List Mgmt. 2017 Draft Prospects

[goodcop badcop]

What do you think about Joel Garners kicking?

I admit that I'm very iffy on the guy

What I saw of him last year was a very reliable kick, but I'm starting to think it's not that good now. Whatever highlights I've seen of him this year, he barely hits a target. It wasn't that great today as well. Too often he over cooks it on the run.

 

[goodcop badcop]

Yeah, that was me, I see quite a lot about Hodge in Garner, even though I'm certain he won't hit the heights that Hodge did. That hit backs it up, in a less positive way.

I think it's a fair comparison

 

[goodcop badcop]

Watched all 3 games at Ballarat today, may have been seeing things after the 2nd game . Just a brief write up of who liked and disliked

Liked

Kane Farrell - BOG for Bendigo.

Darby Henderson - Half back/winger. Showed a bit of class & speed

Brent Daniels - Broke the game open at times. Tried hard. Bit small though

Jordan Johnston - Exciting player. Lloyd was BOG but he was next best IMO

Aiden Domic - Very good, just needs to finish off his work

Flynn Appleby - Mini Dale Morris. Gave Brander a bath despite the massive height difference. Provided some rebound as well

Jaidyn Stephenson - Easily the ranges best IMO. Felt like he had 30 possies in the midfield

Sam Hayes - Around the ground work was good. Better if he could hit the scoreboard

Dylan Moore - Usual good game from him. Consistent

Ryley Stoddart - Impressed with his run from defence and his long kicking. Some poor defensive efforts though

Harrison Nolan - Does a lot of the 1% and helped out his team mates. Good on the intercept and just a good tall defender

Ed Richards - BOG for chargers. Silk

Jack Higgins - Was solid, kicked two but didn't have a big impact. Good forward pressure

Charlie Thompson - See Higgins

Toby Woller - Good. Kicked 3, marked well and had a fair bit of it. Doesn't seem overly threatening for a tall forward though

Matthew Day - Something good happened when he had it. Does need to find more of it

Jack Petruccelle - Close to the knights best . Some of the stuff he does is so wow. Still needs to tidy things up and was quieter towards the end of the game

Ethan Penrith - Outstanding pressure. Did need to get more involved more

Federico - Keeps racking up good numbers

Hamish Brayshaw - BOG. Showed a bit as a forward with 5 goals, his marking has improved

Andrew Brayshaw - Very good on the inside and kicked a goal

Nathan Murphy - Seemed to be switched around a bit and had an impact wherever he played

Charlie Constable - Good game. Kicked a goal, not a big impact though

Will Walker - Had a couple good clearances, where he was able to speed away from the contest. Impressive


Disliked

Lachie O'Brien - Was ok, he just didn't do enough when his team needed him. Fails to get his hands dirty and did his best work in junk time. Disappointing

Jarrod Brander - Got towelled up by a very good but much smaller defender in Appleby. Rubbish

Angus Schumacher - Just has to get in the game more

Loyd Meek - Not a great day for talls, but didn't like his marking and had little impact in general. Had the better of his opponent though

Callen Wellings - Good, but can't kick. Pass

Joel Garner - A day to forget. Had some good battles with Higgins I guess

Nic Coffield - Had some attention in periods but didn't look to be a hard tag. Was shown up in the midfield, looks so much more comfortable down back

Patrick Naish - Meh. Too soft Richmond can have him

Angus Styles - Not liking his ball use off half back

Hayden McLean - Tries hard and I thought he went ok. Should be doing more with his size

 

[CaptainMurphy]

What's everyone's thoughts on Brander? Starting to think he'll be there at 9.

 

[LittleG]

What's everyone's thoughts on Brander? Starting to think he'll be there at 9.

Don't want. IMO Not worth a top ten pick.

 

[murphy2bedabest]

Thoughts on Alex boyse? 190cm 3rd. Tall forward, skinny about 83kg but seems to have a good tank

 

[Dav1d]

Don't want. IMO Not worth a top ten pick.

I hope for our sake that the clubs selecting above feel differently

Penrith is someone that I can see us liking, later in the draft.

 

[CaptainMurphy]

I hope for our sake that the clubs selecting above feel differently

Penrith is someone that I can see us liking, later in the draft.

Carlton Next Gen Academy player if I recall correctly

 

[Pugz89]

Lloyd Meek named in the TAC team of the year, Higgins picks up the Morrish Medal.

 

[Dav1d]

Carlton Next Gen Academy player if I recall correctly

well damn, I think they should take him

he'd suit them nicely to.

 

[Wizard17]

TAC TEAM OF THE YEAR


B - Paton - Podhajski - Garner
HB - Clark - Clavarino - Coffield
C - Fogarty - Worpel - Naish
HF - J.Stephenson - Balta - Davies-Uniacke
FF - Miers - Rayner - Higgins
OB - Hayes - Cerra - Dow

INT - Constable - Handley - Porter - Meek - Parish - Moore

--------------------------------------

Bushrangers Full Forward Daniel Johnston wins the Goal kicking with 45 majors.

-----------------------------------------

Jack Roughsedge wins the personal growth award.

