson was all that good,but though the season he should be a soild scorer.

 

[Mattrox]

I currently have the Bont.

Very excited.

There is an ointment for that now.

#Concerning

 

[Unknown Identity]

Minson Was number 1 for hit outs to advantage in 2013. Locked in R1 for me.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Can i have Minson hits outs with a spinkle of Maric around the ground touches please.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Can i have Minson hits outs with a spinkle of Maric around the ground touches please.

Yup, but you have to pay a bit of extra coin for Mumford.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Yup, but you have to pay a bit of extra coin for Mumford.

Can i pay in sausages.

 

[Two Planks]

He's only played 9 senior games, how good was Johnathon Brown after 9 games?

Hawkins was a spud until something clicked in the finals of his 5th year.

 

[Deliverance]

Swan has looked like crap. And I don't think it's his fault, Buckley has him playing the same stupid role as last year.

Pies fans, what do you think about this theory?He's never adapted to the interchange cap. Seems to me he used to be untaggable because he would Sprint like mad for a few minutes, rack up a few possies and then rest using Kicks revolving door of interchanges. With less rest on the bench, he can't guy run like that anymore. If that's part of the problem, he won't get back to his 100+ average.

 

[Double the Fist]

Can i pay in sausages.

.... can you afford that?

 

[Krujan]

I thought Minson played pretty badly honestly, that is very surprising.
Waiting for idiots saying how we overpaid for Boyd, disregarding that we're paying him the normal draftee wage this year as well as paying for what he'll bring in a few years

You can't say definitively that he will bring anything in a few years. Could have a Gumbleton run with injury from here on and never realise his "potential". Or just be one of those kids who peaked in the TAC Cup & never take the next step. Regardless of what happens from here, no other team has ever paid anywhere near the overs the dogs have for potential alone.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

You can't say definitively that he will bring anything in a few years. Could have a Gumbleton run with injury from here on and never realise his "potential". Or just be one of those kids who peaked in the TAC Cup & never take the next step. Regardless of what happens from here, no other team has ever paid anywhere near the overs the dogs have for potential alone.

Tom Scully and his dad say hi.

 

[Deliverance]

Tom Scully and his dad say hi.

So does Brendan Fevola

 

[Krujan]

So does Brendan Fevola

Fev had 575 goals under his belt @ 3 goals per game before going to Brissy. Then 48 goals from 17 in Brissy that matched his career average. His goal kicking ability didn't cost him his career. He was still only 29 years old when he went to Brisbane. They should have got at least 3 or 4 years of elite goal kicking out of him. Alas, Fev was his own worst enemy. Could have had close to 1000 career goals to his name and been remembered as one of the modern day greats, if it weren't for his pea brain. He was worth the money Brisbane paid for him at the time though.

 

[Krujan]

Tom Scully and his dad say hi.

I was not aware that GWS gave Skully a 7 year deal