Universal Love 2016/2017 Pre-season Thread

marty36

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Posts
20,948
Likes
7,401
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
It's the coaches and selectors who rate Mackay's AFL performances extremely lowly - it's not just a few posters on here.

What baffles most of us is that Mackay's B&F results are those of a fringe player who gets dropped repeatedly whereas the attitude towards him regarding selection is as though he's a multiple Brownlow medal winning champion.

There is something askew at the club regarding our senior players.

I think you may be over exaggerating. He is in and out of the team his competition if you look at it were like him, in and out fringe players, he wasn't keeping a superstar out of the team.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
May 24, 2006
Posts
50,200
Likes
82,925
Location
Car 55
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
Moderator #1,827
I think you may be over exaggerating. He is in and out of the team his competition if you look at it were like him, in and out fringe players, he wasn't keeping a superstar out of the team.
Among others, he's keeping first round draftees out, the likes of which we apparently cannot survive without - hence no Gibbs
 

marty36

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Posts
20,948
Likes
7,401
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Among others, he's keeping first round draftees out, the likes of which we apparently cannot survive without - hence no Gibbs

Good point

But what will those first rounders offer the team, obviously not ready in the coaches views, who is picking people on who he believes will win games

And going on last years results the coach did his job well
 

GreyCrow

Hall of Famer
Joined
Mar 21, 2016
Posts
44,476
Likes
63,763
Location
Down South Corvus Tristis
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Sturt, Redskins , White Sox
Good point

But what will those first rounders offer the team, obviously not ready in the coaches views, who is picking people on who he believes will win games

And going on last years results the coach did his job well
Actually it will be this years results which will be a reflection on last years coaching.

If Mackay shines then his keeping him in the side is a master stroke. If players are injured or don't perform, and those untried players from last year, who might have had games, don't perform either or perform well below a level. Is that a good thing or a bad thing?

And it wasn't only Mackay, there was a lot of discussion over Thompson and his need for a rest.
 

marty36

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Posts
20,948
Likes
7,401
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Actually it will be this years results which will be a reflection on last years coaching.

If Mackay shines then his keeping him in the side is a master stroke. If players are injured or don't perform, and those untried players from last year, who might have had games, don't perform either or perform well below a level. Is that a good thing or a bad thing?

And it wasn't only Mackay, there was a lot of discussion over Thompson and his need for a rest.

As in life your only as good as your last result, unfortunately for coaches they need consistent results, well Pyke especially as we have an expectation of where we want our team to finish. Different to say Bolton who is in a rebuild mode and can experiment with those untried and unproven players he has, he can afford to play a number of draftees and if they don't cut it and cost him games it's not going to put his job on the line, Pyke is being driven by expectation
 

1970crow

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jun 7, 2011
Posts
26,753
Likes
27,502
Location
alice springs
AFL Club
Adelaide
It's the coaches and selectors who rate Mackay's AFL performances extremely lowly - it's not just a few posters on here.

What baffles most of us is that Mackay's B&F results are those of a fringe player who gets dropped repeatedly whereas the attitude towards him regarding selection is as though he's a multiple Brownlow medal winning champion.

There is something askew at the club regarding our senior players.
The idea that training outweighs SANFL performances is rubbish. Unless it just happens that the best trainers just happen to be the best SANFL performers. Because whenever a player comes up from the SANFL, they're either a returning AFL performer or the player in the best SANFL form. It's just another example of bulkshit being manufactured to explain the gold pass system for mediocre experience holding their spot despite shitful form.
 

James_37

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 19, 2007
Posts
9,788
Likes
9,290
Location
Darwin
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
GCFC/Sturt/MLDFC
Glad to hear the reports of Menzel and Hampton impressing at training. As has bee reported these are two with absolute A-Grade potential who would instantly improve our side if they hit their straps. Also glad to hear Hamptons in the middle, its where we have a need for fast, solidly built players with skill and spread which he offers. Sounds like he's been harassing the coaches for a shot in the midfield and he's going to give it his all to prove himself right.
 

marty36

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Posts
20,948
Likes
7,401
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Glad to hear the reports of Menzel and Hampton impressing at training. As has bee reported these are two with absolute A-Grade potential who would instantly improve our side if they hit their straps. Also glad to hear Hamptons in the middle, its where we have a need for fast, solidly built players with skill and spread which he offers. Sounds like he's been harassing the coaches for a shot in the midfield and he's going to give it his all to prove himself right.

These two clearly could be the improvement we are looking for this year. Having watched Menzel in his early AFL games he showed an enormous about of ability and as proven last year a less amount of application. He sounds like he now has the balance right, who knows could he be the next elite player at ADelaide, I hope so, because we need one to take us to the next level.
 

