I would need to ask you the same question again; Do you believe the club would have been right in giving up two first round picks for Gibb? And, If they did, would you have called it a win and therefore not a failure by the club? Or, would you have said that the club failed by overpaying, as I suspect you would have? I don't think, in all honesty, you could have it both ways.
It was up to us to negotiate with Carlton and get them to agree to a fair trade. I can hear you say but but but they wanted 2 firsts, well if we were good negotiators we would have turned them around.
I would have swapped our two firsts for Gibbs and their 2017 second, that is overs but a fair trade given the circumstances and should have been enough to get the job done.
Anyway this is the pre-season thread and not about Gibbs.

