2016 Rate My Team

[Plastic_Hawk9]

Name: Fantasy Shredder (i hope)
Cash remaining: $27k

Defence: Boyd, Shaw, Laird, Bonner, byrne, hartley, (weitering, broad)

Midfield: Rockliff, T Mitchell, Ablett, Liberatore, O'Meara, Parish, Mills, Oliver, (N Freeman, Mathieson)

Ruck: Martin, Goldstein, (S frost, Naismith)

Forward: D Martin, Franklin, Petracca, Kerridge, C Curnow, D Rioli, (H McKay, Schache)

Note: Forward line is weak imo

 

[BigVic]

Is anyone going Wells?

No way for me. He's a pass. Lumumba is a "never again" player

 

[BigVic]

TEAM NAME: Big V Superstars
DEF: J Bartel, K Kolodjashnij, E Yeo, B Smith, M W Brown, Mitch Hibberd (C Byrne, M Hartley)
MID: S Pendlebury, P Dangerfield, G Ablett, T Rockliff, T Liberatore, J Gresham, M Kennedy, R Mathieson (S Menegola, J Jansen)
RUC: S Martin, M Lobbe (M Cox, D Currie)
FWD: D Martin, B Deledio, M Barlow, C Bird, C Petracca, J Anderson (T Phillips, N Kommer)
REMAINING SALARY: $56,000

Happy with my team. Last change before the NAB rolls in.

Bartel vs Shaw
Martin vs Goldstein
Yeo vs Simpson

 

[getgaff]

First attempt at 2016 team for If the Shuey fits (no doubt it will change) - $119,00 left over

BACKS: Boyd, Laird. Simpson, Salem, M. Brown (ESS), Adams (Josh Wagner, Broad)

MIDFIELDERS: Ablett, Rockliff, Parker, Patrick Cripps, Hopper, Petracca, David Cunningham, Gore (Mathieson, Tom Phillips)

RUCKS: Stefan Martin, Leuenberger (Loersch, Korcheck)

FORWARDS: Dustin Martin, Dahlhaus, Wingard, Shane Edwards, Laverde, Kerridge (Fitzpatrick, Kommer)

Attempt # 2 for If the Shuey fits

BACKS: Boyd ~ Simpson/ Bartel ~ Yeo ~ Rosa/ KK, Aish, Byrne (Josh Wagner, Broad)

MIDFIDLERS: Ablett, Rockliff, Patrick Cripps, Liberatore, Zaharkis, Hartung, Gresham, Morabito (Mathieson, Marcon)

RUCKS: Stefan Martin, Lobbe (Loersch, Korcheck)

FORWARDS: Barlow, Wingard, Greene, Shane Edwards, Petracca, Kommer (O'Brien, Gallucci)

• Simpson V Bartel - Simpson a bit cheaper but I'll monitor both during NAB Cup. The DPP on Bartel makes him an attractive option.

• Rosa V KK - Gone the cheaper and DPP option of Rosa for the 4th back.

• Any Hawks fans can give an inside info on who is going to replace Roughead inside 50. I'm thinking O'Brien or even Fitzpatrick as a guy that can play deep forward and ruck inside 50.

 

[Coaster2012]

DEF: H Shaw, E Yeo, K Kolodjashnij, P Seedsman, M Brown, M Hibberd (C Byrne, T Mohr)
MID: G Ablett, N Fyfe, T Rockliff, A Gaff, L Parker, O Wines, B Keays, A Morabito (J Jansen, D Gore)
RUCK: S Jacobs, B Grundy (M Cox, D Currie)
FWD: D Martin, L Dahlhaus, C Bird, C Petracca, J Simpkin, J Anderson (N Kommer, T Phillips)

Think my forward line might be a little light on power, but I think my midfield makes up for it. What you think?

