This is just a ridiculous way to assess the list .......under your methodology if we had 26 Gary Abletts, and no injuries, then 4 Gary Abletts would be viewed by you as a failure
You have not factored in:
1.lack of injuries in AFL side ....injuries to players in the SANFL.. Otten, Shaw, Menzel (concussions), Hampton
2. Developing players ....Wigg, Milera, Dear, Doedee
3. First Year Cat B players ......Keath, Greenwood
So it seems your comments should be aimed at a small select group of players, that i agree have stagnated on the list whilst they've been leap-frogged .......but what are we talking about maybe 3-4 players only
Regarding Seedsman, fallen out of favor......are you kidding!!! .......injuries are the only reason he's been out & the selectors via the media indicated their desire to have Seedsman in the team ......only injuries prevented his elevation and the senior side winning