List Mgmt. 2016 Trade Thread

[Demon 16]

Not the King and Newton stuff he didn't
Pretty sure scottty works at the club mate, if they say don't post it before the decisions been made we should probably listen. Last thing King or Newton need is rumours getting around that they're delisted before they're told or before they've told others.

The King and Newton stuff is already out.

Sorry Scottty, I didn't know you work at the club.

Perhaps you blokes should be using PM, rather than blowing up each other's anonymity.

VitalDread has put so much into our board this year - he shouldn't be criticised for sharing info that is already out, just because he's the first to share it on here.

 

[DemonTim]

The King and Newton stuff is already out.

Sorry Scottty, I didn't know you work at the club.

Perhaps you blokes should be using PM, rather than blowing up each other's anonymity.

VitalDread has put so much into our board this year - he shouldn't be criticised for sharing info that is already out, just because he's the first to share it on here.

It's not out mate. That's what scottty is saying

It's not really criticising. Relax mate. There's just a time and place to post. The amount of shit I find out but can't post is very large. Just gotta know when to not post info. Jacob will understand

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Where does Maynard go? Onto our senior rookie list?

edit: Surely he's not spending a year on the development squad at 25yo? If he's that far behind he will be 30 before he's up to speed.

 

[DemonTim]

Where does Maynard go? Onto our senior rookie list?

Nah. He will stay cat b for now I'd say

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Nah. He will stay cat b for now I'd say

I edited the above, as a 25yo? really? So he will be 26 before he is even looked at. Surely he is a more ready made player than what we are lead to believe, seems a complete waste of time otherwise.

 

[DemonTim]

I edited the above, as a 25yo? really? So he will be 26 before he is even looked at. Surely he is a more ready made player than what we are lead to believe, seems a complete waste of time otherwise.

I think they use cat b to determine if it's worth listing him, and it doesn't take up a list spot.

 

[DemonTim]

This. Of course everyone can post their opinions- that's the idea of the forum and thread specifically.

But as Tim said you don't want things spreading when you've got guys out of contract and nervously awaiting their fate..

There have been 3 delistings publicly so far.

Yep. Agree mate

It's why I haven't announced my signing yet, I'm waiting for the club to make it official

 

[givemethecure]

Jacob yeah?

Mate just be careful making comments about player delistings when the club still hasn't made those decisions yet.

NARC!

 

[givemethecure]

This. Of course everyone can post their opinions- that's the idea of the forum and thread specifically.

But as Tim said you don't want things spreading when you've got guys out of contract and nervously awaiting their fate..

There have been 3 delistings publicly so far.

EDIT: and of course Jacob can post here just gotta make sure it's clear its his opinion not fact

N A R C ! NARC!

 

[VitalDread]

N A R C ! NARC!

relax man

 

[DemonTim]

relax man

Don't stress it mate. You made a mistake, most likely after being so star struck from meeting me

 

[VitalDread]

Don't stress it mate. You made a mistake, most likely after being so star struck from meeting me

this is very true man, your eyes just captured me

 

[DemonTim]

this is very true man, your eyes just captured me

Not the first bloke from casey to say that

 

[Demon 16]

This. Of course everyone can post their opinions- that's the idea of the forum and thread specifically.

But as Tim said you don't want things spreading when you've got guys out of contract and nervously awaiting their fate..

There have been 3 delistings publicly so far.

EDIT: and of course Jacob can post here just gotta make sure it's clear its his opinion not fact

I understand your point, but just because is not on the website yet, doesn't mean we can't mention it on here.

If we played it like that, I'd delete my account and just go read the newspaper.

 

[DemonTim]

I understand your point, but just because is not on the website yet, doesn't mean we can't mention it on here.

If we played it like that, I'd delete my account and just go read the newspaper.

I think he's saying employees shouldn't release private info mate. Which is fair.

I get that you guys want info lol but some stuff should wait

Also seems scottty is saying the club hasn't even told the players that yet, so it's not just that it hasn't been released, it's that the involved parties haven't been told (not saying it's true or not)

 

[dazzledavey36]

I think he's saying employees shouldn't release private info mate. Which is fair.