 

[Drewie11]

Boyd, shaw, laird, kk, francis, aish (byrne, hartley)

Ablett, rockliff, gibbs, duncan, libba, b crouch, anderson, b kennedy ( menegola, gore)

Lobbe, luey (currie, obrien)

Martin, greene, s gray, bird, McLean, petracca (ahern, kommer)

Bit worried about some of my mid priced midfielders but could pay off. So overall pretty happy until nab kicks off

 

[Spank2304]

Team Name: The Spanka's
BACKS: K. Kolo, Yeo, Rosa, Aish, Z Jones, M Brown(Ess) (Hibberd, Byrne)
MIDS: Rocky, Ablett, Pendles, Wines, Gibbs, Libba, Duggan, M Kennedy (Morabito, Menegola)
RUCK: Martin, Blicavs (Cox, Naismith)
FWD: Barlow, Greene, Bird, Leuenberger, Petracca, Anderson (Kommer, Phillips)

Tossing up between a few options for some of the spots, bench spots are def still up for grabs.
Anderson vs B.Kennedy
Gibbs vs O'Meara vs B.Crouch
M Kennedy vs Gresham vs ??
Not too sure about Z.Jones but I would think he would be getting games

 

[Spank2304]

DEF: H Shaw, E Yeo, K Kolodjashnij, P Seedsman, M Brown, M Hibberd (C Byrne, T Mohr)
MID: G Ablett, N Fyfe, T Rockliff, A Gaff, L Parker, O Wines, B Keays, A Morabito (J Jansen, D Gore)
RUCK: S Jacobs, B Grundy (M Cox, D Currie)
FWD: D Martin, L Dahlhaus, C Bird, C Petracca, J Simpkin, J Anderson (N Kommer, T Phillips)

Think my forward line might be a little light on power, but I think my midfield makes up for it. What you think?

I don't mind it, the mid priced forwards you have should go up in value as long as they play. Not interested in any of the "fallen premium" mids tho?

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Any suggestions appreciated.

Balance: 111,000

 

[VSTone]

to all those picking Kommer...is he over the leg issues?

 

[getgaff]

Any suggestions appreciated.

Balance: 111,000

View attachment 212859

Just my opinion but I think you've got one to many rookie backs there. Look to replace Harley with Brown (ESS) or Hibberd maybe. Hartley be a KPP most likely down back so scores won't be high.

If you downgrade Jack Steven to Patrick Cripps (under 500k), take Jon Simpkin out of the midfield and use him to replace Reece Conca inside 50 that should allow you to trade in a best 22 lock defender like Brodie Smith or Matt Rosa who should average well.

Not sold on Bryce Gibbs yet either, in a great position to increase price quickly but you can get Jeager O'Meara or Brad Crouch for cheaper.

 

[getgaff]

View attachment 212860

first crack at it not many i liked it the back or forwards which is a good excuse to put some mid pricers in then i can grab all the big dawgs in the mids

Strong midfield, only fault that except maybe its even to strong. Keep Ablett, Fyfe and Rockliff if you like but downgrade on one or both of Steven or Hodge to a cheaper midfielder. Patrick Cripps a great option as are O'Meara and B. Crouch

Weaker in the back and forward halfs. Conca, Lowden, Silvagni as well as Montagna and try to build the forward line with guys like Wingard, Greene, Titch Edwards along with Martin

 

[One_Wing]

First time doing Fantasy, thoughts?

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

Supercoach:

Backs: Yeo, Rosa, A. Walker (def/fwd), Seedsman (def/mid), Aish (def/mid), Hampton. Bench: Byrne, Viojo-Rainbow

Mids: Ablett, D Martin (mid/fwd), Neale, Steven, Rockliff, D Swallow, A Moore, Kerridge (mid/fwd), Willis (mid/fwd), Hibberd (def/mid), Cole (def/mid)

Rucks: Lobbe, Sinclair (ruck/fwd), M King (ruck/fwd)

Fwds: Bennell (mid/fwd), T. Walker, Greene (mid/fwd), LeCras, Leuenberger (ruck/fwd), Vardy (ruck/fwd), M Brown (def/fwd), M Adams (def/fwd)

 

[Fitzey]

Is there something I have missed in regards on all of the Conca selections?

