List Mgmt. 2016 Trade Thread

[Tempy Tiger]

Yep reckon Campbell meets our needs more than Spencer. Can go forward.

Why would we expect players to show loyalty to a club when we look at things like that? The muss has been a good servant for our club, has killed it at VFL level and hasn't soiled about not getting one ****ing match this year. The thought of replacing him with a plodder from another club chaps my arse.

 

[markm106]

Why would we expect players to show loyalty to a club when we look at things like that? The muss has been a good servant for our club, has killed it at VFL level and hasn't soiled about not getting one ******* match this year. The thought of replacing him with a plodder from another club chaps my arse.

Nothing wrong with adding another ruck to the list. Gawn Spencer ??????
King has done a knee in his first year so will be a while off.

 

[PizzaChief]

Why would we expect players to show loyalty to a club when we look at things like that? The muss has been a good servant for our club, has killed it at VFL level and hasn't soiled about not getting one ******* match this year. The thought of replacing him with a plodder from another club chaps my arse.

Nah the muss won't be getting replaced.. If we do go after a ruck they will be taking Max Kings spot on the list

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Why would we expect players to show loyalty to a club when we look at things like that? The muss has been a good servant for our club, has killed it at VFL level and hasn't soiled about not getting one ******* match this year. The thought of replacing him with a plodder from another club chaps my arse.

Harden up m8, theres a reason why he only got a one year deal. He will still be on the list next year regardless. The fact of the matter is that Spencer is one dementional and just not that good, we need a better back up and Tom Campbell most certainly is.

 

[Topkent]

Why would we expect players to show loyalty to a club when we look at things like that? The muss has been a good servant for our club, has killed it at VFL level and hasn't soiled about not getting one ******* match this year. The thought of replacing him with a plodder from another club chaps my arse.

Doesn't matter how loyal you are if you aren't very good, by that logic we shouldn't trade for Hibberd because we have Terlich

 

[Proper Gander]

Doesn't matter how loyal you are if you aren't very good, by that logic we shouldn't trade for Hibberd because we have Terlich

I just read that he got reported yesterday. Respect. Seeing him in an entirely new light now.

 

[Bokonon]

James Stewart is an interesting one - 1.97m athletic tall forward. Not sure if he can ruck at all though.

He might not cost the earth, which is a plus.

View attachment 284156 James Stewart

I get it's a bit late and just noticed this. Backup ruck is probably his most useful input us in the one's.
I gunna be frank. He has all the physical attributes of a Tall forward. To me he cant have a work ethic problem becuase he has started the last 2 years in the one's so must impress in the off season.
Has never delivered at AFL ended up a NEAFL ayer both years.
Have watched him a bit and he does everything right at NEAFL level, as you guys have said, much lower standard.
I just dont think he handles the pressure of AFL. It may be a different club system would work, and he deserves a chance elsewhere. I wouldn't be thinking he will be the next big thing though. Collingwood had hom as a father son pick and passed as well.

 

[Devastating Boris]

Perhaps a trade of Terlich for Hibberd. Might need Essendon to upgrade our 2nd on top to make it fair. Terlich has been playing like a bull this year and Hibberd has been running from them. Seems fair to me [emoji12]

 

[Hayes4PM]

Jack Grimes, what is the deal there my dudes?

 

[LeverPuller]

Jack Grimes, what is the deal there my dudes?

Restricted FA but if your offer is reasonable the club will let him walk.

 

[The Dr]

I get it's a bit late and just noticed this. Backup ruck is probably his most useful input us in the one's.
I gunna be frank. He has all the physical attributes of a Tall forward. To me he cant have a work ethic problem becuase he has started the last 2 years in the one's so must impress in the off season.
Has never delivered at AFL ended up a NEAFL ayer both years.
Have watched him a bit and he does everything right at NEAFL level, as you guys have said, much lower standard.
I just dont think he handles the pressure of AFL. It may be a different club system would work, and he deserves a chance elsewhere. I wouldn't be thinking he will be the next big thing though. Collingwood had hom as a father son pick and passed as well.

Thanks for this.

Stewart sounds like a bit of an enigma. He's still 22 so I guess has scope for improvement.

Considering he's pretty reasonable as a back-up ruck and has some AFL attributes as a forward it might be worth giving him a shot.

Do you think the Giants will go as far as delisting him, or does he have some trade value?

 

[Bokonon]

Thanks for this.