I get that you guys want info lol but some stuff should wait

Also seems scottty is saying the club hasn't even told the players that yet, so it's not just that it hasn't been released, it's that the involved parties haven't been told (not saying it's true or not)

Find it extremely hard to believe that some people already know about Newton and King before they know themselves. In this day and age where our club is now run by true professionals im pretty sure Newton and King would have been already told first before anyone else.

 

[LeverPuller]

Find it extremely hard to believe that some people already know about Newton and King before they know themselves. In this day and age where our club is now run by true professionals im pretty sure Newton and King would have been already told first before anyone else.

I've heard about King and Juice from my non-BF source too. That one has gotten out somehow.

 

[Jordie_tackles]

I've heard about King and Juice from my non-BF source too. That one has gotten out somehow.

Didn't juice get delisted 5 years ago? Thought that one was out there...

 

[schmuttt]

Find it extremely hard to believe that some people already know about Newton and King before they know themselves. In this day and age where our club is now run by true professionals im pretty sure Newton and King would have been already told first before anyone else.

Agree but think it's more when some people on the forum know who you are at Casey/Melbourne it isn't a good idea to leak info.

 

[dazzledavey36]

I've heard about King and Juice from my non-BF source too. That one has gotten out somehow.

Same.

Im pretty sure they know about it too just club hasn't released it out in the media yet.

 

[Devastating Boris]

In my eyes, you are all bullshitting about having any inside info. Produce a caravan purchase receipt or GTFO! [emoji6]

 

[pjfairbairn]

I think anybody who has heard anything from any source has every right to post whatever they like. It's a forum. There are far more disrespectful things about players posted on different threads, especially gameday, all the time. I have zero doubt that if somebody on here has it on good authority that Max King & Newton are being delisted, it's not going to be news to the tw boys themselves.

And FWIW I rarely notice who posts what on here, have never met any of you and try not to judge posts on their author... But if you work for the Club, lurking in here to be the forum police is not good footy.

I have worked in professional sports for the past 5 years and don't post anything except personal opinion/observations on forums related to my sport. It means often people are speculating about topics I already have full knowledge of, yet I refrain from commenting on topics such as this.

As per the Casey thread a couple of weeks ago, the 'I know but I can't say' rhetoric is getting fairly tired. If you can't say anything, don't, and allow people to speculate and the chuckle to yourself when they get it massively wrong. It's highly entertaining and also a lot more professional than implying you know more than you are permitted to write...

 

[Pedantic]

Pedo one year
White stays on rookie
Viv stays on rookie
Joel smith upgraded
Dawes likely staying but may change depending on trade period (as coverage for the lack of age on kpf)

Would be interesting to see us upgrade a first year rookie who hasn't played a senior game and is presumably still contracted. If it happens the club must really be rating his chances to play a fair chunk of senior games next year.

 

[DemonTim]

I think anybody who has heard anything from any source has every right to post whatever they like. It's a forum. There are far more disrespectful things about players posted on different threads, especially gameday, all the time. I have zero doubt that if somebody on here has it on good authority that Max King & Newton are being delisted, it's not going to be news to the tw boys themselves.

And FWIW I rarely notice who posts what on here, have never met any of you and try not to judge posts on their author... But if you work for the Club, lurking in here to be the forum police is not good footy.

I have worked in professional sports for the past 5 years and don't post anything except personal opinion/observations on forums related to my sport. It means often people are speculating about topics I already have full knowledge of, yet I refrain from commenting on topics such as this.

As per the Casey thread a couple of weeks ago, the 'I know but I can't say' rhetoric is getting fairly tired. If you can't say anything, don't, and allow people to speculate and the chuckle to yourself when they get it massively wrong. It's highly entertaining and also a lot more professional than implying you know more than you are permitted to write...

Your post seems contradictory

 

[DemonTim]

Find it extremely hard to believe that some people already know about Newton and King before they know themselves. In this day and age where our club is now run by true professionals im pretty sure Newton and King would have been already told first before anyone else.

i wouldn't know. Last night was the first I'd heard, a club employee has posted saying it's false.
If it had already been done, wouldn't the club have done it when they released grimes, Terlich and jones?