List Mgmt. 2016 Draft, Trades and Retirements Thread

[bedford]

I don't know why you bothered chumpy

 

[The Swans Blog]

It was also a 5yr year contract extension, so its conceivable that the reported deal could cover the full 6 years so even if the deal was $2.5m it would still only be in the vicinity of $416k/yr,

The contract extension was for 5 years, not including the current season. 13-17.

 

[Tedeski]

I don't know why you bothered chumpy

"Sometimes I just get no respect"!

Dangerfield!

The funnier one!

 

[Tesla Tenet]

He reached his potential in 12. Premiership player. WTFDWFT.

Hi Bedford, i generally support your comments but do we have different views of potential.

Reid 2012 season

Games 22
Goals 31 Avg 1.41
Behinds 19 Avg 0.86
Kicks 115 Avg 5.23
Handp 91 Avg 4.14
Disp 206 Avg 9.36

Do you call this as his full potential as KPF. This numbers shows a journeyman to me. A couple of very good/great games and average the rest.

For me, no way close to his full potential.


Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

 

[Tedeski]

The player above get us a late first round draft pick should we trade him.
The player we have today gets us a third round draft pick, early at best!

 

[Mick Oxlong]

The player of both years won't get traded!

 

[Tedeski]

The player of both years won't get traded!

Exactly.
Get him right for 2017 & we have basically 'recruited' a ready made first round draft pick.

 

[Tesla Tenet]

Stats are stats but what do we think about Reid and his role in the team. If he plays in 2017, where do we play him and what do we expect from him.



Can he kick enough goals if KPF or big athletic wing/link player getting about 15-20 possies with maybe a goal a week

 

[The Swans Blog]

Expect him to be a tall winger. Target from a lot of kick outs as well as a link player into the FWD50.

Would allow Franklin to play deeper as well as further up with Reid rotating back into the space.

I don't expect much to be honest. I mostly expect him to be cut.

 

[TripleB]

 

[elastic]

Article from The Rag about Sam Reid signing for 5 years to prevent GWS from swooping
http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/swans-lock-in-reid-for-five-20111216-1oys3.html



That's where the $500k/season comes from.

The funny part of that article is when talking about playing with his brother. Those two could have been playing at the same club the last 3 years and still not managed to play a game together.

 

[Punts]

Would love hartlett and even if it meant reid Had to be traded

 

[The Swans Blog]

Hartlett, what? Looks like someones been puffing on the crack pipe this morning.


Looks like they just make s**t up.

 

[CD__]

Would love hartlett and even if it meant reid Had to be traded

Port are paying him 650k a year supposedly and he's contracted...no way we could afford to pay him that and he's not worth it anyway. He's rarely sighted once the going gets tough.

 

[The Swans Blog]

I read that idiots tweets, he just posts random crap and people follow him. I doubt any of what he says is true.

Like St Kilda bidding for Fyfe.

Seriously. I could make better and more believable crap than he could. His "source" is probably Bay 13 and the club boards here.

 

[The Swans Blog]

And he blocked me, hah. Its all bs.

 

[Superstar swan]

hartlett would be an awesome get..

 

[Mick Oxlong]

And he blocked me, hah. Its all bs.

Yet people still believe that rubbish...see post above!

 

[Dan87]

+1 to chasing Hartlett

 

[miggs]

Port are paying him 650k a year supposedly and he's contracted...no way we could afford to pay him that and he's not worth it anyway. He's rarely sighted once the going gets tough.

Hamish Hartless.

No thanks

 

[Tedeski]

This is why I have a hunch we are in it up to our necks in the recruiting of Fyfe!
Call me mad, but we don't have picks to give up but he will be able to go as a free agent & cost us nothing for the 2018 season.
Come on folks.
Think outside the square!
http://www.sydneyswans.com.au/news/2015-09-29/fyfe-praises-kirks-influence

 

[miggs]

if we dont replace tom or any other players. use next year to get more games into our 7 rookies and then snag fyfe the year after for another tilt at the flag before bud is past his prime. Id be happy with that

 

[Wayne Swan]

Would love hartlett and even if it meant reid Had to be traded

Hartlett NFW! He's on an inflated contract that we would have to honour and I've seen a fair bit of him play, he's a downhill skier, never shows up when the game is a slog.

If we can't afford to pay Mitchell what his ability is worth there can't be any way we are bringing in players on more than $400-450k unless there is a major clearing of depth players like we did in consecutive years to afford Tippett and Buddy.

As for Reid going, he's worth far more to us in upside than what we'd get at the trade table.

 

[stevie26]

Some reports saying that the club might be interested in Zac Tuoey (linked with Mitchell deal). I've always rated this guy. Tough as nails, super reliable, a very good user of the ball and someone we could slot into the backline to release a Jones or Mills into the midfield or Lloyd on a wing or high forward. Would not be the worst deal ever done.

But ... agree that if Fyfe was half a chance for a trade then we should do everything we can to make it happen.

 

[The Swans Blog]

This is why I have a hunch we are in it up to our necks in the recruiting of Fyfe!
Call me mad, but we don't have picks to give up but he will be able to go as a free agent & cost us nothing for the 2018 season.
Come on folks.
Think outside the square!
http://www.sydneyswans.com.au/news/2015-09-29/fyfe-praises-kirks-influence

Of course but 1+1 != 3