 

[Blinger]

Is there something I have missed in regards on all of the Conca selections?

He is priced 15-20 pts below what he would average normally & would be a good stepping stone for a premium. For me he is a big risk for job security & whether he can stay injury free, high risk, good reward if he plays lots of games.

 

[mezaire]

First time doing Fantasy, thoughts? View attachment 212932

First of all sort your team from highest to lowest dollar value like the others you see here.
Interesting team, Wood is a DT dud at that price

 

[Iamcarlton]

You get a captaincy loop hole only in weeks with Thursday night games, as there is a partial lockout until the friday night game. That's also different to Supercoach, there is no rolling lockout and teams are set at bouncedown on Friday

Yep and that's exactly why super coach is better there is much more flexibility unlike fantasy .

 

[Iamcarlton]

on my never again list FBI... too many risk factors...dodgy body + age

At the price he's at if he does stay fit you may well regret not having wells in particular going by the news he's training well . Worth the punt I reckon if doesn't work dump him and not much lost ?

 

[VSTone]

At the price he's at if he does stay fit you may well regret not having wells in particular going by the news he's training well . Worth the punt I reckon if doesn't work dump him and not much lost ?

he has done quite a few rip it up pre-seasons before... way too fragile for me

 

[bluelad]

First crack for 2016. 34k In the bank.

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Team Name: The Spanka's
BACKS: K. Kolo, Yeo, Rosa, Aish, Z Jones, M Brown(Ess) (Hibberd, Byrne)
MIDS: Rocky, Ablett, Pendles, Wines, Gibbs, Libba, Duggan, M Kennedy (Morabito, Menegola)
RUCK: Martin, Blicavs (Cox, Naismith)
FWD: Barlow, Greene, Bird, Leuenberger, Petracca, Anderson (Kommer, Phillips)

Tossing up between a few options for some of the spots, bench spots are def still up for grabs.
Anderson vs B.Kennedy
Gibbs vs O'Meara vs B.Crouch
M Kennedy vs Gresham vs ??
Not too sure about Z.Jones but I would think he would be getting games

Injury interrupted preseason for ZJones, pass.
If you want Leuenberger, start him as R2 if not don't start him at all.
I'd choose Gibbs over the other two.

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

Any suggestions appreciated.

Balance: 111,000

View attachment 212859

Biggest concern for me would be too much money in the forward line and too little down back. The back rookies suck this year while we have some great mid rookies who got forward eligibility this year.
I would consider turning Conca> Kennedy/Anderson or even paul ahern and Trade Brown to a Rosa/Rich or kolojashnij if you have the funds.

ps Hams>Kommer

Just my opinion but I think you've got one to many rookie backs there. Look to replace Harley with Brown (ESS) or Hibberd maybe. Hartley be a KPP most likely down back so scores won't be high.

If you downgrade Jack Steven to Patrick Cripps (under 500k), take Jon Simpkin out of the midfield and use him to replace Reece Conca inside 50 that should allow you to trade in a best 22 lock defender like Brodie Smith or Matt Rosa who should average well.

Not sold on Bryce Gibbs yet either, in a great position to increase price quickly but you can get Jeager O'Meara or Brad Crouch for cheaper.

Disagree, for 34k more you can have a more proven Gibbs who has gone 100+ twice in his career and isn't coming off major injuries like the other two.

However if this was RDT or SC the 100k+ difference between them would incline me to go for B Crouch.

 

[Wymo]

Gday Lads. Thought I'd post my current team. Open to any suggestions.

DEF: McVeigh, Shaw, Bartel, Rosa, M.Brown, Hibberd (Mohr, Byrne)
MID: Hennebery, Rockliff, Ablett, I.Smith, Liberatore, Hartung, Gresham, Keays (Menegola, Jansen)
RUC: Jacobs, Lobbe (Currie, Cox)
FWD: Martin, Bell, Greene, Petracca, Simpkin, Anderson (Sumner, T.Phillips)

$20k in the bank.

 

[Jars458]

First go for 2016.