-------------------------------------------

Top 5 Morrish Medal

22 - Jack Higgins
20 - Brad Bernacki
15 - Gryan Miers
15 - Hamish Brayshaw
14 - Sam Hayes

 

[Dav1d]

Crazy how of the players played Champs

Insane forward line.

 

[Wizard17]

Crazy how of the players played Champs

Insane forward line.

Be stronger if Porter /Handley/Moore where in LDU's spot

Surprised to not see Porter in the top 5 for the Morish Medal.

Always thought Bernacki would give Higgkns a run for his money.

 

[Freezin]

Sam Taylor 196cm tall defender had a standout game for Swan Districts league side yesterday in their elimination final win v West Perth. Only his 3rd or 4th senior game from memory...always telling of a players character,temperament and ability when they can step up and perform in big games. Seems to be lost in Aaron Naughtons shadow from Peel, but just as good, taller and one hopefully the WBD have a look at come draft day.

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Could Jack Higgins become a high level small forward like we want? Or will he just spend some time there with a plan to move into the midfield? Doesn't interest me too much as a mid but as a small forward maybe? I've heard Toby Greene comparisons.

 

[CaptainMurphy]

And how about a trade with Richmond, pick 9 for their's and Geelong's first rounders? I know the consensus seems to be that last time we did this (with Carlton) it was a mistake because we missed out on Curnow, but this draft really feels like a clear top 4 and then really even after that. Richmond could be keen to do it since a bid for Naish might come mid first round and this way they get to trade up for someone they like and still get Naish with a later pick. The only risk for us is if a Dow/Cerra/LDU/Rayner slides and we could have had them.

 

[Pugz89]

Had a chat to Meek Lloyd (As listed in the bests from Saturday's game) this morning. Disappointing season for the Rebels but he is one of a few positives to come out of the year.

Check it out if you're keen.

http://www.araratadvertiser.com.au/story/4898516/tac-cup-honours/

 

[Gollo]

TAC TEAM OF THE YEAR


B - Paton - Podhajski - Garner
HB - Clark - Clavarino - Coffield
C - Fogarty - Worpel - Naish
HF - J.Stephenson - Balta - Davies-Uniacke
FF - Miers - Rayner - Higgins
OB - Hayes - Cerra - Dow

INT - Constable - Handley - Porter - Meek - Parish - Moore

--------------------------------------

Bushrangers Full Forward Daniel Johnston wins the Goal kicking with 45 majors.

-----------------------------------------

Jack Roughsedge wins the personal growth award.

-------------------------------------------

Top 5 Morrish Medal

22 - Jack Higgins
20 - Brad Bernacki
15 - Gryan Miers
15 - Hamish Brayshaw
14 - Sam Hayes

No idea how Dow makes the team from just 3 games. Same with LDU, Rayner, Garner. No way they had the level of performance and consistency in the TAC Cup to warrant a spot.

 

[Dav1d]

No idea how Dow makes the team from just 3 games. Same with LDU, Rayner, Garner. No way they had the level of performance and consistency in the TAC Cup to warrant a spot.

If that is true, you're right

That's absolutely ridiculous

 

[Wizard17]

My top 50 rankings for those who are intetested.

1 - Paddy Dow
2 - Adam Cerra
3 - Cam Rayner
4 - Charlie Constable
5 - Luke Davies-Uniacke
6 - Nick Coffield
7 - Sam Hayes
8 - Jack Higgins
9 - Andrew Brayshaw
10 - Aaron Naughton
11 - Jaidyn Stephenson
12 - Jarrod Brander
13 - Darcy Fogarty
14 - Hunter Clark
15 - Oscar Allen
16 - Joel Garner
17 - Noah Balta
18 - Connor Ballenden
19 - Lachlan Forgarty
20 - Aiden Bonar
21 - Jack Petruccelle
22 - Patrick Naish
23 - Nathan Murphy
24 - Ed Richards
25 - Matthew Ling
26 - Harrison Petty
27 - Zac Bailey
28 - Nathan Kreuger
29 - Jackson Ross
30 - Dylan Moore
31 - Lochie O'Brien
32 - Hugh Dixon
33 - James Worpel
34 - Charlie Spargo
35 - Oscar Clavarino
36 - Andrew McPherson
37 - Callum Coleman-Jones
38 - Gryan Miers
39 - Alex Martini
40 - David Handley
41 - Trent Mynott
42 - Ben Paton
43 - Jordan Houlahan
44 - Toby Wooller
45 - Aiden Domic
46 - Brent Daniels
47 - Jordan Johnston
48 - Jordan Butts
49 - Tom McCartin
50 - Callum Porter

 

[CaptainMurphy]

My top 50 rankings for those who are intetested.

