MVP 2016 Geelong Board MVP Votes.

[Art Vandelay_]

Hi all,

Games are done for another year so let's count votes and crown our MVP.



Round 1 votes - Geelong v Hawthorn
Round 2 votes - GWS v Geelong
Round 3 votes - Geelong v Brisbane
Round 4 votes - Essendon v Geelong
Round 5 votes - Port Adelaide v Geelong
Round 6 votes - Geelong v Gold Coast
Round 7 votes - Geelong v West Coast
Round 8 votes - Adelaide v Geelong
Round 9 votes - Collingwod v Geelong
Round 10 votes - Carlton v Geelong
Round 11 votes - Geelong v GWS
Round 12 votes - Geelong v North Melbourne
Round 13 votes - Western Bulldogs v Geelong
Round 14 votes - St.Kilda v Geelong
Round 16 votes - Geelong v Sydney
Round 17 votes - Fremantle v Geelong
Round 18 votes - Geelong v Adelaide
Round 19 votes - Geelong v Western Bulldogs
Round 20 votes - Geelong v Essendon
Round 21 votes - Richmond v Geelong
Round 22 votes - Brisbane v Geelong
Round 23 votes - Geelong v Melbourne
2nd Qualifying Final votes - Geelong v Hawthorn
1st Preliminary Final votes - Geelong v Sydney

Steps are pretty straight forward.

1. Post in thread pledging to count a round and specify what round. Do this by copying and pasting the list of matches and assigning yourself a round. Next poster copy and pastes the previous poster and adds his/her round and so on.
2.Download and save the googledrive spreadsheet

Spreadsheet:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B0q-guEUvY6cVGo2dk5QRjNXV0E/view?usp=sharing

3.Use the list of rounds above, which are links to the MVP threads to access votes to find your round of voting.

4. Only count votes that adhere to the 5-4-3-2-1 format.
5. After counting each posters votes the 'Raw total' tab should automatically update votes for each player. At the completion of vote counting PM dazbroncos and myself with the results in full.
e.g Selwood 56 Dangerfield 40 Bartel 5 Taylor 22 etc etc.
NOTE: If doing more than 1 round just send one PM with all votes collected.

**Lastly the MVP format**

The 3 players for each match with the most votes will be awarded 3-2-1 accordingly. Most votes after all games are counted is the Geelong Board MVP.

 

[GeelongFTW]

1. paddy
2. selwood

done-no counting required.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

1. paddy
2. selwood

done-no counting required.

ha di ha ha ha.
Easier to be a smartarse when you have two heads

 

[Vdubs]

Seriously, why bother this year? It is so clear cut.
1.Danger
2.Selwood
3.Boris

 

[Hoooops]

Congratulations Patrick Dangerfield.

 

[Frank Bunn]

Happy to do round 1 and the qualifying final as beating Hawthorn is the bestest fun.

Doctor Gero I downloaded the spreadsheet but the Raw votes column didn't seem to update. #computersaidno

And maybe it would speed the process if Danger and Joel were moved to the top of the spreadsheet

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Seriously, why bother this year? It is so clear cut.
1.Danger
2.Selwood
3.Boris

Congratulations Patrick Dangerfield.

Firstly, I'm interested to see how close our top 10 is to that of B&F.
Secondly I offered to do this myself. Was told to share and let everyone contribute.

Happy to do round 1 and the qualifying final as beating Hawthorn is the bestest fun.

Doctor Gero I downloaded the spreadsheet but the Raw votes column didn't seem to update. #computersaidno

And maybe it would speed the process if Danger and Joel were moved to the top of the spreadsheet

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B0q-guEUvY6cVGo2dk5QRjNXV0E/view?usp=sharing

Fixed

 

[Lana]

Hi all,
The 3 players for each match with the most votes will be awarded 3-2-1 accordingly. Most votes after all games are counted is the Geelong Board MVP.

Before voting commences can I suggest the 3-2-1 votes system gets changed to a 5-4-3-2-1 or a 7-6-5-4-3-2-1 System or even a 10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 system. Otherwise it doesn't give mid ranged players a chance to poll votes, The top 10 wont be that interesting when we have the 6 to 10th players polling between 1 and 6 votes. The higher the better. If we use the 10 system and we have less than 10 players poll we don't award points on the lower end.

 

[AM]

Firstly, I'm interested to see how close our top 10 is to that of B&F.
Secondly I offered to do this myself. Was told to share and let everyone contribute.

Doc! In footy parlance, always take the first option.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Before voting commences can I suggest the 3-2-1 votes system gets changed to a 5-4-3-2-1 or a 7-6-5-4-3-2-1 System or even a 10-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 system. Otherwise it doesn't give mid ranged players a chance to poll votes, The top 10 wont be that interesting when we have the 6 to 10th players polling between 1 and 6 votes. The higher the better. If we use the 10 system and we have less than 10 players poll we don't award points on the lower end.

