List Mgmt. 2016 Trade Thread

[Marc_Remillard]

Do we have to bring this tedious "prove it with a quote" shit over and over to this board? It's what the MB and Trade and Drafts boards are for - ******s who think it's fun playing that game all day. **** this. I'm going to go have a soothing chat with Sweet Jesus.

meh, if someone tries to make something up in an attempt of trying to make themselves look good then they should pay for it.

I didn't post what he accused me of doing, it's his problem that he's trying to save face now

 

[Marc_Remillard]

You're arguing against the coaches and also saying that they know best. Read back the last couple of pages and see if you can spot where you've dug yourself a nice big hole.

Really? So Goodwin told you this personally that we're going to use a 2nd rounder on Hibberd.

Good for you, what else did Good in say to you? This should be great

 

[Sando22]

Does anyone else feel that we really don't have many holes to fill right now, just need game time?

Yeah good call, completely agree.
Maybe another wingman who uses it well but that could be Salem.

 

[Topkent]

Yeah good call, completely agree.
Maybe another wingman who uses it well but that could be Salem.

Hawks have already proved that speed of ball movement beats legspeed anyway, Salem will add a lot to the wing IMO


I think we should pay a future first for Hibberd maybe include Kent in a deal

 

[Sando22]

Hawks have already proved that speed of ball movement beats legspeed anyway, Salem will add a lot to the wing IMO


I think we should pay a future first for Hibberd

Yeah agree with all of that.
Good ball users are too few and far between these days and are the quickest way of moving it from A to B.

I'd be fine with future 1st of Hibberd.

 

[LeverPuller]

No. No future 1st.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Really? So Goodwin told you this personally that we're going to use a 2nd rounder on Hibberd.

Good for you, what else did Good in say to you? This should be great

This is you using the logical fallacy of arguing from authority:

Read my posts carefully. I stated that Goodwin loves having Harmes and Hunt in the backline

There's is just a crazy thought I know but I have a hunch that his coach would probably have a fair idea.

Crazy I know and really out there

You are using Goodwin and Roos' authority as coaches to add weight to your argument against Hibberd. If you think they know best about who should play at half back then it follows either Hibberd is better suited than one of them at half back OR that Goodwin/Roos are not in favour of bringing in Hibberd to play half back for us.

I don't think I can spell it out any clearer for you than that.

 

[Topkent]

This is you using the logical fallacy of arguing from authority:




You are using Goodwin and Roos' authority as coaches to add weight to your argument against Hibberd. If you think they know best about who should play at half back then it follows either Hibberd is better suited than one of them at half back OR that Goodwin/Roos are not in favour of bringing in Hibberd to play half back for us.

I don't think I can spell it out any clearer for you than that.

Match point, only Kyrgios could blow it from here

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Match point, only Kyrgios could blow it from here

Tomic?

 

[Theo X]

Future 1st for a 27 year old Hibberd? We paid a 2nd for Bernie and he was/is a far, far superior player to Hibberd, whose best form was probably influenced by PEDs. Picks in the hands of Taylor are pure gold, let's not squander them.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Future 1st for a 27 year old? We paid a 2nd for Bernie and he was/is a far, far superior player to Hibberd, whose best form was probably influenced by PEDs.

He was clearly baiting hence the addition of Kent in the trade.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

This is you using the logical fallacy of arguing from authority:




You are using Goodwin and Roos' authority as coaches to add weight to your argument against Hibberd. If you think they know best about who should play at half back then it follows either Hibberd is better suited than one of them at half back OR that Goodwin/Roos are not in favour of bringing in Hibberd to play half back for us.

I don't think I can spell it out any clearer for you than that.

No, you're twisting my words, I was referring his love for Harmes and Hunt.

But you think he doesn't like them at all and wants to replace both of them with milkshake and hibberd.

Seriously? you really think that Goodwin wants to replace them with two drag cheats?

 

[Topkent]

He was clearly baiting hence the addition of Kent in the trade.

Whaaaaat? No id even include weiderman in the deal .. Hibberd could be the single most important player in history

 

[Topkent]

Tomic?

What a time to be alive

 

[Marc_Remillard]

Match point, only Kyrgios could blow it from here

I'm still waiting for your response

 

[Theseventhhamster]

No, you're twisting my words, I was referring his love for Harmes and Hunt.

But you think he doesn't like them at all and wants to replace both of them with milkshake and hibberd.

Seriously? you really think that Goodwin wants to replace them with two drag cheats?

I'm not twisting your words at all. Even provided EXACT QUOTES.

 

[Theo X]

He was clearly baiting hence the addition of Kent in the trade.

Ah fair enough, was just skimming over, didn't even see the Kent bit

 

[Marc_Remillard]

I'm not twisting your words at all. Even provided EXACT QUOTES.

And you think Goodwin doesn't like Hunt and Harmes and wants to replace them with milkshake and hibberd

Let's see who is correct

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Whaaaaat? No id even include weiderman in the deal .. Hibberd could be the single most important player in history

My cousin is close mate of Hibberd and I'm seeing him next week (cousin not Hibberd) so I'll see if I can get you an autograph from the great man.

 

[Topkent]

I'm still waiting for your response

There's no point your incapable of having a reasonable chat, your consistently labeling the 2 drug cheats and asking why Goodwin would want them forgetting he was working their when it happened

 

[Theseventhhamster]

And you think Goodwin doesn't like Hunt and Harmes and wants to replace them with milkshake and hibberd

Let's see who is correct

It's pretty clear Goodwin wants to bring in Hibberd to play half back. No idea what his other plans are.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

There's no point your incapable of having a reasonable chat, your consistently labeling the 2 drug cheats and asking why Goodwin would want them forgetting he was working their when it happened

They are drug cheats, it's relevant to the discussion.

Regardless, that issue has only been a very small part of my posts, about 20% of my argument.

 

[Topkent]

My cousin is close mate of Hibberd and I'm seeing him next week (cousin not Hibberd) so I'll see if I can get you an autograph from the great man.

Can you make it out to Marc remillliajdkfkd?

 

[Proper Gander]

Oh do shut up.

Edit: not you Topkent

 

[Topkent]

They are drug cheats, it's relevant to the discussion.

Regardless, that issue has only been a very small part of my posts, about 20% of my argument.

So you hate our coach aswell?