List Mgmt. 2016 Trade Thread

[Sir Hugh Percy]

According to the live trade chat happening right now on the AFL site apparently the swans are into TMac. How the heckarooney would they fit him under their cap?
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-06-23/chat-live-with-aflcomaus-free-agency-expert-nick-bowen

Bowen also said (in his opinion) "Michael Hibberd is likely to be at the Dees next year. Dion Prestia also in Melbourne's sights."

 

[Yoda_]

Would happily accept your second rounder for Hibbo.

3rd rounder and Hullet?

 

[ThaiBarmats]

Trade predictions 2017...

Ins - Michael Hibberd (Ess), Dion Prestia (GC), L Neale (Fre), J Hannah (Fre).
Outs:- J Hogan (Fre), T Mac (Syd), J Trengove, J Grimes

2017 Team:-
FB:- Jetta, O Mac, Bugg
HB:- Vince, Hibberd, Melksham
Ct:- Tyson, Jones, Brayshaw
HF:- Petracca, Watts, Viney
FF:- Garlett, Weltering, Dawes
Ru:- Gawn, L Neale, Prestia
Bench/Emg:- Frost, Kent, Hunt, Vanderberg, Kennedy, Oliver etc

But I live in Thailand, so I know nothing...Lol

 

[Proper Gander]

Bowen also said (in his opinion) "Michael Hibberd is likely to be at the Dees next year. Dion Prestia also in Melbourne's sights."

Nice to have a bit of trade hype for a change. Seems marginally more authentic the Danger to Melbourne stuff. Interesting times.

 

[schmuttt]

On reflection Proper Gander I don't think Jesse made a statement about his contract at all, they just assumed he meant early 2017 when he said it a while back. Like really, we would have gotten a lot more news on it (The Freo board would be frothing at the mouth).

 

[Tempy Tiger]

Trade predictions 2017...

Ins - Michael Hibberd (Ess), Dion Prestia (GC), L Neale (Fre), J Hannah (Fre).
Outs:- J Hogan (Fre), T Mac (Syd), J Trengove, J Grimes

2017 Team:-
FB:- Jetta, O Mac, Bugg
HB:- Vince, Hibberd, Melksham
Ct:- Tyson, Jones, Brayshaw
HF:- Petracca, Watts, Viney
FF:- Garlett, Weltering, Dawes
Ru:- Gawn, L Neale, Prestia
Bench/Emg:- Frost, Kent, Hunt, Vanderberg, Kennedy, Oliver etc

But I live in Thailand, so I know nothing...Lol

Couple of comments. Assume your going with Weideman at FF rather than Weitering? Also Hibbard is not key position size is he? I thought he was only just six foot?
If we lose Hogan and TMAC abandon ship.

 

[Demon 16]

What happened with Hogan? I missed it.

 

[PerfectFooty]

What happened with Hogan? I missed it.

Word is contracts talks have been pushed to early 2017.

I call BS because nothing has been reported yet

 

[mrmonkey]

This reminds me of the IT crowd episode with the tradie from hell. Jen has a tradie in her house and Roy is 98% sure he saw him on tradies from hell urinating in the sink. Each time Roy talks about it, the percentage goes down until the end of the episode he says actually now that I think about it, I think he was black.

 

[Topkent]

Us getting Prestia for mine says we dont have alot of faith in ANB and Trenners becoming gun inside players, or conversely we think he is a far better player than we could ever draft with our next first rounder which might be smart business

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

I'd be disappointed if we got Prestia without throwing whatever we get him with at Hurley first.

 

[ThaiBarmats]

Trade predictions 2017 mod 1 -
FREMANTLE star Lachie Neale has ended months of speculation by signing a three-year contract extension with Fremantle.
Ok, back to drawing board.
Ins - Michael Hibberd (Ess) or every quiet trade period. Above well informed posters correct. Must keep Hoges/Mac. Dion Prestia (GC) unlikely. Just cannot see how we can do a deal. Richmond more likely.
2017 Team:-
FB:- Jetta, O Mac, Bugg
HB:- Hibberd, T Mac, Melksham
Ct:- Vince, Tyson, Brayshaw
HF:- Petracca, Watts, Viney
FF:- Garlett, Hogan, Weideman
Ru:- Gawn, Jones, Oliver
Bench/Emg:- Frost, Kent, Hunt, Vander, Kennedy etc

 

[Demon 16]

Our future first round pick trade for Weideman is starting to look a rather inspired decision.

You could throw a blanket over the top 10-12 picks this year, and none of them are a tall forward.

 

[Captain Jack]

One possibility is Mitchell isn't retained. Another is the retirements of Richards and McGlynn, combined with likely player movements such as Jake Lloyd and Tom Derickx

I think there's the possibility of a reasonable contract, but I doubt we'll come close to a Demons offer if they want him enough and Mitchell stays.

Where is Lloyd going Dan87? I like the look of him as an efficient winger type.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Our future first round pick trade for Weideman is starting to look a rather inspired decision.

You could throw a blanket over the top 10-12 picks this year, and none of them are a tall forward.

I thought it was common knowledge that the club wanted another KPF, and given the lack this year decided to grab one of the boys on offer last year.

 

[The Dr]

I wonder if Pearce Hanley could be a target? Seems completely unhappy this year and at his best offers the pace and line-breaking we need. 27yo. I wonder if the Lions would be open to a trade?

 

[Dan87]

Where is Lloyd going Dan87? I like the look of him as an efficient winger type.

He remains unsigned so there's a chance hes on the way back to Victoria IMO.
Good list fit for the Dees I agree.

 

[LeverPuller]

Does anyone think we will get a pick for Grimes? I doubt it

 

[schmuttt]

Does anyone think we will get a pick for Grimes? I doubt it

Nope.

 

[freddy mercury]

A lot of talk about Mick Hibberd heading to Melbourne, I personally don't mind if he goes, we have tippa and will likely sign Matt Dea to play his role.

What would you guys give for him? I would ask for Jack Watts, perhaps throw in a 4th round pick as the steak knifes.

 

[Dez!]

A lot of talk about Mick Hibberd heading to Melbourne, I personally don't mind if he goes, we have tippa and will likely sign Matt Dea to play his role.

What would you guys give for him? I would ask for Jack Watts, perhaps throw in a 4th round pick as the steak knifes.

Yeah you're not getting Watts.

The consensus here is a 2nd round pick would get it done.

 

[Headless]

A lot of talk about Mick Hibberd heading to Melbourne, I personally don't mind if he goes, we have tippa and will likely sign Matt Dea to play his role.

What would you guys give for him? I would ask for Jack Watts, perhaps throw in a 4th round pick as the steak knifes.

I would not trade Jack Watts for Michael Hibberd.

 

[freddy mercury]

I would not trade Jack Watts for Michael Hibberd.

Why not? Hibberd is elite off half back which you need. You have Hogan, sam weideman and Dawes as your forwards. With Maxy Gawn kicking a goal a game too, plenty of fire power.

 

[freddy mercury]

Yeah you're not getting Watts.

The consensus here is a 2nd round pick would get it done.

2nd round?

 

[LeverPuller]

Why not? Hibberd is elite off half back which you need. You have Hogan, sam weideman and Dawes as your forwards. With Maxy Gawn kicking a goal a game too, plenty of fire power.

Firstly Watts is FA.
Secondly he's very much a required player and has improved a shitload with the side improving.

I suggest that it'll be Melbourne's 2nd.