List Mgmt. 2016 Trade Thread

[Rack Watts]

No, they were found guilty of being unable to prove they didn't take anything.. they were never specifically found guilty of taking any substances that's why they are still going through the appeal process
That's the difference between the aus court and the Swiss one, I don't have a view either way but in Australia asada had to prove they were guilty, wada only had to create doubt they were innocent

This guy gets it!
Hoping Hibberd has a blinder with you guys next year, absolutely love him, and always will, even if his heart beats true. Figure we owe you one, re: Melksham.

 

[Topkent]

This guy gets it!
Hoping Hibberd has a blinder with you guys next year, absolutely love him, and always will, even if his heart beats true. Figure we owe you one, re: Melksham.

How do you rate Hibberd?

 

[VitalDread]

Reckon Pederson done enough for a new one year deal imo

 

[Topkent]

Reckon Pederson done enough for a new one year deal imo

Hope so, always has a crack and adds good physicality

 

[Rack Watts]

How do you rate Hibberd?

He reads the play as well as anyone at the club, including Hooker, he's our best HBF, raking left boot, albeit his only boot. At his best he's a top 5 HBF in the league though, which I think he will be back to next year.
I feel like he was badly affected by the saga last year, his production dropped.
He's hungry, and he's one of the most liked in the dressing rooms.

 

[VitalDread]

Hope so, always has a crack and adds good physicality

Especially with a very young tall forward line

 

[Sam Guest]

Hogan for Fyfe and taberner? if he does wanna go home what would get?

 

[Back Jillings]

Hogan for Fyfe and taberner? if he does wanna go home what would get?

no

 

[Marc_Remillard]

You do know a wingers job is to get back and help out in defence or do you think he's just gonna stand on the logo waiting for the ball to get to him
Mate it doesn't matter, Vince and Harmes won't stay in defence for much longer and you have almost have a personal issue with Hibberd who would be our best mid sized defender

If there were classy ball users on the market we wouldn't be trading our second round pick for Hibberd.. you think we have just gone to Essendon said we will do the deal and not bothered talking to anyone else? Like Ahmed Saad is gonna go to Richmond for a second round pick while we are sitting in the trade office going **** why did we sign that contract saying we are only allowed to trade for Hibberd this year

I'm going to concede this one to you mate, i wouldn't want to upset proper gander any more with my posts

 

[pjfairbairn]

What a waste of trawling this thread trying to find genuine information or quality debate. Keep the handbags to the side ladies. Pathetic.

No problem having a difference of opinion, but when it descends to trying to 'prove who is wrong' on an opinion-based argument and wastes 4 pages of a thread, we're all poorer for it.

On a side note, noticed this which suggested Sydney are into Grimesy. Any chance we could work this into a trade for perhaps Nankervis?

 

[givemethecure]

hi guys what's happening in this thread

 

[The Dr]

What a waste of trawling this thread trying to find genuine information or quality debate. Keep the handbags to the side ladies. Pathetic.

No problem having a difference of opinion, but when it descends to trying to 'prove who is wrong' on an opinion-based argument and wastes 4 pages of a thread, we're all poorer for it.

On a side note, noticed this which suggested Sydney are into Grimesy. Any chance we could work this into a trade for perhaps Nankervis?

Grimes is a FA and can walk for nothing, and fair play to him as well.

 

[Hotdees]

It's pretty clear Goodwin wants to bring in Hibberd to play half back. No idea what his other plans are.

He was on the coaches box on SEN a while back and admitted we'd talked to Hibberd and would love to have him. Clearly Goodwin wants him.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Cool story bros

 

[Franky_024]

Popped on to see 4 pages of unread posts and thought you beauty something has happened in regards to Hibberd or whispers of some sort

People keep forgetting that we've had a good year with injuries, it's the only thing keeping performing guys like M Jones, Neal-Bullen, Grimes and Trengove out of the side. Hell i'd love to have Lumumba and Melksham dominating in the 2nds next year trying to pinch a spot from O Mac or Hunt. Add another quality defender in Hibberd and we'll be laughing.

 

[VitalDread]

Popped on to see 4 pages of unread posts and thought you beauty something has happened in regards to Hibberd or whispers of some sort

People keep forgetting that we've had a good year with injuries, it's the only thing keeping performing guys like M Jones, Neal-Bullen, Grimes and Trengove out of the side. Hell i'd love to have Lumumba and Melksham dominating in the 2nds next year trying to pinch a spot from O Mac or Hunt. Add another quality defender in Hibberd and we'll be laughing.

Dont recon H will play again, those head hits have done some damage i reckon.

 

[freddy mercury]

Do you really have this much time on your hands?

Plenty.

 

[Hotdees]

Dont recon H will play again, those head hits have done some damage i reckon.

What on earth would make you think this ?

 

[VitalDread]

What on earth would make you think this ?

Because he had 2 head knocks this year and hasnt played in 6 weeks and dont think he was training as well according tk media

 

[LeverPuller]

On Hibberd, apparently we will know by end of the season (according to Essendon CEO on SEN today)

 

[Hotdees]

Because he had 2 head knocks this year and hasnt played in 6 weeks and dont think he was training as well according tk media

Haha ok , I was thinking about some of the interviews he's done. The head knocks appear to have done some damage but maybe that's just me

 

[schmuttt]

On Hibberd, apparently we will know by end of the season (according to Essendon CEO on SEN today)

Did he say Hibberd specifically or the ones who haven't confirmed if they are coming back?

 

[LeverPuller]

Did he say Hibberd specifically or the ones who haven't confirmed if they are coming back?

Well there's only 3 left really, Howlett, Hibberd and Watson. Howlett and Hibberd by end of H&A and Watson later.

 

[pjfairbairn]

Grimes is a FA and can walk for nothing, and fair play to him as well.

If he's on a decent contract, which he probably is, we should actually get half decent compensation right?

 

[The Dr]

If he's on a decent contract, which he probably is, we should actually get half decent compensation right?

It depends on his next contract, not his current one. I reckon he'll get picked up somewhere but it'll be a pretty lowball contract. So, doubtful we'll get any meaningful compo, if anything.