List Mgmt. 2017 Draft Needs...

[Danger in Texas]

Rayner and Rankine are two amazing talents.

D Fogarty has been invisible

Also Bicks Harrison Petty has been very impressive

 

[hey shorty]

Rayner and Rankine are two amazing talents.

D Fogarty has been invisible

Also Bicks Harrison Petty has been very impressive

Fogarty strikes me as a FIGJAM. Struts around the field and does very little.

 

[Viva la Mattner]

I honestly think he's carrying an injury.

Hopefully means he slides to us!

 

[GrommoT]

I honestly think he's carrying an injury.

And he looks ... kinda chunky ... at the Adelaide Oval game - has he always been like that?

Spoiler

[0.9mb]

 

[Squiba]

He won't be a latish pick, about 30 players would have to show about 200% more than they have half way through the season for that to happen, IMO he goes 2nd round at the latest. Really don't think he's a list need personally, IMO we need more midfield depth, a developing KPP mostly a KPD [Keath? but he does seem to be injury prone] and a developing rookie Ruckman.

I really can't see Dear being retained on his output this year, he's big, strong and reasonably quick but it's just not translating into anything on field that says keep him, Gore after a good 1st year at Geelong has done little to get enthused about since arriving here, Hunter shows a bit but really not seeing anything that says he's any more than depth. Wigg for whatever reason hasn't been given any opportunity at all so it's hard to justify retaining him though from the outside it's hard to fathom given his SANFL form. You would think we'd persevere with Doedee but he's uncontracted at year's end??

Personally I'd give our SANFL "top up" player Lachy Murphy a list spot or a rookie spot, he's been playing across half back for us but though he's short I saw him play some tip top midfield/Forward for the Northern Knights last year and think he's just a good all round player and at the very least a great depth player. Really unlucky not to get drafted IMO.

By latish, remember I was all over him at our first at one point. Now it'd be a toss up between him and CCJ, but a lot of water to go under the bridge yet. The first round will be shaped late this year

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I honestly think he's carrying an injury.

I thought that too but apparently not

 

[Jeffcrowe]

And he looks ... kinda chunky ... at the Adelaide Oval game - has he always been like that?

Yep 'big bodied'

Can't play midfield unless you can run and have some power

He can't do both at the moment

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Have been watching him he deserves a 3rd, 4th round easy. Just hope he is not picked up by another club. but he definitely worth a rookie spot.

He's a chance in this draft , there's a dozen good players from Vic metro and just a sprinkle elsewhere

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Rayner and Rankine are two amazing talents.

D Fogarty has been invisible

Also Bicks Harrison Petty has been very impressive

I was at the game

Liked Petty

Krueger had some good moments and some X factor

Not much else from SA !

Houlihan is a talent but goes missing and seems v introverted

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Very, very inconsistent at this stage, but I like the look of him as a late pick.

Tom McCartin, too

De Koenig is an enigma - has some talent ; he's ordinary in the air though , but of JJ about his marking contests

Lachie Fogarty goes ok, you called it on constable - he's a top 5 player

Cerra has some class and courage , prob doesn't quite do enough considering

I reckon it's Rayner , LDU and then maybe Constable TBH

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Paddy Dow is all class. He's another I wouldn't mind getting with our first.

Ethan Floyd is one that's quite damaging too. LDU worked his way into the game that quarter

Dow has a bit of Rory Sloane tenacity , you reckon he's classy ? I like him but he's not overly polished with his kicking . I'd take him in a heartbeat though

 

[Jeffcrowe]

See idk, but 3rd round onwards I can see someone taking a punt. If he has a dismal year, maybe not, but he really could turn into a Neale or even Prestia type if everything goes right.

Can't see it TBH

 

[Jeffcrowe]

In other news - don't reckon Edwards is top 40 . 3rd rounder - rookie level

 

[Jeffcrowe]

There are a few decent half backs - coffield Garner naish hunter Clarke and Ling is dynamic

 

[Danger in Texas]

I was at the game

Liked Petty

Krueger had some good moments and some X factor

Not much else from SA !

