MVP 2016 COACHES VOTES (with poll)

[JADED]

I've been posting these (generally in the autopsy thread) but as per last years, it is good to have a dedicated thread.
(to be updated when I can. Yes, every player is included in the poll, select "other" if you really think someone else can top our votes)

AFL LEADER BOARD AFTER 23 ROUNDS
AFLCA Leaderboard

Final LEADERBOARD for 2016

121 – PATRICK DANGERFIELD (GEEL)
93 – RORY SLOANE (ADEL)
90 – DUSTIN MARTIN (RICH)
88 – MARCUS BONTEMPELLI (WB)
86 – LUKE PARKER (SYD)
86 – JOEL SELWOOD (Geel)
83 – DAN HANNEBERY (SYD)
82 – LUKE SHUEY (WC)
77 – ROBBIE GRAY (PA)
69 – JOSH KENNEDY (Syd)

Interesting notes,
-From round 5, former eagle Koby Stevens scored a perfect 10 for his 34 disposal, 7 clearance effort against the Lions. (Another former eagle, Matt Rosa did not receive a vote in his clubs loss to the Roos despite doing it all with 29 touches, 7 marks, 2 tackles and 5 hitouts.. Rosa the Ruck)

WCE LEADER BOARD AFTER 23 ROUNDS
(I have added their game score in brackets, as someone like Yeo "could" quite easily top our scoring with 4 or 5 BOG scores of 10 and feature very little in the other rounds, or a mid range scorer could lead our votes getting 5 nearly every week)


82. Luke Shuey (8,6,4,10,10,10,9,6,3,4,10,2,)
69. Josh Kennedy (9,3,3,10,8,4,8,10,6,8,)
55. Andrew Gaff (4,5,5,2,4,8,6,1,10,10,)
47. Matt Priddis (9,9,4,7,2,3,4,2,2,4,1,)
29. Nic Naitanui (6,8,4,1,6,4,)
25. Jeremy McGovern (1,2,2,6,6,2,1,5)
21. Mark LeCras (9,6,3,3,)
13. Shannon Hurn (1,3,3,2,1,3,)
12. Jack Darling (5,7,)
12. Elliot Yeo (1,10,1,)
6. Tom Barrass (6,)
5. Patrick McGinnity (5,)
4. Cripps (1,3,)
4. Mark Hutchings (3,1,)
4. Jack Redden (2,2,)
4. Chris Masten (4,)
3. Sheppard (1,1,1)
3. Johnathon Giles (3,)
1. Samuel Butler (1,)


Coaches votes rd 1, WCE vs BRIS
9. Kennedy (WCE)
9. Priddis (WCE)
6. Naitanui (WCE)
4. Gaff (WCE)
1. Christensen (BRIS)
1. Rich (BRIS)

Coaches votes rd 2, HAW vs WCE
10. Gibson (HAW)
8. Mitchell (HAW)
5. Rioli (HAW)
4. Hartung (HAW)
2. Sicily (HAW)
1. Stratton (HAW)

Coaches votes rd 3, WCE vs FREO
9. Priddis (WCE)
8. Shuey (WCE)
5. Darling (WCE)
5. Gaff (WCE)
2. Fyfe (FREO)
1. Yeo (WCE)

Coaches votes rd 4, WCE vs RICH
10. Yeo (WCE)
7. Darling (WCE)
6. Shuey (WCE)
5. Gaff (WCE)
1. McGovern (WCE)
1. Riewoldt (RICH)

Coaches votes rd 5, SYD vs WCE
10. Richards (SYD)
5. Rampe (SYD)
4. Hannebery (SYD)
3. Kennedy (SYD)
3. Papley (SYD)
2. McGovern (WCE)
2. Parker (SYD)
1. Franklin (SY)

Coaches votes rd 6, WCE vs COLL
9. LeCras (WCE)
8. Naitanui (WCE)
4. Shuey (WCE)
3. Kennedy (WCE)
3. Treloar (Coll)
2. Redden (WCE)
1. Butler (WCE)

Coaches votes rd 7, GEEL vs WCE
10. J.Selwood (GEEL)
8. Motlop (GEEL)
4. Dangerfield (GEEL)
4. Guthrie (GEEL)
3. Blicavs (GEEL)
1. Sheppard (WCE)

Coaches votes rd 8, WCE vs StKilda
10. Shuey (WCE)
6. Lecras (WCE)
4. Naitanui (WCE)
4. Priddis (WCE)
3. Kennedy (WCE)
2. Gaff (WCE)
1. Sheppard (WCE)

Coaches votes rd 9, Port vs WCE
10. Kennedy (WCE)
7. Priddis (WCE)
4. Young (PA)
3. R Gray (PA)
2. Dixon (PA)
2. Wingard (PA)
1. Hurn (WCE)
1. Naitanui (WCE)

Coaches votes rd 10, WCE vs GCS

10. Shuey (WC)
8. Kennedy (WC)
3. Ablett (GC)
3. Hurn (WC)
2. Priddis (WC)
2. Redden (WC)
1. Cripps (WC)
1 Sheppard (WC).