I guess for comparison It wouldn't take me long to do both in truth (privately). Happy to go with whatever is more accurate. Just know this was the system used in the past.

Doc! In footy parlance, always take the first option.

and I paid for it. Paid with a Blicavs like hospital handpass

 

[catempire]

We are not really getting anywhere here are we?

If there's no appetite to share it around Doctor Gero can do it himself as he offered to do so.

I have added a poll, open for the next 24 hours, to give people the opportunity to have a say.








PS. This is the off-season. We have heaps of time to do meaningless s**t like this.

 

[Lana]

We are not really getting anywhere here are we?

If there's no appetite to share it around Doctor Gero can do it himself as he offered to do so.

I have added a poll, open for the next 24 hours, to give people the opportunity to have a say.








PS. This is the off-season. We have heaps of time to do meaningless s**t like this.

I've done the finals just finalizing the the voting system

 

[catempire]

I've done the finals just finalizing the the voting system

The voting system is 5-4-3-2-1 as it has always been.

 

[Lana]

I guess for comparison It wouldn't take me long to do both in truth (privately). Happy to go with whatever is more accurate. Just know this was the system used in the past.

Pretty sure last year we just counted the raw votes and that was it.

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/thre...-mvp-final-results-and-winners.1114624/page-2

Blicavs won with almost 1000 votes

 

[Art Vandelay_]

The voting system is 5-4-3-2-1 as it has always been.

nah, what used to happen when SJ did this was that we added up all the votes.
Eg. Danger 50, Sel 55 Boris 40 Linc 12 etc
You end up with all players ranked by votes.
Most votes would get the 3 votes (Selwood). 2nd the 2 (danger) and 3rd the 1 (boris). Most of these votes is the winner.

In a way it was a democratically voted Brownlow style vote. What that did was eliminate errors which can be borne out of inconsistent number of voters per game. This is largely going to be moot for the winner but it can distort the results.

What lana is suggesting is to broaden the range of affixed votes based of aggregate numbers.

 

[Lana]

In any case



Round 23 v Melbourne (26 voters)
Name Votes
Dangerfield 112
Selwood 105
Hawkins 66
Menzel 43
Menegola 34
Bartel 7
Taylor 6
Bews 5
Caddy 5
Ruggles 3
Blicavs 1
Motlop 1
Guthrie 1


Qualifying final (33 voters)

Name Votes
Selwood 146
Guthrie 121
Hawkins 83
Dangerfield 34
Blicavs 33
Menegola 28
McCarthy 24
Lonergan 15
S.Selwood 3
Caddy 2
Motlop 2
Duncan 2
Mackie 1

Preliminary final (6 voters)

Name Votes
Selwood 30
Dangerfield 19
Bews 11
Lonergan 10
Bartel 7
Guthrie 5
Taylor 3
Enright 3
Duncan 2

 

[catempire]

nah, what used to happen when SJ did this was that we added up all the votes.
Eg. Danger 50, Sel 55 Boris 40 Linc 12 etc
You end up with all players ranked by votes.
Most votes would get the 3 votes (Selwood). 2nd the 2 (danger) and 3rd the 1 (boris). Most of these votes is the winner.

In a way it was a democratically voted Brownlow style vote. What that did was eliminate errors which can be borne out of inconsistent number of voters per game. This is largely going to be moot for the winner but it can distort the results.

What lana is suggesting is to broaden the range of affixed votes based of aggregate numbers.

I understand that. Why are we talking about changing it now?

 

[catempire]

So far "share it around" is dominating the poll.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

I understand that. Why are we talking about changing it now?

I'm not necessarily. Lana made a suggestion, I'm not so arrogant as to merely dismiss it under the premise that my way is better.
I'm happy with whatever is easiest/most accurate.

 

[catempire]

*bump*

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Round 1



GEELONG 4.0 11.1 11.4 18.8 (116)
HAWTHORN 1.2 5.7 10.12 12.14 (86)
GOALS
Geelong: Smith 3, Caddy 3, Lang 3, McCarthy 2, Hawkins 2, Motlop, Blicavs, Guthrie, Murdoch
Hawthorn: Puopolo 3, Gunston 3, Langford 2, Breust 2, Burgoyne, Hartung

BEST
Geelong: Dangerfield, Blicavs, Guthrie, Caddy, Duncan, Lang, Selwood
Hawthorn: Mitchell, Frawley, Puopolo, Lewis, Gibson, Burgoyne, Hartung

INJURIES
Geelong: Nil
Hawthorn: Luke Hodge (suspected broken right arm)

Reports: Mitch Duncan (Geelong) reported for rough conduct against Luke Hodge (Hawthorn) in the fourth quarter.

