Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2015 Trade/Draft/FA - SuperMegaUltraThread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I personally think fringe players at successful clubs can sometimes be overrated. If a player is actually a jet, they will be getting more then 10 games in 5 seasons. See brad hill, hartung etc.

Pupolo had a pretty average season imo, if Anderson was the jet some believe surely he could have got games ahead of him or hartung?

Same thing happens with savage, I remember people thinking he could be answer to our midfield depth and I doubt he would be in our 22.

That being said, sure I'd be happy to get Anderson in. But for a first rounder no chance and can we guarantee him more game time... I don't think so either. He'd have to earn it and there's no guarantees.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Wow just realised Selwood has confirmed the FA move.

Sorry, very behind the 8 ball
 
Jed Anderson has asked if a trade was able to done he would like it done, Eagles are interest.

Heres what id like: 2016 first round and Lycett for Jed and our 3rd pick 2015

What are your thoughts and what would you give.
 
Jed Anderson has asked if a trade was able to done he would like it done, Eagles are interest.

Heres what id like: 2016 first round and Lycett for Jed and our 3rd pick 2015

What are your thoughts and what would you give.
Still drunk from Premiership celebrations?
 
Jed Anderson has asked if a trade was able to done he would like it done, Eagles are interest.

Heres what id like: 2016 first round and Lycett for Jed and our 3rd pick 2015

What are your thoughts and what would you give.

That's the equivalent of two first rounders for a guy who hasn't played that much footy.

As I said on your board, his value to Hawthorn will be greater than his market value, especially considering he is contracted. I don't reckon we will be able to pony up the asking price unless Hawthorn are very lenient for some reason. If he were uncontracted, he could go for a second or third rounder.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Jed Anderson has asked if a trade was able to done he would like it done, Eagles are interest.

Heres what id like: 2016 first round and Lycett for Jed and our 3rd pick 2015

What are your thoughts and what would you give.

Don't think you'll get either our 2016 first rounder or Lycett, let alone both.
He'd likely be a fringe player for us as well.
 
Can't see us parting with Lycett for a fringe mid.

Would only be draft picks, probable 2nd round.

i think Simmo was at the hawks the year we got him, so he knows the potential he has. If he didn't have the serious illnesses, today we could have been saying he was a premiership player as he is in our best 18 when fit
 
Jed Anderson has asked if a trade was able to done he would like it done, Eagles are interest.

Heres what id like: 2016 first round and Lycett for Jed and our 3rd pick 2015

What are your thoughts and what would you give.
Lmao.

Nice joke.
 
i think Simmo was at the hawks the year we got him, so he knows the potential he has. If he didn't have the serious illnesses, today we could have been saying he was a premiership player as he is in our best 18 when fit

That's the equivalent of two first rounders for a guy who hasn't played that much footy.

As I said on your board, his value to Hawthorn will be greater than his market value, especially considering he is contracted. I don't reckon we will be able to pony up the asking price unless Hawthorn are very lenient for some reason. If he were uncontracted, he could go for a second or third rounder.


Refer quoted post below yours
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Jed Anderson has asked if a trade was able to done he would like it done, Eagles are interest.

Heres what id like: 2016 first round and Lycett for Jed and our 3rd pick 2015

What are your thoughts and what would you give.

This kind of post should be ban worthy. I'd rather minson.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top