Coaches votes rd 11, WBD vs WCE

8. Bontempelli (WB)
6. Hunter (WB)
5. Liberatore (WB)
5. Macrae (WB)
3. Stringer (WB)
2. Boyd (WB)
1. Suckling (WB).

Coaches votes rd 12, WCE vs ADEL

10. Sloane (Adel)
8. Betts (Adel)
4. Laird (Adel)
3. Lynch (Adel)
3. Priddis (WCE)
2. Jacobs (Adel).

Coaches votes rd 13, BRIS vs WCE

10. Shuey (WCE)
8. Robinson (BL)
4. Gaff (WCE)
4. Kennedy (WCE)
3. Hutchings (WCE)
1. Yeo (WCE).

Round 14 BYE

Coaches votes rd 15, WCE vs ESS

9. Shuey (WCE)
8. Gaff (WCE)
5. McGinnity (WCE)
3. Daniher (Ess)
3. Hurn (WCE)
2. McGovern (WCE)

Coaches votes rd 16 WCE vs NORTH

8. Kennedy (WCE)
6. McGovern (WCE)
6. Shuey (WCE)
4. Goldstein (NM)
3. Cripps (WCE)
2. Hurn (WCE)
1. Brown (NM).

Coaches votes rd 17, CARL vs WCE

9. Docherty (Carl)
6. Gaff (WCE)
6. McGovern (WCE)
3. Le Cras (WCE)
3. Shuey (WCE)
2. Simpson (Carl)
1. Gibbs (Carl).

Coaches votes rd 18 WCE vs MELB

8. Tyson (Melb)
7. N. Jones (Melb)
4. Kent (Melb)
4. Priddis (WCE)
4. Viney (Melb)
2. McGovern (WCE)
1. Hurn (WCE).

Coaches votes rd 19, COLL vs WCE

9. Adams (Coll)
8. Pendlebury (Coll)
4. Treloar (Coll)
3. Grundy (Coll)
3. Sidebottom (Coll)
2. Smith (Coll)
1. Gaff (WCE).

Coaches votes rd 20, FRE vs WCE


10. Kennedy (WCE)
4. Masten (WCE)
4. Shuey (WCE)
3. Hurn (WCE)
3. Le Cras (WCE)
2. Hill (Frem)
2. Priddis (WCE)
1. McGovern (WCE)
1. Sheridan (Frem)


Coaches votes rd 21, GWS vs WCE

10. Shuey (WCE)
8. Lobb (GWS)
6. Naitanui (WCE)
3. Greene (GWS)
2. Priddis (WCE)
1. Griffen (GWS)

Coaches votes rd 22 WCE vs HAW

10. Gaff (WCE)
6. Kennedy (WCE)
5. McGovern (WCE)
4. Naitanui (WCE)
4. Priddis (WCE)
1. Hutchings (WCE).

Coaches votes rd 23, ADEL vs WCE

10. Gaff (WCE)
8. Kennedy (WCE)
6. Barrass (WCE)
3. Giles (WCE)
2. Shuey (WCE)
1. Priddis (WCE).

 

[ioppolo]

Hoping Shuey jumps ahead of Priddis.

 

[DickDunn]

Someone must have a lot of faith in Sheed

 

[Ochre]

Someone must have a lot of faith in Sheed

Two of us idiots actually. I mean them. Damn it.

 

[ioppolo]

No more Shuey love?8

 

[nameless]

You forgot Gaff's 5 votes against Richmond.

 

[kane249]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-05-...gerfield-polls-again-to-take-the-overall-lead

WEST COAST v COLLINGWOOD
9 Mark LeCras (WCE)
8 Nic Naitanui (WCE)
4 Luke Shuey (WCE)
3 Josh Kennedy (WCE)
3 Adam Treloar (Coll)
2 Jack Redden (WCE)
1 Sam Butler (WCE)

 

[nameless]

Reckon Buckley didn't give Shuey any votes because of his ducking?? Hahaha

Loved the table slams from bucks all day.