Umpires: Findlay, Jeffery, Mollison

Official crowd: 74,218 at the MCG


5.Patrick Dangerfield 263
4.Zac Smith 135
3.Mark Blicavs 107
2.Josh Caddy 104
1.Cameron Guthrie 69
Mitch Duncan 61
Darcy Lang 36
Joel Selwood 9
Jimmy Bartel 3
Rhys Stanley 3
Lincoln McCarthy 2
Corey Enright 1
Andrew Mackie 1
Harry Taylor 1
Jake Kolodjashnij 1

Votes counted by sorted

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Round 2






GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY 2.1 8.4 12.8 13.11 (89)
GEELONG 1.5 5.7 8.8 11.10 (76)
GOALS
Greater Western Sydney: Griffen 2, Smith 2, Johnson 2, Wilson, Coniglio, Shiel, Scully, Mumford, Hoskin-Elliott, Lobb
Geelong: Hawkins 3, Blicavs 2, Stanley 2, Lang, McCarthy, Caddy, Gregson
BEST
Greater Western Sydney: Griffen, Scully, Mumford, Johnson, Kelly, Greene
Geelong: Hawkins, Blicavs, Mackie, Enright, Guthrie, Lang
INJURIES
Greater Western Sydney: Marchbank (ankle)
Geelong: TBC
Reports: Nil
Umpires: Stevic, Fleer, Mitchell
Official crowd: 13,656 at Manuka Oval

5. Mark Blicavs 85
4. Tom Hawkins 65
3. Cameron Guthrie 55
2. Corey Enright 42
1. Darcy Lang 40
Andrew Mackie 17
Rhys Stanley 15
Jimmy Bartel 5
Patrick Dangerfield 2
Harry Taylor 1
Joel Selwood 1
Josh Caddy 1

Running Tally:
Blicavs 8
Dangerfield 5
Hawkins 4
Guthrie 4
Smith 4
Enright 2
Caddy 2
Lang 1

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Round 3



GEELONG 6.2 10.5 12.14 18.17 (125)
BRISBANE LIONS 1.5 3.9 6.11 7.14 (56)

GOALS
Geelong: Hawkins 4, Dangerfield 3, Kersten 3, McCarthy 2, Motlop 2, Menzel, Blicavs, Duncan, Bartel
Brisbane Lions: Bell 2, Taylor, Bastinac, McStay, Martin, Green

BEST
Geelong: Selwood, Dangerfield, Duncan, Enright, Motlop, Hawkins, Ruggles
Brisbane Lions: Bell, Robinson, Zorko, Hanley, Martin

INJURIES
Geelong: Nil
Brisbane Lions: Nil

Reports: Mitch Robinson (Brisbane Lions) for engaging in rough conduct on Joel Selwood (Geelong)

Umpires: Findlay, Jeffery, Mollison

Official crowd: 23,320 at Simonds Stadium


Votes:
5. Joel Selwood 105
4. Patrick Dangerfield 85
3. Corey Enright 69
2. Mitch Duncan 24
1. Tom Hawkins 22
Jimmy Bartel 9
Mark Blicavs 9
Tom Ruggles 9
Steven Motlop 4
Cameron Guthrie 2
Daniel Menzel 2
Shane Kersten 2
Lincoln McCarthy 1



Running Tally:
Dangerfield 9
Blicavs 8
Selwood 5
Hawkins 5
Enright 5
Guthrie 4
Smith 4
Duncan 2
Caddy 2
Lang 1

 

[Lana]

Lana's better running total

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Round 4



ESSENDON 2.2 5.4 6.5 6.6 (42)
GEELONG 2.3 5.6 6.13 9.18 (72)
GOALS
Essendon: Zaharakis, Laverde, Merrett, Brown, Fantasia, Stokes
Geelong: Motlop 2, Caddy, Stanley, Gregson, Cockatoo, Bartel, Lang, Smith
BEST
Essendon: Zaharakis, Merrett, Hartley, Cooney, McDonald-Tipungwuti
Geelong: Duncan, Dangerfield, Selwood, Lonergan, Taylor, Motlop, Caddy
INJURIES
Essendon: Jayden Laverde (shoulder), Mitch Brown (nose)
Geelong: Shane Kersten (calf) replaced in selected side by Jake Kolodjashnij
Reports: Nil
Umpires: Hay, McInerney, Mitchell
Official crowd: 42,723 at the MCG

5. Lachie Henderson 117
4. Steven Motlop 73
3. Tom Lonergan 63
2. Nakia Cockatoo 50
1. Mitch Duncan 47
Josh Caddy 42
Cameron Guthrie 36
Patrick Dangerfield 34
Harry Taylor 29
Joel Selwood 23
Andrew Mackie 21
Daniel Menzel 9
Darcy Lang 6
Tom Ruggles 2

Running Tally:
Dangerfield 9
Blicavs 8
Selwood 5
Hawkins 5
Henderson 5
Enright 5
Guthrie 4
Motlop 4
Smith 4
Lonergan 3
Duncan 3
Caddy 2
Cockatoo 2
Lang 1