1990crow

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jan 31, 2009
Posts
17,842
Likes
21,093
AFL Club
Adelaide
Glad to hear the reports of Menzel and Hampton impressing at training. As has bee reported these are two with absolute A-Grade potential who would instantly improve our side if they hit their straps. Also glad to hear Hamptons in the middle, its where we have a need for fast, solidly built players with skill and spread which he offers. Sounds like he's been harassing the coaches for a shot in the midfield and he's going to give it his all to prove himself right.
Yeah I'm stoked. If Mackay gets picked ahead of Hampton I will give up.
Menzel needs to prove himself in a couple of preseason games I think. Not so obvious who he gets picked ahead of.
 

James_37

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 19, 2007
Posts
9,788
Likes
9,290
Location
Darwin
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
GCFC/Sturt/MLDFC
Yeah I'm stoked. If Mackay gets picked ahead of Hampton I will give up.
Menzel needs to prove himself in a couple of preseason games I think. Not so obvious who he gets picked ahead of.
Yeah, I think Mackays spot is possibly were Hampton should be looking. Mackay spent a lot of time in the square in 2016 as we looked for some pace and spread and clean delivery from clearances. Unfortunately it was hardly a success. Well also be looking to replace Lyons and possibly Thommo from the set up, so certainly spots up for grabs.

I think Dougies going to be taken out of the forward set up and Cameron will spend more time on the wing, which will allow Menzel a position as a half forward. We might also push McGovern and Lynch up to the wing at times.
 
Joined
May 21, 2001
Posts
49,537
Likes
38,519
Location
Floating around the Universe
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide Crows
Yeah, I think Mackays spot is possibly were Hampton should be looking. Mackay spent a lot of time in the square in 2016 as we looked for some pace and spread and clean delivery from clearances. Unfortunately it was hardly a success. Well also be looking to replace Lyons and possibly Thommo from the set up, so certainly spots up for grabs.

I think Dougies going to be taken out of the forward set up and Cameron will spend more time on the wing, which will allow Menzel a position as a half forward. We might also push McGovern and Lynch up to the wing at times.
Won't be exact replacements, as we are looking to have deeper rotations with increased flexibility.

Knight, Hampton & Menzel as probable ins.
Lyons, Mackay & Thompson as probable outs.

Hampton looking like a replacement for Thommo, but expect will be inside & outside, as we play more dual mids & 1 less pure insider. Think we will see more of Douglas, Atkins, Knight, Smith, etc increasing their inside minutes.

Menzel replaces Lyons up forward, but will be more outside than Lyons if in the midfield, with others covering Lyons on the inside.

Knight for Mackay gives us that hard gut running player, but more intent.

Would like to see CC & Gov given decent minutes off a wing.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Elite Crow

Premium Platinum
Joined
Mar 21, 2008
Posts
48,515
Likes
63,215
Location
adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Won't be exact replacements, as we are looking to have deeper rotations with increased flexibility.

Knight, Hampton & Menzel as probable ins.
Lyons, Mackay & Thompson as probable outs.

Hampton looking like a replacement for Thommo, but expect will be inside & outside, as we play more dual mids & 1 less pure insider. Think we will see more of Douglas, Atkins, Knight, Smith, etc increasing their inside minutes.

Menzel replaces Lyons up forward, but will be more outside than Lyons if in the midfield, with others covering Lyons on the inside.

Knight for Mackay gives us that hard gut running player, but more intent.

Would like to see CC & Gov given decent minutes off a wing.
Lyons was more midfield than forward, Menzel should replace Douglas.
 
Joined
May 21, 2001
Posts
49,537
Likes
38,519
Location
Floating around the Universe
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide Crows
Lyons was more midfield than forward, Menzel should replace Douglas.
Imo, Lyons was 60%+ in the forward line, but should have been on ball more.

Agree, Douglas should be more on ball, freeing up a forward spot for Menzel

As I mentioned before, won't be like for like replacements.
 

Jack is Back

Premiership Player
Joined
Apr 17, 2013
Posts
3,436
Likes
7,817
AFL Club
Adelaide
A few myths in this thread.

Mackay had a small number of centre square involvements, mostly in the first half of the year. He played 90% of his TOG on the wing, 8% as a defender, less than 2% as an inside midfielder.

We rotated Seedsman, Mackay and Atkins on the wing in the first half of the season. Following Seedsman's injury we used two wingmen, Mackay (except for one game in defence) and Atkins and used Sloane, Brad Crouch and Dougie to soak up the balance of outside mids TOG.

So... I will be more than a little surprised if Hampton who played almost all his time off halfback in the Twos and is training as an inside mid will replace Mackay as an outside mid. If we play two outside mids this year the contenders are The RAT, The SEED, Bran Nue Mackae, Knight, Charlie, Dougie and Milera.

IMHO Hampton is in a showdown with Thommo, CEY and Wigg for an spot as an inside mid. I expect that our improvement will come from our outside mids more than our inside mids.
 