Houlihan is a talent but goes missing and seems v introverted

Yep Petty and Kreuger were the standouts for me today. Reckon Kreuger has oodles of potential as a mobile 3rd tall type.

What makes you say Houlahan is introverted? Has a tiny bit of Hayward about him, not as productive though

 

[Danger in Texas]

There are a few decent half backs - coffield Garner naish hunter Clarke and Ling is dynamic

Coffield jumped right into my top 10 after that performance. So classy. Naish disappointed a little after last week. Ling is raw, but absolutely had the tools.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Dow has a bit of Rory Sloane tenacity , you reckon he's classy ? I like him but he's not overly polished with his kicking . I'd take him in a heartbeat though

Seems to kick better when he's in space. Very classy in the guts though, has great awareness and runs a 2.91 20m. Has a little bit of Parish about him, I reckon

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Yep Petty and Kreuger were the standouts for me today. Reckon Kreuger has oodles of potential as a mobile 3rd tall type.

What makes you say Houlahan is introverted? Has a tiny bit of Hayward about him, not as productive though

He doesn't seem to have much fire in the belly or swagger for someone so talented

Doesn't seem to connect with his teammates from a far , doesn't have any alpha male presence

He's got something so gets drafted but should or could be the best prospect from SA but isn't - yet

 

[Danger in Texas]

De Koenig is an enigma - has some talent ; he's ordinary in the air though , but of JJ about his marking contests

Lachie Fogarty goes ok, you called it on constable - he's a top 5 player

Cerra has some class and courage , prob doesn't quite do enough considering

I reckon it's Rayner , LDU and then maybe Constable TBH

Constable is a jet. Great clearance player and good skills. Only knock for me is pace.

Cerra probably needs to lift his production, but he's very much a complete mid - if he can lift his numbers for the final match and continue to do well at TAC level, he's absolutely top 5 I reckon.

L Fogarty and Higgins will go 10-20. Would go higher if they were 5cm taller. Still think Higgins is Greene 2.0

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Seems to kick better when he's in space. Very classy in the guts though, has great awareness and runs a 2.91 20m. Has a little bit of Parish about him, I reckon

One of the more competitive guys out there today in either game

That's why reminded me of Sloane , scraps hard like Sloane or Viney

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Constable is a jet. Great clearance player and good skills. Only knock for me is pace.

Cerra probably needs to lift his production, but he's very much a complete mid - if he can lift his numbers for the final match and continue to do well at TAC level, he's absolutely top 5 I reckon.

L Fogarty and Higgins will go 10-20. Would go higher if they were 5cm taller. Still think Higgins is Greene 2.0

Higgins is elite for that type no doubt

Smoky for top 10 as you know you're getting a guaranteed player

L Fogarty would be a great get in 2nd round if still there

 

[Danger in Texas]

He doesn't seem to have much fire in the belly or swagger for someone so talented

Doesn't seem to connect with his teammates from a far , doesn't have any alpha male presence

He's got something so gets drafted but should or could be the best prospect from SA but isn't - yet

Yeah that's a fair point, a lot of these juniors do take time to realise their talent however. That's why the confident players always go high, it's a rarity, and a good rarity

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Constable is a jet. Great clearance player and good skills. Only knock for me is pace.

Cerra probably needs to lift his production, but he's very much a complete mid - if he can lift his numbers for the final match and continue to do well at TAC level, he's absolutely top 5 I reckon.

L Fogarty and Higgins will go 10-20. Would go higher if they were 5cm taller. Still think Higgins is Greene 2.0

There was a handball in a centre bounce that Constable gave at 45 deg angle that was top shelf , lack of pace won't matter because of his size and ball winning ability

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Giro was found out today IMO

 

[Danger in Texas]

One of the more competitive guys out there today in either game

That's why reminded me of Sloane , scraps hard like Sloane or Viney

Got better speed and more penetrating kicking in space than Sloane/Viney IMO, you're right that he's competitive though. In/out mid