1 - Paddy Dow
2 - Adam Cerra
3 - Cam Rayner
4 - Charlie Constable
5 - Luke Davies-Uniacke
6 - Nick Coffield
7 - Sam Hayes
8 - Jack Higgins
9 - Andrew Brayshaw
10 - Aaron Naughton
11 - Jaidyn Stephenson
12 - Jarrod Brander
13 - Darcy Fogarty
14 - Hunter Clark
15 - Oscar Allen
16 - Joel Garner
17 - Noah Balta
18 - Connor Ballenden
19 - Joel Garner
20 - Lachlan Forgarty
21 - Aiden Bonar
22 - Jack Petruccelle
23 - Patrick Naish
24 - Nathan Murphy
25 - Ed Richards
26 - Matthew Ling
27 - Harrison Petty
28 - Zac Bailey
29 - Nathan Kreuger
30 - Jackson Ross
31 - Dylan Moore
32 - Lochie O'Brien
33 - Hugh Dixon
34 - James Worpel
35 - Charlie Spargo
36 - Oscar Clavarino
37 - Andrew McPherson
38 - Callum Coleman-Jones
39 - Gryan Miers
40 - Alex Martini
41 - David Handley
42 - Trent Mynott
43 - Ben Paton
44 - Jordan Houlahan
45 - Toby Wooller
46 - Aiden Domic
47 - Brent Daniels
48 - Jordan Johnston
49 - Jordan Butts
50 - Tom McCartin

My (definitely less informed) top 48. I had it ready to go so thought I might as well reply with it. I left out academy and father son players.

1 Paddy Dow
2 Cameron Rayner
3 Luke Davies-Uniacke
4 Adam Cerra
5 Jarrod Brander
6 Nick Coffield
7 Jaidyn Stephenson
8 Noah Balta
9 Darcy Fogarty
10 Oscar Allen
11 Hunter Clark
12 Sam Hayes
13 Aaron Naughton
14 Charlie Constable
15 Jack Higgins
16 Lochie O'Brien
17 Matthew Ling
18 Joel Garner
19 Jack Petruccelle
20 Zac Bailey
21 Andrew Brayshaw
22 Aiden Bonar
23 James Worpel
24 Gryan Miers
25 Jordan Houlahan
26 Hugh Dixon
27 Toby Wooller
28 Jackson Ross
29 Harrison Petty
30 Charlie Ballard
31 Nathan Kreuger
32 Callum Coleman-Jones
33 Oscar Clavarino
34 Tom McCartin
35 Charlie Spargo
36 Lachlan Fogarty
37 Nathan Murphy
38 Dylan Moore
39 Ryley Stoddart
40 Sam Taylor
41 Thomas Schmusch
42 Matthew Day
43 Aiden Domic
44 Jordan Butts
45 Charlie Thompson
46 Andrew McPherson
47 Ed Richards
48 Jordan Johnston

 

[Dav1d]

1 Luke Davies-Uniacke
2 Paddy Dow
3 Cameron Rayner
4 Nick Coffield
5 Darcy Fogarty
6 Jaidyn Stephenson
7 Adam Cerra
8 Oscar Allen
9 Sam Hayes
10 Charlie Constable
11 Hunter Clark
12 Aaron Naughton
13 Sam Hayes
14 Jack Petruccelle
15 Joel Garner
16 James Worpel
17 Oscar Clavirino
18 Zac Bailey
19 Matthew Ling
20 Jack Higgins
21 Callum Coleman-Jones
21 Hugh Dixon
22 Noah Balta
23 Toby Wooler
24 Lachlan Fogarty
25 Dylan Moore

 

[Dav1d]

My top 50 rankings for those who are intetested.

1 - Paddy Dow
2 - Adam Cerra
3 - Cam Rayner
4 - Charlie Constable
5 - Luke Davies-Uniacke
6 - Nick Coffield
7 - Sam Hayes
8 - Jack Higgins
9 - Andrew Brayshaw
10 - Aaron Naughton
11 - Jaidyn Stephenson
12 - Jarrod Brander
13 - Darcy Fogarty
14 - Hunter Clark
15 - Oscar Allen
16 - Joel Garner
17 - Noah Balta
18 - Connor Ballenden
19 - Joel Garner
20 - Lachlan Forgarty
21 - Aiden Bonar
22 - Jack Petruccelle
23 - Patrick Naish
24 - Nathan Murphy
25 - Ed Richards
26 - Matthew Ling
27 - Harrison Petty
28 - Zac Bailey
29 - Nathan Kreuger
30 - Jackson Ross
31 - Dylan Moore
32 - Lochie O'Brien
33 - Hugh Dixon
34 - James Worpel
35 - Charlie Spargo
36 - Oscar Clavarino
37 - Andrew McPherson
38 - Callum Coleman-Jones
39 - Gryan Miers
40 - Alex Martini
41 - David Handley
42 - Trent Mynott
43 - Ben Paton
44 - Jordan Houlahan
45 - Toby Wooller
46 - Aiden Domic
47 - Brent Daniels
48 - Jordan Johnston
49 - Jordan Butts
50 - Tom McCartin

Are there two Joel Garners?

You have one at 16 and one at 19

 

[Wizard17]

Are there two Joel Garners?

You have one at 16 and one at 19

I knew I'd do something stupid with headache lol.

Fixed

 

[Dav1d]

I knew I'd do something stupid with headache lol.

Fixed

It always happens, at least it shows clearly where you rate Garner at.

If he was a better kick, I think he'd be fantastic

Tough & versatile.