 

[wce4premiership]

Good to see Buttman recognised.

 

[DanWCE]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-05-...gerfield-polls-again-to-take-the-overall-lead

WEST COAST v COLLINGWOOD
9 Mark LeCras (WCE)
8 Nic Naitanui (WCE)
4 Luke Shuey (WCE)
3 Josh Kennedy (WCE)
3 Adam Treloar (Coll)
2 Jack Redden (WCE)
1 Sam Butler (WCE)

Simmo:
5 Lecca
4 Shuey
3 Nic
2 Redden
1 JK

Nafan:
5 Nic
4 Lecca
3 Treloar
2 JK
1 Butler

Think that adds up. Tough to work out on a Monday arvo

 

[JADED]

Original post updated with round 6 votes.
Shuey moves in to equal 1st position with Priddis.

Coaches votes rd 6, WCE vs COLL
9. LeCras (WCE)
8. Naitanui (WCE)
4. Shuey (WCE)
3. Kennedy (WCE)
3. Treloar (Coll)
2. Redden (WCE)
1. Butler (WCE)

 

[avishka5]

Simmo:
5 Lecca
4 Shuey
3 Nic
2 Redden
1 JK

Nafan:
5 Nic
4 Lecca
3 Treloar
2 JK
1 Butler

Think that adds up. Tough to work out on a Monday arvo

about 83% of trelors touches were in the defensive half. absolute rubbish voting.

 

[JADED]

Shep our only vote getter. Not surprised as we didn't really have a top 5 player on the ground type of day.

Coaches votes rd 7, GEEL vs WCE
10. J.Selwood (GEEL)
8. Motlop (GEEL)
4. Dangerfield (GEEL)
4. Guthrie (GEEL)
3. Blicavs (GEEL)
1. Sheppard (WCE)

No surprise Geelong are flying with Selwood & Dangerfield leading the coaches votes.
We mightn't be travelling that badly, coming up against top teams with league leader / in form players.

 

[fidstar]

Thought Motlop was clearly best. Surprised both coaches gave Selwood BOG.

 

[Chris_6678]

West Coast v St Kilda
10 Shuey (WCE), 6 Le Cras (WCE), 4 Naitanui (WCE), 4 Priddis (WCE), 3 Kennedy (WCE), 2 Gaff (WCE), 1 Sheppard (WCE).

 

[Keys]

So one coach rated Naitanui as 2nd BOG and the other not at all but rated Priddis instead

 

[ZergMinion]

So one coach rated Naitanui as 2nd BOG and the other not at all but rated Priddis instead

I came up with a way to score that so both coaches rated Priddis (mainly to annoy Domo):

5 Shuey
4 Lecras
3 Priddis
2 Gaff
1 Sheppard



5 Shuey
4 Naitanui
3 Kennedy
2 Lecras
1 Priddis

 

[WCErevival]

So one coach rated Naitanui as 2nd BOG and the other not at all but rated Priddis instead

There's a couple of ways it could go

5 Shuey Shuey
4 Natanui Lecras
3 Kennedy Priddis
2 Gaff Lecras
1 Sheppard Priddis
or

5 Shuey Shuey
4 Naitanui Priddis
3 Lecras Lecras
2 Kennedy Gaff
1 Kennedy Sheppard

 

[JADED]

OP updated.
Interesting that we're travelling reasonably well without Gaff being anywhere near a perceived (by coaches) best on ground in any game. (No more that 5 votes)
Pretty surprised at that. Most would have him penciled in for a few standout 10 vote games a year.
Luke Shuey extends his lead. Odds on to add to that this weekend, he plays alright again Port.

 

[ziad]

all this proves is that all polling by humans is subjective

 

[eaglespremiers]

all this proves is that all polling by humans is subjective

Yep coaches voting for WC games is often very perplexing.

 

[DanWCE]

There's a couple of ways it could go

This would account for both coaches voting Nic Keyser Soze

5 Shuey Shuey
4 Priddis Lecras
3 Kennedy Naitanui
2 Lecras Gaff
1 Naitanui Sheppard

 

[Chris_6678]

Port Adelaide vs West Coast

10 Kennedy (WCE)
7 Priddis (WCE)
4 Young (PA)
3 R Gray (PA)
2 Dixon (PA)
2 Wingard (PA)
1 Hurn (WCE)
1 Naitanui (WCE)

 

[eaglespremiers]

I swear Simpson votes while intoxicated.

 

[Matera LeNui]

How on earth Is Lycett not there? Simmo is just focusing on the intricacies of the web...must be