Planting my flag here, but:
1. Carlisle has said nothing publicly yet, so no point in flogging him for character flaws until he does and it's 'I'm off to Hawthorn'.
2. If he goes, he does. We shouldn't be held to ransom by him, the media or Dodoro.
3. We can still turn 5 into two picks and grab someone like Collins, or a Skinner type late.
4. IF he turns his back on his own very strongly worded comments - the only direct quotes from him BTW - then we probably didn't want him around our club.
5. Ameet and Trout are widely acknowledged as one of the best teams in the business. I'll trust them.
6. Jay Clark is one of the most shameless EFC mouthpieces around, second only to Slobbo, so take what he says with a grain of salt.
Fin.