List Mgmt. 2016 Trade Thread

[blitznu]

Maybe we could trade next years first to goldcoast or GWS for 1 of there firsts this year to trade to port cause im pretty sure port would want a 1st from this year to get some talent in

 

[TheCount]

Yeah noone should judge on NEAFL form. Was up in canberra for work for a few days, and was talking to a bloke in the office who plays full back in the NEAFL. Was mid 30s, said he was lucky to make 1 training a week, went to the gym a few other days, and was picked every weekend. Said he had played on some big name players and gotten absolutely destroyed every time

Haha, I reckon I might know exactly who you're referring to there. To be fair, I certainly wouldn't be judging the NEAFL on anything out of Canberra, all of the teams from there, including the "merged" team this year have been complete rubbish.

Aside from the AFL teams tho, there is a lack of KPP players in terms of height, so Stewart really should be dominating at that level

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

I want Caleb Marchbank.

 

[mrmonkey]

Maybe we could trade next years first to goldcoast or GWS for 1 of there firsts this year to trade to port cause im pretty sure port would want a 1st from this year to get some talent in

There's an article on the afl site that says exactly that. They want the picks for the upcoming draft. I'm not sure if port need to go down this path. But looking at ports list Hamish hartlett seems to be the best fit for trading in high draft pick(s)

 

[blitznu]

There's an article on the afl site that says exactly that. They want the picks for the upcoming draft. I'm not sure if port need to go down this path. But looking at ports list Hamish hartlett seems to be the best fit for trading in high draft pick(s)

Yeah Hinkley needs to make the 8 next year so not sure i would be trading out 1 of their stars so something must be up to want to trade him out in a make or break year.
I reckon GCS would be down for that trade as well as they have so many high picks this year already.

 

[mrmonkey]

Yeah Hinkley needs to make the 8 next year so not sure i would be trading out 1 of their stars so something must be up to want to trade him out in a make or break year.
I reckon GCS would be down for that trade as well as they have so many high picks this year already.

I would think so considering they're losing prestia and have plenty of picks.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Reckon Hartlett would be a good get. 4 years left on his contract is no different to what we are offering Hibberd. Comes with experience and leadership with plenty of footy still ahead of him, outside ball usage is what we need and a bonus that Hartlett isn't soft. The way we got Bernie Vince to turn up his career I'd back our coaching staff to get the best out of Hartlett in his prime years.

Its not so much the length of the contract that scares me its the amount of money he is on for the remaining four years, ive heard around 750K per year! Madness! Would have to bring that down to 600ish at least for it to be worthwhile.

 

[Topkent]

Its not so much the length of the contract that scares me its the amount of money he is on for the remaining four years, ive heard around 750K per year! Madness! Would have to bring that down to 600ish at least for it to be worthwhile.

We could easily afford to front load the first 2 years you would think though, if we lost Dawes, Dunn, Grimes that's over a million plus Garland and Trenners maybe next year could be as much as 2 million total

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

We could easily afford to front load the first 2 years you would think though, if we lost Dawes, Dunn, Grimes that's over a million plus Garland and Trenners maybe next year could be as much as 2 million total

Id still want Port paying some of it, they are the ones putting him up for trade him after signing him last year.

 

[Topkent]

Id still want Port paying some of it, they are the ones putting him up for trade him after signing him last year.

For me it wouldn't break the deal If they refused to but if we can do it then shit yeah, I don't feel like he's shown an ability to stand up in big games but he's more Vince than Sylvia and he can get brownlow votes for fun when on form

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

For me it wouldn't break the deal If they refused to but if we can do it then shit yeah, I don't feel like he's shown an ability to stand up in big games but he's more Vince than Sylvia and he can get brownlow votes for fun when on form

Oh yeah, im not against getting him, i like him, when on song he's a fantastic player, last year he wasnt a 750K per year player, that all im saying, if we got a discount on that id be all for having a crack at getting him.

 

[schmuttt]

I think a future first is about his worth. Port would probably ask for more though.

If hogan goes I wouldn't mind trying to secure another quality mid then drafting a KPF with an early pick. Sure, would worsen our forwardline in the short term but we've got a bunch of goal kickers this year, it is unlikely we could recruit a guy to play hogans role anywhere near as well from day one and last but certainly not mleast I think our midfield could end up the best in the league, so it won't matter who is up forward.

 

[mrmonkey]

Future first and ANB?

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

Jarryd Lyons is still unsigned, has performed pretty well this year.

 

[Topkent]

Future first and ANB?

Id do this

 

[Topkent]

Jarryd Lyons is still unsigned, has performed pretty well this year.

And we have had a crack at him every year for a few now haven't we, decent wing/linkman

 

[Blackas87]

Its not so much the length of the contract that scares me its the amount of money he is on for the remaining four years, ive heard around 750K per year! Madness! Would have to bring that down to 600ish at least for it to be worthwhile.

If he's on that F me dead.

 

[KickLongTackleHard]

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2016-09-03/big-men-set-for-big-moves-in-trade-period.mobileapp

We're still being linked to Tom Campbell. My guess would be Downie and Nankervis we'd also have in frame. No idea who Downie is.

 

[The Dr]

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2016-09-03/big-men-set-for-big-moves-in-trade-period.mobileapp

We're still being linked to Tom Campbell. My guess would be Downie and Nankervis we'd also have in frame. No idea who Downie is.

Campbell is basically Spencer. An OK ruck and pretty hopeless forward. Big no from me. We need a 80/20 forward/ruck, not 20/80.

 

[CWaffles]

Would prefer Vardy, has more upside imo

 

[Bluelegs]

Has Hartlett been injured? Seems a bit Hartless from port to get rid of him after one bad year.

 

[mrmonkey]

Has Hartlett been injured? Seems a bit Hartless from port to get rid of him after one bad year.

It's weird, it's a brave trade but it's not like they're doing a major rebuild. I don't think getting rid of one player for a pick in the draft will do anything.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

It's weird, it's a brave trade but it's not like they're doing a major rebuild. I don't think getting rid of one player for a pick in the draft will do anything.

It will all be about the cap and make up of their list after a review, they will be thinking Harlett's money can be spent better elsewhere while netting them a decent return in trade.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Campbell is basically Spencer. An OK ruck and pretty hopeless forward. Big no from me. We need a 80/20 forward/ruck, not 20/80.

Bit harsh, Campbell is easily an upgrade on Spencer in terms of an around the ground ruck, decent enough skills for a big fella and can kick some goals, but i get your point, id rather a forward ruck also.

 

[markm106]

Yep reckon Campbell meets our needs more than Spencer. Can go forward.