Stewart sounds like a bit of an enigma. He's still 22 so I guess has scope for improvement.

Considering he's pretty reasonable as a back-up ruck and has some AFL attributes as a forward it might be worth giving him a shot.

Do you think the Giants will go as far as delisting him, or does he have some trade value?

I dont know
We'll try to trade of course, dont think price will be a major issue, spot on the list for a club might. I get your point though cheap he might be value, he is young and Key forwards usually take time.

 

[blitznu]

Anyone reckon we would be any chance of putting hand up for Matt Eagles (bloke off of the recruit with the dreads) a contract? wont he be a rookie or cat b? 199cm looks really fit and can move around ground for a ruck/fwd kinda what we need looks the winner of the show not sure he would actually be any good as most are shite but costs us nothing and will get a pre season at an AFL club to see if he is up to it... Never heard of the bloke b4 the show so know absolutely nothing about him..
Be voted off next ep and never be heard of again

 

[Proper Gander]

Anyone reckon we would be any chance of putting hand up for Matt Eagles (bloke off of the recruit with the dreads) a contract? wont he be a rookie or cat b? 199cm looks really fit and can move around ground for a ruck/fwd kinda what we need looks the winner of the show not sure he would actually be any good as most are shite but costs us nothing and will get a pre season at an AFL club to see if he is up to it... Never heard of the bloke b4 the show so know absolutely nothing about him..
Be voted off next ep and never be heard of again

Nah. I only saw 10 minutes of one recent episode ever, but I remember the guy for thinking he looked a bit like the love child of Ben Brown and Joe Daniher after a prolonged forceps delivery. Do not want.

 

[blitznu]

Nah. I only saw 10 minutes of one recent episode ever, but I remember the guy for thinking he looked a bit like the love child of Ben Brown and Joe Daniher after a prolonged forceps delivery. Do not want.

Thought he looked more like Vickery x Brown no1 is as ugly as Daniher.

 

[Proper Gander]

Thought he looked more like Vickery x Brown no1 is as ugly as Daniher.

Yes. I think your reading is accurate. Still don't want.

 

[VitalDread]

Jack Grimes, what is the deal there my dudes?

off to Swans imo

 

[VitalDread]

Anyone reckon we would be any chance of putting hand up for Matt Eagles (bloke off of the recruit with the dreads) a contract? wont he be a rookie or cat b? 199cm looks really fit and can move around ground for a ruck/fwd kinda what we need looks the winner of the show not sure he would actually be any good as most are shite but costs us nothing and will get a pre season at an AFL club to see if he is up to it... Never heard of the bloke b4 the show so know absolutely nothing about him..
Be voted off next ep and never be heard of again

He is struggling up in Ballarat and when Casey played Nth a few months back, he lasted 2mins before tearing his hamstring.

 

[blitznu]

He is struggling up in Ballarat and when Casey played Nth a few months back, he lasted 2mins before tearing his hamstring.

Cheers for that. so thatll be a pass. Looks about the only one on that show who could play yet cant even football.

 

[Portstar Johnny]

Harden up m8, theres a reason why he only got a one year deal. He will still be on the list next year regardless. The fact of the matter is that Spencer is one dementional and just not that good, we need a better back up and Tom Campbell most certainly is.

Lol! Is he really that one dementional?

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

No fuglies please.

 

[Cannon82]

Lol! Is he really that one dementional?

We don't like to talk about Spencil here, so he's always referred to as a one dementional player as per the example below.

Bob: "What does everyone think about Spencil? I think he's underrated in an overrated way."
Don: "We don't talk about Spencer."
Bob: "Sorry, one de-mention please."

 

[Proper Gander]

We don't like to talk about Spencil here, so he's always referred to as a one dementional player as per the example below.

Bob: "What does everyone think about Spencil? I think he's underrated in an overrated way."
Don: "We don't talk about Spencer."
Bob: "Sorry, one de-mention please."

You've gone strangely chatty now that the season has done and we've stopped alarmingly winning things

 

[Cannon82]

You've gone strangely chatty now that the season has done and we've stopped alarmingly winning things

Optimism is cancer.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Lol! Is he really that one dementional?

Lol! Sorry! Spelling/Grammer mistake! Whoops! Got my mention's, dementia's and dimensional's mixed up! Silly me!

For a Portstar, you sure do act a lot like those nutcases Doctor Whoo/Demonic Fav, Johnny