Nah, he has done alright so far. I'll be honest the late season fade out was a completely shit effort by the club, to be at the top of every predictor for the premiership and then fall in a heap without giving so much as a yelp, verging on unforgivable. Selection policy late in the season contributed to that no doubt, injured players in the 22, players not performing in the 22, it wasn't many, but you don't need to be off by much to lose big in finals, losing 2-3 contests across the ground can cascade, especially if those contests are in the middle. Now in some ways his hands were/are tied, in terms of available personnel, but Pyke could have made these decisions in 2016, to rest players that needed to be rested, but he didn't, or couldn't convince the rest of the selection committee to do it. The big test will be this year of course, can he and the club recognise they made mistakes, learn from those mistakes and then make different decisions at the selection table. If Pyke can make that happen I think he will go on to be a successful head coach, may even get us that long awaited 3rd premiership, but if he can't, he will join the other also ran coaches we have had since Blight (not counting Walsh). Such a significant change in selection policy would certainly be a first since Blight, but thus far I haven't seen much public indication that we are headed that way.