1970crow

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jun 7, 2011
Posts
26,753
Likes
27,502
Location
alice springs
AFL Club
Adelaide
Mackay set up a fair bit just outside the contested area. My guess is that he was meant to provide the speed out of a stoppage once our grunts had won the ball. Inside, inside/outside, outside, it doesn't matter, he's just a bog average performer. Hampton playing inside mid late last year doesn't necessarily mean he's being pigeon-holed into a Thommo replacement or bust scenario. He's obviously got an outside game, so best way to develop him into inside/outside is get him to punch out minutes as an insider. That's where his development has lacked thus far.
 

MRB37

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
May 17, 2009
Posts
21,769
Likes
27,399
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Glenelg
A few myths in this thread.

Mackay had a small number of centre square involvements, mostly in the first half of the year. He played 90% of his TOG on the wing, 8% as a defender, less than 2% as an inside midfielder.

We rotated Seedsman, Mackay and Atkins on the wing in the first half of the season. Following Seedsman's injury we used two wingmen, Mackay (except for one game in defence) and Atkins and used Sloane, Brad Crouch and Dougie to soak up the balance of outside mids TOG.

So... I will be more than a little surprised if Hampton who played almost all his time off halfback in the Twos and is training as an inside mid will replace Mackay as an outside mid. If we play two outside mids this year the contenders are The RAT, The SEED, Bran Nue Mackae, Knight, Charlie, Dougie and Milera.

IMHO Hampton is in a showdown with Thommo, CEY and Wigg for an spot as an inside mid. I expect that our improvement will come from our outside mids more than our inside mids.
Set up the kids for failure if they have them competing for a spot with Thommo since he has an iron grip on his place in the side.
 

Jeffcrowe

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 28, 2014
Posts
13,307
Likes
15,321
AFL Club
Adelaide
Won't be exact replacements, as we are looking to have deeper rotations with increased flexibility.

Knight, Hampton & Menzel as probable ins.
Lyons, Mackay & Thompson as probable outs.

Hampton looking like a replacement for Thommo, but expect will be inside & outside, as we play more dual mids & 1 less pure insider. Think we will see more of Douglas, Atkins, Knight, Smith, etc increasing their inside minutes.

Menzel replaces Lyons up forward, but will be more outside than Lyons if in the midfield, with others covering Lyons on the inside.

Knight for Mackay gives us that hard gut running player, but more intent.

Would like to see CC & Gov given decent minutes off a wing.
Milera is miles ahead of Menzel and Hampton as a first round draft talent but also as a short and long term option for those spots
 

1970crow

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jun 7, 2011
Posts
26,753
Likes
27,502
Location
alice springs
AFL Club
Adelaide
Milera is miles ahead of Menzel and Hampton as a first round draft talent but also as a short and long term option for those spots
Not sure on Menzel, the advantage he should have had is underlying conditioning, but he arrived with zilch. But he's got shit tins of talent, I can't see Milera being a certainty to have his measure in that department.
 
Joined
May 24, 2006
Posts
50,200
Likes
82,925
Location
Car 55
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
Moderator #1,844
Menzel's issue is that the position he's shown aptitude for at AFL level is as a deep forward. There's no spot there with us, which is why we're trying to turn him into a high half forward/winger. Not sure I saw any sign of success with this last year.
 

mistylake

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Mar 21, 2014
Posts
8,574
Likes
7,602
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Norwood, Canadiens, Maroons.
Yeah I'm stoked. If Mackay gets picked ahead of Hampton I will give up.
Menzel needs to prove himself in a couple of preseason games I think. Not so obvious who he gets picked ahead of.
Would we describe Menzel as being a bit like a Robbie Gray type?
I haven't seen him play.
 

Scorpus

Enough is Enough
Joined
Apr 16, 2014
Posts
29,768
Likes
63,170
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
Would we describe Menzel as being a bit like a Robbie Gray type?
I haven't seen him play.
No.

Gray gets a lot more ball around the contest than Menzel. Menzel is more of a Stevie J type forward with fantastic goal sense and the ability to pinch hit at half forward and sometimes in the middle/wing
 
Joined
Oct 31, 2014
Posts
1,710
Likes
3,918
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Miami Heat
Menzel's issue is that the position he's shown aptitude for at AFL level is as a deep forward. There's no spot there with us, which is why we're trying to turn him into a high half forward/winger. Not sure I saw any sign of success with this last year.
Didn't watch long enough unfortunately then DABM. Showed real aptitude as a Mid/Winger in the last 5 weeks of the season once he built a tank and some continuity. Will be a good Wing/Mid/Half Forward in the rotations with sloane and brad crouch.
 

Grenville

All Australian
Joined
Apr 25, 2013
Posts
716
Likes
1,047
AFL Club
Adelaide
A few myths in this thread.

Mackay had a small number of centre square involvements, mostly in the first half of the year. He played 90% of his TOG on the wing, 8% as a defender, less than 2% as an inside midfielder.
Guessing this is just an estimation, but if you know where detailed data like this is publicly available I'd love to know mate?
 
Top Bottom