Here's a doozy (shit, sorry) of a post from our favourite mod:
I literally can't even.
Being an expert on these kinds of trades I can confirm this poster has NFI.
He alludes to the fact that even if all we give for Caddy is pick 24 it doesn't mean that Geelong don't get a first round pick. He then contradicts himself by suggesting we will give GWS pick 24 and 27 to ensure they send pick 15 to Geelong.
Then he goes into something that involves their picks getting downgraded so GWS get some points.
Anyways I can solve his little problem without it actually costing us 2 second round picks
We trade Geelong pick 24 for Caddy
Geelong trade GWS pick 24 + 42 for Pick 15 this gives GWS a net gain of 68 points.
Geelong also cover off one of their two required firsts (unless they have to be next year).