List Mgmt. 2017 Draft Discussion (cont in Pt 2)

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

triggering bro

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Aug 30, 2017
Posts
7,788
Likes
31,174
AFL Club
St Kilda
Feck off Campaigner, I claimed him first. He is more a Selwood or Lever pick coming off a knee, but potentially could have been pick 1 if not for knee
Yea I'll give you that. You have me the early heads up. Now let's get hold of Ameet & Trout & let them know to recruit this 6f3 mutant man-child
 

StCicatriz

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 3, 2016
Posts
14,658
Likes
27,016
AFL Club
St Kilda
Just written a few members names down, I'm interested on who you think we could get with our picks 7 and 8 after the teams have taken Rayner, LDU , Dow , Cerra , Brander
just for future reference and see how they turn out.

Premium Coffield and Higgins I expect Stephenson to be taken before 7
Lightsxo Coffield and Constable/O'Brien however would take LDU if he fell to us
Wright1
VDS66
CHBENCH
Cursing Fijian
St BKD
Narkles Helmet
Aussierulesrules
Diehard Saint review with Ads734
Greg1853
Sheeza69
Baughb
D2D3
Dark Saint use 7 for Coffield and trade 8 for something in the 15 - 20 range for D.Fogarty & O'Brien
Geelong Saint
Bird Man Brayshaw and Stephenson
Lewdog
JG22 Higgins and Coffield would have pretty solid immediate impact
Triggering bro Coffield & Brayshaw
Joffa ------
Jackie Chiles
Plugger66
Border Barry trade player & 8 for Brander, trade 7 to Lions for 12 & 18 Clavarino or Sam Taylor
Kilroy
Ads734
st trav ofWA
Saints September Brayshaw and Higgins
Gringo 2011
StCicatriz
Grav Coffield & Stephenson. If either are gone O'Brien or Ross as a dark horse
LeonardHayes87
screw the blues
Superduperouzel
bennymc7 trade up to no.2 Rayner or Dow
SaintSteele9 Coffield and Higgins Stephenson if he gets to our picks
KernelT we won't have both 7 & 8
Trade for a big fish. If that's not happening. Then Stephenson and Naughton. If one looks like going earlier trade into 2018 first round.
 

Premium

Premiership Player
Joined
Oct 8, 2016
Posts
4,244
Likes
8,226
AFL Club
St Kilda
Just written a few members names down, I'm interested on who you think we could get with our picks 7 and 8 after the teams have taken Rayner, LDU , Dow , Cerra , Brander
just for future reference and see how they turn out.

Premium Coffield and Higgins I expect Stephenson to be taken before 7
Lightsxo Coffield and Constable/O'Brien however would take LDU if he fell to us
Wright1 Stephenson probably gone, so will say... Coffield & Boner
VDS66
CHBENCH
Cursing Fijian
St BKD
Narkles Helmet
Aussierulesrules
Diehard Saint review with Ads734
Greg1853
Sheeza69
Baughb
D2D3
Dark Saint use 7 for Coffield and trade 8 for something in the 15 - 20 range for D.Fogarty & O'Brien
Geelong Saint
Bird Man Brayshaw and Stephenson
Lewdog
JG22 Higgins and Coffield would have pretty solid immediate impact
Triggering bro Coffield & Brayshaw
Joffa ------
Jackie Chiles
Plugger66
Border Barry trade player & 8 for Brander, trade 7 to Lions for 12 & 18 Clavarino or Sam Taylor
Kilroy
Ads734
st trav ofWA
Saints September Brayshaw and Higgins
Gringo 2011
StCicatriz Stephenson and Naughton
Grav Coffield & Stephenson. If either are gone O'Brien or Ross as a dark horse
LeonardHayes87
screw the blues
Superduperouzel
bennymc7 trade up to no.2 Rayner or Dow
SaintSteele9 Coffield and Higgins Stephenson if he gets to our picks
KernelT we won't have both 7 & 8
Significant Cerra and Coffield
Sab22 7 or 8 + 2nd 2018 for Tigers first 2 picks,pick up a FB/Mid.7 or 8 we can bring in Coffield

Impatient Saint Cerra & Brayshaw


updated
 

RWB4life

Team Captain
Joined
May 28, 2016
Posts
334
Likes
428
AFL Club
St Kilda
I send 7 or 8 + 2nd 2018 for Richmond's first 2 picks this year.

So we have a chance to pick up a FB/Mid. With 7/8 we can bring in Coffield or best player available.
I'd rather going to pick 1 or 2 but doing that could take
coffield/Stephenson with top 10
Sam taylor/other defender
Obrien or bonar

That's a very good draft haul.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

gringo2011

Premium Gold
Joined
Nov 12, 2011
Posts
21,916
Likes
45,998
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
St Kilda
Very similar heritage. Gwilt was PNG/Wales, this kid is PNG/Scotland. So Gwilty was a better singer, Bonar is tighter with a dollar?

I'm not sure who you offended more in there but I loved Gwilt he was a gun of a guy. i know some Scots that do keep that cultural stereo type going though, never met any campaigners that leave the house with out wallets or get confused who's turn to go to the bar more than those two.
 
Joined
Mar 13, 2014
Posts
118
Likes
500
AFL Club
St Kilda
Nah he's in the open draft[/QUOTE

All academy players are in the open are draft I thought but you get a discount. For example. Ethan Penrith from the Northern Nights is available to Carlton but anyone else can draft him.

They are under the same rules as northern state academy kids, why would he not be eligible given he fits the criteria?
 
Joined
Jun 7, 2017
Posts
12
Likes
54
AFL Club
St Kilda
There is a guy in the Bendigo League called Lachlan Sharp, who plays for Strathfieldsaye. He kicked 142 goals this season and won the League Best and Fairest award, as well the League goalkicking. I was at the Grand Final yesterday and he kicked five goals in the last term while injured, to guide his team to a runaway victory from two or three goals down at three quarter time. This was in front of quite a few thousand people, including his ex team mate and mentor (?), Stephen Milne. Two of Jarryn Geary's brothers I believe, are guns at Strathfieldsaye as well, with one brother winning the best player award yesterday. Lachlan Sharp appears to be an absolute matchwinner and gun. As he is aged 26 or so however, perhaps now he will never get a chance to play AFL. I for one believe he may be a worth a late draft pick this year.
 

aussierulesrules

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jan 7, 2011
Posts
26,994
Likes
45,851
Location
Heaven. I mean Victoria.
AFL Club
St Kilda
Thread starter #1,772
I've been wondering what injury has put an end to Rayner's season, as I hadn't seen it mentioned anywhere, and Bishop said he's been told it's his knee, which if correct is interesting, as I first saw talk of him having had a knee issue around the 2nd or so game of the champs, and then someone who said they go to school with him said a few weeks later that Cam said it was still very sore, so if he's been playing with a knee injury for half the year at least (as well as playing with a broken hand/thumb/finger late in the year), it augurs well for how well he would have gone if fully fit!

Probably also explains why he went back to playing more permanent forward than he had been.

Not bad if you can average 120 SC points per game in the champs and kick 5 goals in one of those games when playing with a bung knee.

Watching Dusty being a nightmare match-up deep inside 50 yesterday and Danger doing the same the week before just made me think of Rayner, as that's the exact sort of stuff that he's renowned for when he plays forward, at an identical type size and with such similar strengths/attributes.

If we manage to get our hands on any of him, Dow, or LDU we ought to be seriously pumped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom