The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #126
Good on you for saying this FlowersByIrene , because I hardly noticed you last year, when I did other years.
The OP also is somewhat strange in terms of pushing the 'community' and 'respect' values of determining these...........awards.
Maybe I have it wrong, but shouldn't a football forum be about........football and vigorously debating football matters?
It's petty I'm sure and it will likely mean nothing to the players I felt worthy of being recognised, but just took the time out to have my say.
FBI still was fairly prolific and his rebuild thread is a fine contribution.
Is the Brownlow all about vigorously playing football?
You'd note that I did include debating skills in the OP but I use words like respectful and constructive. If someone debates by questioning the intelligence of others or acting superior, it's not exactly promoting inclusive discussion. We always maintain we don't want to be like the Facebook forum.
The community part is about contribution i.e going above and beyond to provide content and information, and also being a positive presence.
Remember there were a few criteria with no particular weighting and no requirement to address them all. I'm quite happy to consider them all important though.
You won 2 POTY awards Harks and part of the consideration that helped that would have been the criteria you take issue with.