List Mgmt. 2017 Draft - Pick 10 - Poll Added

[Funk]

Watch the all star game from grand final day and tell me he isnt worth pick 10!! Plus the professionalism he has shown coming back from the knee injury! Just remember they said Judd's shoulders were shot!! Selwood's knee was shot!! Don't let injuries scare you off

I haven't seen that game but it's his composure/skills that look shaky to my eye - not his knee.

 

[Jorge]

With SPS & Dow in as well the likelihood of having a top 4 pick again next year, I doubt SOS will be looking hard for x factor here. He should pick the kid he's most confident will make it.

 

[ClaudeClavi]

Dow and LOB look like they're best mates. Would be a nice story, especially after LOB spent his AIS time with us.

Brent Daniels is very close with Dow too, could be a Vic C trio! Daniels at 30 is a bit of a reach though IMO

They have also all played together at Geelong Grammar for at least 2 years. Elite team chem

 

[Omega Blue]

If Stephenson is available at 10 we have to take him, Kyle Chalmers (Olympic swimmer) has a similar heart condition I believe, he's still an elite athlete

 

[therubbernub]

Do do still think I'm lying?

So Its
1 carlton
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

 

[rog1995]

Constable, Kennedy, Cripps all on the ground means we’ll be as slow as a treacle.

Dow and LOB = breakaway pace from packs and pace to create spread which is sorely lacking in this team. We’re currently one dimentional and need to get midfielders with characteristics that can compliment the team.

Logical & balanced post.

 

[TooBlue14]

They have also all played together at Geelong Grammar for at least 2 years. Elite team chem

This will be a common occurance too after going Fisher and SPS last year together who played a whole lot of footy together in WA.

 

[My name geoff]

Constable, Kennedy, Cripps all on the ground means we’ll be as slow as a treacle.

Dow and LOB = breakaway pace from packs and pace to create spread which is sorely lacking in this team. We’re currently one dimentional and need to get midfielders with characteristics that can compliment the team.

Pick 3 > Dow
Pick 10 > O'Brien
Pick 30 > Kelly

Rookie > Shaw

Plowman(23) Jones(27) Byrne(23)
Mullett(26) Marchy(22) Weitering(20)
SPS(20) Cripps(23) O'Brien(19)
Pickett(22) Casboult(28) Curnow(22)
Fisher(20) Mckay(20) Kelly(24)

Kruezer(29) Murphy(31) Kennedy(21)

Cuningham(21) Ed(28) Silvagni(20) Dow(19)


Emerg: Williamson(19) Polson(20)

Highlighted are players with line breaking pace. Looks a pretty damn quick lineup we are building.

Compared to our rd 1 lineup last season..

Plowman Weitering Simpson
Macreadie Rowe Marchbank
Docherty Gibbs Pickett
Armfield Casboult Wright
Curnow Silvagni Thomas

Kruezer Cripps Murphy

Smedts White Curnow SPS

 

[thylacine60]

Logical & balanced post.

not the sort of language we expect to read on this site - might want to take a good look at yourself.........

 

[Mr_Plow]

 

[J-dog]

Take away the FACT that we know Boekhurst stuggles with the body contact at AFL level and we don't yet know with LOB, but does LOB do anything better than Boekhurst? I've not seen any highlights of LOB, I'm just following descriptions of his style of play...and it sounds Boekhurst like..

Watch this and then tell me if you think it's Boekhurst mk II or not.

 

[Anzac16]

Bit of talk about Stephenson to the Pies @ 6. Fogarty might slip past the Saints but can't see the Dogs passing him up to be honest. I still get the feeling O'Brien is SOS's man at 10.

 

[J-dog]

The kid's a gun and very determined. He won't shirk a contest unnecessarily.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Stephenson/Higgins/Clarke/O’Brien.

Any of them will do me.

 

[Robbo's my hero]

Watch this and then tell me if you think it's Boekhurst mk II or not.

I can’t see a similarity to B.B. Lovely balance, excellent skills, hits targets and has a nice step. I’m thinking LOB is a different class of footballer.

 

[Pinnell]

Constable, Kennedy, Cripps all on the ground means we’ll be as slow as a treacle.

Dow and LOB = breakaway pace from packs and pace to create spread which is sorely lacking in this team. We’re currently one dimentional and need to get midfielders with characteristics that can compliment the team.

Whose to say that constable doesn't turn out to be a better player than Kennedy? I remember we overlooked Andrew swallow when he was available in the 3rd round years ago because we had another similar player on our list - Adam bentick. That turned out well..
If constable slides to 30 we would be mad not to take him

 

[JuddgementDay]

#3 dow
#10 d.fogarty

 

[Sharks On A Plane]

If O'Brien has even an ounce of mongrel in him he will be a gun at AFL level. If we pick him, I trust that SOS did his due diligence re: the first criterion.

 

[Soapy V]

If O'Brien has even an ounce of mongrel in him he will be a gun at AFL level. If we pick him, I trust that SOS did his due diligence re: the first criterion.

He does.

 

[smashbox gill]

If O'Brien has even an ounce of mongrel in him he will be a gun at AFL level. If we pick him, I trust that SOS did his due diligence re: the first criterion.

He's identified its a weakness of his and he will work on it. I think he will be a gun

 

[Sharks On A Plane]

He does.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

DFog available again?

 

[teagueyubeauty]

Why not Fog? Clearly weren’t that into him

 

[LanceRomance]

Welcome Lobba

 

[Mr_Plow]

Fog is an overgrown flanker, not a need.