- Joined
- Oct 11, 2008
- Posts
- 14,010
- Likes
- 5,825
- Location
- Sunbury
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Sunbury Lions
Freeman was rated as an explosive mid who runs straight lines and was a bit selfish with his ball use, would rather kick it long than dish it off. No doubt he was rated a top 10-15 talent in a very strong draft, probably a top 5-10 in most other drafts. What's he worth now? Well Collingwood have played around 47 games since he arrived and he has played the grand total of zero. He has ongoing issues and may not play more than half of next season once fit.
If anyone thinks he is worth more than a third round pick then they are deluded.
Re Carlisle, quite simply, how are they going to pay him at the Dogs? Paying Boyd has totally destroyed their salary cap, he is the price of a Jack Riewoldt AND Nick Riewoldt, think about that! I also think they are paying their ex captain to play at GWS next year also.
If anyone thinks he is worth more than a third round pick then they are deluded.
Re Carlisle, quite simply, how are they going to pay him at the Dogs? Paying Boyd has totally destroyed their salary cap, he is the price of a Jack Riewoldt AND Nick Riewoldt, think about that! I also think they are paying their ex captain to play at GWS next year also.

